The Best ETF to Play Oil’s Continuing Volatility

With oil prices falling the most they have in the past month, the obvious play in energy—iShares S&P/TSX Capped Energy Index Fund (TSX:XEG)—has seen its share price decline by almost 2%, leaving investors scratching their heads, wondering what’s the best play.

Investors who made a proxy bet on higher oil prices in 2016 by buying the iShares S&P/TSX Capped Energy Index Fund (TSX:XEG) on December 31, 2015, have been generously rewarded with a 24% year-to-date gain for their unwavering optimism.

Bravo. But don’t get too confident. Volatility in oil prices is expected to remain high as the bulls and bears fight it out for directional supremacy. In hindsight, the easy money is waiting for those who were confident enough to take a calculated risk earlier this year that oil prices had indeed bottomed and a recovery, no matter how slow its progress, was underway.

I couldn’t have made that bet, but many did. The question now is whether or not these same investors can stomach the next leg up. Some will take profits, others will trim positions, while the diehards will hold fast, knowing that ultimately higher energy prices are in the cards.

I’m not clairvoyant, so I honestly can’t help you make a decision on what to do with your XEG holdings. However, what I can do is suggest a better way to play oil’s continuing volatility. All you need to do is exchange one ETF for another. The best part: the ETF I’m recommending will also save you a sliver on your annual management expenses.  It’s not a huge amount, mind you, but it’s something nonetheless.

 Horizons S&P/TSX 60 Equal Weight Index ETF (TSX:HEW) is the fund I believe energy investors can successfully use to hedge their bets in the coming months.

How so?

The iShares S&P/TSX 60 Index Fund (TSX:XIU) is an ETF that tracks the index of the same name. It has 60 holdings, including 13 in the energy sector.  Horizons holds the same 60 stocks, including those in the energy sector.

However, Horizons rebalances four times a year: March, June, September, and December, while the XIU rarely does. This means that every quarter the holdings in the equal-weight version of the S&P/TSX 60 Index are reset to a weighting of approximately 1.66%. This allows for profits to be taken on winners, while losers are able to fight another day.

What does this mean for energy investors? It means you get to maintain your exposure to energy stocks regardless of what happens to the 13 individual stocks that represent the energy sector. Big or small, their performance is of equal value.

For example, Suncor Energy Inc. (TSX:SU)(NYSE:SU) currently is the fifth-largest holding in the XIU at a weighting of 4.27%. In Horizons, it’s not even in the top 25 holdings. That’s because Suncor’s stock hasn’t done much since the June rebalancing compared to other stocks such as Teck Resources Ltd. (TSX:TCK.B)(NYSE:TCK), the number one holding as of August 24 at 2.21%, about 32% higher than at its rebalancing in June.

Theoretically, if all 13 energy stocks in the cap-weighted version of the S&P/TSX 60 Index were to lose half of their value in a quarter, energy stocks would be reduced to about 10% of the index’s portfolio from its current weighting of about 21%. Although I doubt this would ever happen, it points out an obvious weakness in float-adjusted, cap-weighted indexes.

On the other hand, if that were to happen to Horizons, energy stocks would see their weighting rebalanced back to 21.5% (13 times 1.66%) at the end of the quarter in question instead of remaining at 10% like the XIU.

For investors keen on energy stocks but unsure of their near-term direction given oil’s ongoing volatility, you might want to consider Horizons’s equal-weighted version of the S&P/TSX 60. It gives you exposure to energy stocks while reducing the risk associated with the cap-weighted version of the index.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Will Ashworth has no position in any stocks mentioned.

More on Energy Stocks

Arrowings ascending on a chalkboard
Energy Stocks

Beat the TSX With This Cash-Gushing Dividend Stock

Canadian Natural Resources stock is well set up to beat the TSX as it continues to generate strong cash flows…

Read more »

energy industry
Energy Stocks

2 TSX Energy Stocks to Buy Hand Over Fist Now

These two rallying TSX energy stocks can continue delivering robust returns to investors in the long term.

Read more »

green energy
Energy Stocks

1 Magnificent TSX Dividend Stock Down 37% to Buy and Hold Forever

This dividend stock has fallen significantly from poor results, but zoom in and there are some major improvements happening.

Read more »

oil tank at night
Energy Stocks

3 Energy Stocks Already Worth Your While

Here's why blue-chip TSX energy stocks such as Enbridge should be part of your equity portfolio in 2024.

Read more »

Solar panels and windmills
Energy Stocks

1 Beaten-Down Stock That Could Be the Best Bet in the TSX

This renewable energy stock could be one of the best buys you make this year, as the company starts to…

Read more »

Dice engraved with the words buy and sell
Energy Stocks

Is Enbridge Stock a Buy, Sell, or Hold?

Here's why Enbridge (TSX:ENB) remains a top dividend stock long-term investors may want to consider, despite current risks.

Read more »

Gas pipelines
Energy Stocks

If You Had Invested $5,000 in Enbridge Stock in 2018, This Is How Much You Would Have Today

Enbridge's high dividend yield hasn't made up for its dismal total returns.

Read more »

Bad apple with good apples
Energy Stocks

Avoid at All Costs: This Stock Is Portfolio Poison

A mid-cap stock commits to return more to shareholders, but some investors remember the suspension of dividends a few years…

Read more »