Air Canada (TSX:AC) vs. Canadian Tire (TSX:CTC.A): Which Is a Better Buy?

Should you invest in Air Canada (TSX:AC) stock or Canadian Tire (TSX:CTC.A) stock? Which is a better investment for you?

| More on:
Plane on runway, aircraft

Image source: Getty Images.

Both Air Canada (TSX:AC)(TSX:AC.B) and Canadian Tire (TSX:CTC.A) are popular TSX stocks. Which is a better buy today? There’s no quick answer because it depends on your risk tolerance and comfort levels in the investments.

Should you buy Air Canada stock?

Air Canada is a top contrarian stock as a turnaround investment. The coronavirus pandemic will greatly impact the company and other airlines this year. That’s why year to date, Air Canada stock has lost 60% of its value.

Air Canada is the largest provider of scheduled passenger services and cargo services within Canada, between Canada and the U.S., and between Canada and the rest of the world. According to statista, Air Canada has 46% of the domestic market share.

Unfortunately, the pandemic will likely be a big drag on air travel throughout the year. Thankfully, the company has improved its financial position significantly over the years. Its stronger balance sheet should help it to ride through these tough economic times.

Insiders are confident in the business. Thus far this year, seven insiders bought a total of more than $414,000 worth of shares directly from the market. Their average price and median price per share, respectively, are $32.50 and $33.82.

At $19.43 per share at writing, Air Canada stock trades at a 40% discount from the average price. When the economy returns to normal, say, in two to three years, the stock should be able to trade at about $60 for a three-bagger.

Should you buy Canadian Tire stock?

Canadian Tire stock is a Dividend Aristocrat with nine consecutive years of dividend increases. Its 10-year dividend growth rate is 17%. Its payout ratio, which is sustainable, is about 40% of this year’s earnings. The stock starts investors off with a decent yield of nearly 4.8%.

The company tends to buy back shares. In 10 years, it has reduced about 20% of its share count. The buybacks have assisted the retailer to generate relatively stable earnings and high returns on equity.

Its five-year return on equity is more than 14%. Consistent and stable profitability has translated to predictable dividend growth.

Canadian Tire has a long history of operation with roots stretching as far back as 1922. Over the years, Canadian Tire has acquired other banners, including Marks, Sport Chek, and Party City. They cover retailers in work, casual, and active wear, sporting goods, and party supplies and seasonal and celebration, respectively.

The retailer has a solid financial position to weather the pandemic storm. At $95.58 per share, it trades at about 8.5 times this year’s estimated earnings.

When the economy returns to normal, the stock can trade at about $200 to double an investor’s money today. All the while, it’ll pay nice dividend income that’ll add to total returns.

The Foolish bottom line

Air Canada is a higher-risk investment due to its bigger swings in profitability. Canadian Tire is lower risk partly because it pays a dividend.

For long-term investment, Air Canada stock will likely deliver greater returns than Canadian Tire stock — a three-bagger versus a two-bagger. However, the latter offers quarterly dividends that yield close to 4.8%.

Beware that both stocks can trade lower should their quarterly earnings reports in 2020 be worse than expected due to the impacts of COVID-19.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Kay Ng owns shares of AIR CANADA.

More on Dividend Stocks

You Should Know This
Dividend Stocks

How to Convert a $300 Monthly Investment Into $338 in Monthly Income

If you want a certain amount in monthly passive income, invest a similar amount today and leave the rest to…

Read more »

Increasing yield
Dividend Stocks

3 Income Stocks With Big Yields to Consider in April 2024

If you haven’t yet made your March investments, here are three income stocks to buy the dip and lock in…

Read more »

Senior Man Sitting On Sofa At Home With Pet Labrador Dog
Dividend Stocks

RRSP Investors: Don’t Miss Out on This Contribution Hack!

This hack has so many benefits for you -- not just when you put it in your RRSP but for…

Read more »

A red umbrella stands higher than a crowd of black umbrellas.
Dividend Stocks

Passive Income: 2 Safe Dividend Stocks to Own for the Next 10 Years

Dividend stocks such as Manulife and Fortis can help you generate a stable and recurring passive-income stream.

Read more »

Young woman sat at laptop by a window
Dividend Stocks

3 Dividend Stocks Everyone Should Own for the Long Haul

For investors looking for top-tier dividend stocks to buy and hold for the long term, here are three of my…

Read more »

Payday ringed on a calendar
Dividend Stocks

3 Dividend Stocks That Pay Me More Than $54.57 Per Month

These three dividend stocks have done me well over the years, so let's look at how much I've gotten in…

Read more »

Golden crown on a red velvet background
Dividend Stocks

Dividend Royalty: 3 Fabulous Stocks to Buy Now for Decades of Passive Income

Rogers Communications stock and Canadian Natural Resources stock could pay you dividends for decades to come.

Read more »

Dividend Stocks

The Top Canadian REITs to Buy in April 2024

For growth and dividends this April, look to these two REITs that have quite the promising present as well as…

Read more »