These 3 TSX Stocks Did it Better Than Most in 2015

Capital allocation is a skill most CEOs haven’t grasped, but three TSX companies, including Gran Tierra Energy Inc. (TSX:GTE)(NYSE:GTE), did a great job buying back stock in 2015. Here’s why.

The Motley Fool

Return to shareholders.

These three simple words drive investors crazy. If I had a dollar for every time a company mentioned these words in their financial reports, I’d be a very wealthy man indeed. Whether through dividends or share repurchases, investors can’t seem to get enough of either capital allocation carrot.

Dividends I get. If a company has been paying out part of its annual earnings for 50 years, why stop now when its shareholders, like drug addicts, need a fix now and again, preferably one that’s bigger each and every time? Besides, it’s hard to deny the success of dividend investing over the long haul. When done properly, it actually works.

Share repurchases, on the other hand, have a much spottier record of delivering results for companies large and small. In 2014 Reuters looked at more than 3,000 publicly traded U.S. companies, all non-financial in nature, and they found that more dollars were paid out for dividends and share repurchases that year than the combined net income of those same companies. It was the first time in history for this to happen outside periods of recession.

The other big problem with share repurchases, other than the fact that this allocation robs a company of its innovation and growth, is the simple truth that many companies do a miserable job buying back their stock by overpaying.

To evaluate a company’s success or failure when it comes to buybacks, I use a simple process that compares the average price paid in a fiscal year to the average trading price (the midway point between its high and low) in that same year. If it manages to pay less than the midway point, it’s doing a good job buying back its shares; if it pays more, it’s doing a bad job.

So, which stocks did better than most in 2015?

Rather than analyze all 238 stocks in the TSX Composite Index in 2015, I took a shortcut by examining the top 10 stocks in the S&P/TSX Composite Buyback Index, a group of 50 stocks with the highest buyback ratios in the TSX itself. Those in the top 10 had the highest ratios, which are calculated by dividing the dollar value of share repurchases in a given year by a company by the market cap of its stock at the beginning of the year in question.

Here’s what I found out.

In 2015 Gran Tierra Energy Inc. (TSX: GTE)(NYSE:GTE) managed to do the best job of the top 10 when it comes to buying buy back its stock. It paid $2.19 per share, 24.7% less than the midway point of its high ($3.95) and its low ($1.87). No one came close to that.

The top 10 runner-up was Methanex Corporation (TSX: MX)(NASDAQ: MEOH), which managed to pay $49.65 in 2015 to repurchase its shares, 15.2% below the midway point between its high of $74.43 and its low of $42.60. Anytime you can deliver double digits from this metric, you’re doing well.

The third spot belongs to business intelligence provider Avigilon Corp. (TSX:AVO), which managed to buy back its stock in 2015 for $16.11 per share, 12.5% less than its high-low midway point of $18.41.

Who didn’t perform so well?

Auto parts distributor Uni Select Inc. (TSX: UNS) was the least effective of the top 10, paying $50.83 per share in 2015, 11.4% more than its high-low midway point of $56.63.

So, how did your favourite stock do in 2015?

Fool contributor Will Ashworth has no position in any stocks mentioned. Avigilon is a recommendation of Stock Advisor Canada.

More on Investing

Rocket lift off through the clouds
Tech Stocks

MDA Space Stock: Big Opportunities, but What Should Investors Pay?

MDA’s backlog gives investors work to follow. The share price asks how much of that work will turn into profit…

Read more »

ETF stands for Exchange Traded Fund
Dividend Stocks

Best Canadian Dividend ETF for Passive Income: My Top Pick

Discover why VDY is my top Canadian dividend ETF for passive income, with low fees, tax-efficient dividends, monthly payouts, and…

Read more »

Two seniors walk in the forest
Energy Stocks

A 3.9% Dividend Stock That Will Pay You Through Your Retirement Years

Retirees might buy this dividend stock gradually on market pullbacks, as a part of a diversified retirement portfolio.

Read more »

c
Stocks for Beginners

Canadian National vs. Waste Connections: Which Stock Would I Hold for Steadier Growth?

Waste Connections has the steadier demand story for me. Canadian National offers a lower price relative to earnings and a…

Read more »

tsx today
Stock Market

TSX Today: What to Watch for in Stocks on Friday, November 20

TSX investors will closely watch falling commodity prices today, while escalating U.S.-Iran tensions, Canada-U.S. trade negotiations, and major telecom takeover…

Read more »

how to save money
Energy Stocks

Want $12,000 a Year in Dividends? Here’s the Capital the Goal Requires

A $12,000 dividend target can look more manageable once you see the required balance and how much monthly deposits can…

Read more »

investor looks at volatility chart
Dividend Stocks

2 Discounted TSX Dividend Stocks That Could Rebound in 2027

Two TSX dividend stocks currently trading at deep discounts are well-positioned to stage a strong rebound in 2027.

Read more »

people sit in two wooden beach chairs facing the Caribbean ocean holding drinks and making a toast
Dividend Stocks

How to Build $5,000 in Tax-Free Passive Income in Your TFSA

Building $5,000 in tax-free Income in your TFSA over time is possible with the right portfolio mix and reinvestment of…

Read more »