Activist Investor Kicks Hudson’s Bay Co. Stock into Gear But Is it Enough?

Hudson’s Bay Co. (TSX:HBC) stock jumped 15% June 19 on news that an activist investor is pushing the retailer to monetize real estate. Will management act?

| More on:
You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s premium investing services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn more

Any time a stock pops 15% and you own it, you’ve got to be happy, especially if it’s Hudson’s Bay Co. (TSX:HBC), whose share price traded near $30 two years ago.

The department store consolidator has excellent real estate, and that’s what’s got Connecticut-based activist investor Land & Buildings Investment Management, who own 4.3% of Hudson’s Bay’s stock, publicly pleading with Hudson’s Bay’s board to consider all strategic alternatives available to monetize its valuable properties.

The question isn’t whether or not Hudson’s Bay owns valuable real estate; the question is if Hudson’s Bay management will finally act to unlock some of that value.

While it’s tempting to placate investors, it might not be the best long-term solution for the company. Here’s why.

Unique assets

We’ve heard this argument before.

It’s not new to suggest that assets like its Saks Fifth Avenue store, which is approximately 660,000 square feet of prime New York real estate and worth as much as $5 billion, should be repurposed.

“Hudson’s Bay’s portfolio of assets is truly unique. Consider that the Saks Fifth Avenue store between 49th Street and 50th Street, across from Rockefeller Center … is likely one of the most valuable locations not only in Manhattan, but in the United States,” wrote Land & Buildings in its June 19 letter to the board. “Is the best use of this location truly a department store? What about a hotel? Or office? Or boutique retail stores the likes of Apple and Gucci?”

Executive Chairman Richard Baker is a pretty smart real estate person. I’m sure he’s run the numbers a million times and understands that what Land & Buildings proposed is indeed a value-creation bonanza.

He continues to stay the course. Why might that be?

Is it a real estate company?

Land & Buildings believes Hudson’s Bay is a real estate company. I’m sure Samuel Lord, George Washington Taylor, Andrew Saks, and the Hudson’s Bay directors, who moved the company away from fur trading into retail in the early 1900s, might see things differently.

In the activist investors’ letter to the board, it points to David Simon, CEO of Simon Property Group Inc. (NYSE:SPG), whose company has a joint venture with Hudson’s Bay, as validation of Hudson’s Bay’s real estate.

I don’t disagree.

However, Simon’s company, along with GGP Inc., 35% of which is owned by Brookfield Asset Management Inc., and Authentic Brands Group, acquired teen retailer Aéropostale for $243.3 million out of bankruptcy in September 2016.

Does that make Simon a retailer? By Land & Buildings’s rationale, it does.

Bruce Flatt, CEO of Brookfield, is one of the best asset allocators anywhere in the world. If he doesn’t see a problem owning malls across the U.S., you can be sure brick-and-mortar retail isn’t dead.

As for Richard Baker, an American operating an iconic Canadian business, he understands the value of the Hudson’s Bay brand. If at all possible, I’m sure he’d like to have an operating business that is cash flow positive to go along with its quality real estate.

Avoiding a fire sale

If Hudson’s Bay admits it’s a real estate company and begins selling its various properties in a fire-sale manner, investors can kiss goodbye any chance of extracting value for its retail businesses, thereby putting thousands of people out of work.

As for the real estate, take a look at what’s happened with Sears Holdings Corp. (NASDAQ:SHLD) and its spin-off, Seritage Growth Properties (NYSE:SRG).

Yes, Eddie Lampert has extracted some value out of Sears’s properties, but with 60% of Seritage’s rent coming from Sears, a collapse of the retailer could be devastating to the real estate company, thereby defeating the purpose.

If Richard Baker goes down this road, you can be sure Hudson’s Bay faces the same outcome.

Bottom line

Lampert never bothered to address Sears’s operating business effectively.

Baker still has an opportunity to do so. What he does next could mark the end of Canada’s oldest company to placate an investor with just 4.3% ownership.

To me, that’s short-sighted and misguided.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Will Ashworth has no position in any stocks mentioned. David Gardner owns shares of Apple. The Motley Fool owns shares of Apple and BROOKFIELD ASSET MANAGEMENT INC. CL.A LV.

More on Investing

calculate and analyze stock
Investing

Market Correction: 3 Dirt-Cheap Dividend Stocks to Buy Now

Investors traversing this market correction may want to snatch up cheap dividend stocks like Emera Inc. (TSX:EMA) to start the…

Read more »

data analyze research
Energy Stocks

Market Correction: 2 Dividend Stocks to Hold for Dear Life

These two top defensive dividend stocks could provide you with a degree of protection through the current market downturn.

Read more »

Dividend Stocks

TFSA Passive Income: 3 Undervalued, High-Yield TSX Dividend Stocks to Buy Now

These top TSX dividend stocks with high yields now look attractive to buy for TFSA passive income.

Read more »

Growing plant shoots on coins
Investing

Got $500? 3 Ridiculously Cheap Growth Stocks That Could Help You Retire Rich

These three growth stocks are hard to ignore at today’s prices. With just $500, investors can own all three companies…

Read more »

Electricity high voltage pole and sky
Dividend Stocks

2 High-Dividend TSX Utilities Stocks to Buy Today

The TSX utility sector has some great high-yield stocks to buy.

Read more »

A close up image of Canadian $20 Dollar bills
Investing

Canadians: A Top Passive Investment for Big Passive Income

BMO Canadian High Dividend Covered Call ETF (TSX:ZWC) is a top passive-income play for Canadians to buy on recent weakness.

Read more »

Retirement plan
Dividend Stocks

Retirement Planning: Now Is the Time to Buy Dividend Stocks

2022 could be a great time to buy quality dividend stocks at attractive discounts. Prioritize your capital allocation now.

Read more »

Payday ringed on a calendar
Dividend Stocks

How to Convert $500 Monthly Investment Into $200 Monthly Income

If you want the stock market to give you regular monthly income, you have to invest in the stock market…

Read more »