Deal-Busters: 3 ETF Flaws Investors Must Know

ETFs offer instant diversification to mitigate market risks but have characteristics that could turn investors away.

Many investors, old and new, see the benefits of investing in exchange-traded funds (ETFs). The key takeaway is instant diversification or low-cost access to a variety of assets, industries, or sectors. However, investors must fully understand beforehand the rudiments of ETF investing to avoid surprises.

Passive or laid-back investors usually prefer ETFs because it eliminates the hassle of picking individual stocks. It also doesn’t require extensive evaluation. Fund supporters say the built-in diversification is the distinct advantage. A better performing stock in the portfolio can offset a poor performer.

Still, there are ETF characteristics that don’t sit well with some investors or are deal-busters.

1. Not immune from market volatility

Diversification is the main selling point of ETFs. Unfortunately, the fund isn’t immune to market volatility even with multiple underlying positions. There could be wild spikes and dips depending on the scope of the ETF. One tip to mitigate the risk is to pick a fund that tracks a broad market index, not a sector or industry.

The advice is to know first what the ETF is tracking and be aware of the underlying risks. Like with individual stocks, ETFs have strengths and weaknesses, and therefore, the funds are not the same.

2. No control on investment

ETFs are excellent investment vehicles, although the lack of investor control over the holdings in the fund is a limitation. You can’t avoid a company or sector you dislike in the underlying index. In such a situation, prospective investors revert to individual stocks.

3. Lack of trading interest

ETFs trade like regular stocks but there’s no certainty you can sell the asset if you need to liquidate. The lack of trading interest could be a material issue to investors. You can get stuck with ETF if it’s thinly traded or there are no ready takers. It would help to review the historical returns or study the market movements before taking a position.

ETF comparison

For purposes of illustration, let us compare two ETFs with the same asset manager. BlackRock manages iShares S&P/TSX Composite High Dividend Index ETF (TSX: XEI) and iShares S&P/TSX Capped Information Technology Index ETF (TSX: XIT).

XEI replicates, to the extent possible, the performance of the S&P/TSX Composite High Dividend Index. The fund is a long-term foundational holding and pays monthly dividend income. At $27.17 per share, the annual yield is 3.67%. There are 76 holdings, composed mostly of dividend-paying Canada stocks. The technology and consumer staple sectors have zero representation.

XIT’s target exposure are Canada’s information technology companies. The ETF’s investment objective is to deliver long-term growth by replicating the performance of the S&P/TSX Capped Information Technology Index. There are 24 holdings with a higher weight on application software companies (54.16%).

If you’re choosing between the two ETFs, look at the risk ratings. XEI is medium, while XIT is medium to high. Performance-wise, XEI’s total return in 3.01 years is 54.53% (15.57% CAGR) compared with XIT’s 121.8% (30.32% CAGR). The tech-heavy ETF has the upper-hand if you’re a growth investor. However, income investors will favour the dividend-paying fund.

Make sound decisions

Whether you invest in funds or stocks, the rule is to make sound investment decisions. While ETFs offer diversification, the pre-requisite is to check the risk rating before investing to be safe.   

Fool contributor Christopher Liew has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned.

More on Dividend Stocks

customer fills up car with gasoline
Dividend Stocks

How Much Emergency Money Do Canadians Actually Need?

A safety fund equivalent to 3 to 6 months of living expenses is generally the baseline buffer that Canadians would…

Read more »

woman holding steering wheel is nervous about the future
Dividend Stocks

Still Up Double Digits This Year: Should You Still Invest in TSX Stocks After Thursday’s Dramatic Drop?

The TSX has gained about 136% over the past decade. So, stay invested, dollar‑cost average, and maintain diversification. 

Read more »

Real estate investment concept
Dividend Stocks

Intact Stock: Would I Buy It for Growth, Income, or Both?

Intact’s modest yield makes profitable long-term growth the main attraction, with catastrophe losses putting the next purchase to a test.

Read more »

hiker with backpack in the mountains
Dividend Stocks

2 Top Canadian Dividend Stocks for $1,850 in Annual Passive Income

With reliable cash flows, high dividend yields, and strong growth prospects, these two Canadian stocks suit income-seeking investors.

Read more »

Data center woman holding laptop
Dividend Stocks

3 Canadian Data Centre Stocks to Buy Now, Ranked

Three Canadian stocks offer strategic exposure to the AI buildout and in-demand data centres.

Read more »

people sit in two wooden beach chairs facing the Caribbean ocean holding drinks and making a toast
Dividend Stocks

Is Manulife Worth Buying for Its Dividend for Retirement Income?

Manulife Financial (TSX:MFC) stock looks like a bargain buy for retirees seeking strong, growing dividends.

Read more »

diversification and asset allocation are crucial investing concepts
Dividend Stocks

How I’d Use $500 a Month to Build a Dividend Portfolio Before Retirement

A $500 monthly habit can build retirement income through contributions, reinvestment, and businesses that keep cash after their payouts.

Read more »

Colored pins on calendar showing a month
Dividend Stocks

CT REIT vs. SmartCentres: Which Monthly Payer Fits a TFSA Better?

CT REIT offers a larger payout cushion, while SmartCentres produces more monthly cash from the same investment.

Read more »