Yield vs Returns: Why You Shouldn’t Prioritize Dividends That Much

The Toronto-Dominion Bank (TSX:TD) has a high yield, but most of its return has come from capital gains.

Key Points
  • Many investors hope to get lots of dividends from their investments, but the preference isn't necessarily rational.
  • Historically, more wealth has been earned through capital gains than through dividends.
  • TD Bank had a near-6% return at the start of this year; still, it gave investors far more through buybacks and capital gains.

Passive income.

High yields.

Consistent dividends.

The terms above describe common investment goals, particularly for older and retired Canadians. Such investors want to get dividend income from their investments, because dividends are seen as more “reliable” than capital gains. That perception is probably true to an extent. Most companies pay the same dividend for an entire year, while stock prices swing around violently in mere days.

Despite this, the relationship between dividends and total returns is not clear. Research finds that high yields do not predict high total returns, while dividend growth does predict outperformance. So, the mere fact of a stock paying a dividend doesn’t mean it’s going to give a high return. It’s dividend growth – or the fundamental performance powering dividend growth – that matters.

It’s easy to think of cases where ‘needing’ dividends would have deprived investors of excellent returns; for example, Berkshire Hathaway since 1965, or Alphabet/Google from its IPO until last year. Both of these stocks delivered excellent returns in the time periods specified, despite not paying dividends. Why is this the case?

Person holds banknotes of Canadian dollars

Source: Getty Images

Dividend irrelevance theory

There is actually quite a bit of academic research attempting to explain the contribution of dividends to total returns. Some theories posit that dividends correlate positively with returns, but the most popular theory holds that dividends are immaterial. This theory is called the dividend irrelevance theory. According to this theory, stock prices reflect underlying intrinsic value at all times, so if a stock pays a dividend, its stock price will simply decline by the amount of the dividend when it is paid (or rather, declared).

This theory makes some sense. Stocks are bits of companies, and the more a company invests back into itself, the more it should be worth – at least if the investments it makes are good ones.

Still, questions can be asked about whether a company’s stock should reflect its underlying value. If a stock never pays a dividend, then how do minority shareholders access the underlying assets? It’s a question worth asking. So, let’s explore how companies can put their wealth back into shareholders’ hands.

The magic of buybacks

Buybacks is one way companies can deliver value to shareholders, without paying dividends. If management thinks its stock is undervalued, it can buy back it back until intrinsic value is achieved. Buying stock creates demand, so buybacks tend to increase stock prices. A buyback is therefore one mechanism by which corporate fundamentals influence stock prices.

The expectation of future dividends and buybacks is another one. If investors think that a company is going to do a buyback in the future, they may hold the company’s stock in anticipation of the payout. If they are right, then they’ll likely get a capital gain in the future.

The power of dividends and buybacks illustrated

A great stock for illustrating the comparative value of dividends and buybacks is The Toronto-Dominion Bank (TSX: TD). Year to date, the bank has paid out $7.5 billion worth of dividends and completed $15 billion worth of buybacks. TD stock was pretty cheap at the beginning of the year, having a near-6% yield at that time. An investor who bought the stock back in January would have earned a lot in dividends. However, they’d have gotten far more in capital gains.

As you can see in the image below, TD stock has risen 67% in price so far this year. It has also delivered a 73% total return with dividends re-invested. The vast majority of the year’s return was from capital gains, not dividends. And since TD’s buyback was more than 10% of the beginning-of-year market cap, said buyback was probably a big influence on the capital gain.

The lesson here is obvious: dividends aren’t everything. Even in high yield stocks like TD, capital gains usually deliver the majority of the return. So, don’t sweat the yield too much. There are more important things to think about.

Fool contributor Andrew Button has positions in Toronto-Dominion Bank, Alphabet, and Berkshire Hathaway. The Motley Fool recommends Alphabet and Berkshire Hathaway. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Bank Stocks

data analyze research
Stocks for Beginners

TD’s Dividend Is Only Half the Investment Case: Here’s the Recovery Math

TD’s dividend pays you while you wait. The bigger payoff depends on how much more the bank can earn from…

Read more »

traders work at stock exchange
Stocks for Beginners

Canadian Bank Stocks: Buy, Sell, or Hold for 2027?

Explore the Big Six, their latest earnings and dividend yields, with income and defensive picks.

Read more »

A worker uses a double monitor computer screen in an office.
Bank Stocks

Canadian Bank Stocks in Late 2026: Which to Buy and Which to Skip

Canada’s banking sector is a bedrock of stability but a Big Bank stock stands out if you’re investing before 2026…

Read more »

The RRSP (Canadian Registered Retirement Savings Plan) is a smart way to save and invest for the future
Bank Stocks

Maxing Out Your TFSA Is Just the Beginning: Here’s What to Do Next

Maxing out your TFSA is not only a financial achievement but also the beginning of the next phase of your…

Read more »

pig shows concept of sustainable investing
Stocks for Beginners

How I’d Turn Quarterly Bank Dividends Into a Monthly Paycheque

Quarterly bank dividends can fund regular monthly transfers without choosing stocks for payment dates.

Read more »

dividend growth for passive income
Bank Stocks

How Much to Invest in TD Bank Stock for $5,000 a Year in Dividends

TD Bank (TSX:TD) stock has been so resilient lately and it's a massive shareholder-friendly dividend giant worth buying up.

Read more »

Group of people in a line at an ATM waiting to make a cash withdrawal
Stocks for Beginners

Scotiabank vs. BMO: Which Bank Would I Choose for Retirement Income?

Scotiabank gets my retirement-income preference, while BMO offers a lower adjusted payout ratio and U.S. recovery potential.

Read more »

Happy golf player walks the course
Stocks for Beginners

The TFSA Investment Strategy I’d Use to Build a Retirement Paycheque

This TFSA investment strategy combines global growth, bonds, and dividend income to help build a reliable retirement paycheque.

Read more »