Is Alberta’s ‘Bitumen Bubble’ About to Re-emerge?

Alberta’s finance minister says one thing. This Fool thinks another.

| More on:
The Motley Fool

By:  Robert Baillieul

Is Alberta’s ‘bitumen bubble’ about to re-emerge? Doug Horner, Alberta’s Minister of Finance, warned that the discount for oil sands crude is likely to increase when he told the press on Friday, “Our bitumen bubble has taken a bit of a holiday. But we’re pretty certain that, like a bad penny, it’s going to return.”

With the province projecting a growing discount for Alberta oil, should investors be concerned as well?

Another bitumen bubble unlikely…

There’s been a lot of focus on the difference between the price of Western Canadian Select and West Texas Intermediate; the discount for Alberta bitumen exceeded $40 per barrel last winter. However, as producers find innovative ways to access the marketplace, this spread has narrowed significantly. Investors should expect this trend to continue for a couple of reasons.

First, there’s a lot of new pipe being laid. Enbridge (TSX: ENB, NYSE: ENB), responsible for shipping two-thirds of Western Canada’s crude oil exports, has been quietly expanding capacity. The company has launched a series of initiatives including the reversal of its Line 9 route, eliminating bottlenecks to refineries in the Chicago area, and twinning the Spearhead and Seaway pipeline. Management projects that these efforts will increase export capacity by 1 million barrels per day by mid-2015.

Second, resistance to new pipeline proposals is falling. While TransCanada’s (TSX: TRP, NYSE: TRP) Keystone XL pipeline remains bogged down in political gridlock south of the border, the company is optimistic about its recently proposed Energy East project. If approved, Energy East will ship 1.1 million barrels per day of Alberta crude to refineries on the country’s east coast. And while some analysts are concerned about political pushback from Quebec, Premier Pauline Marois gave some upbeat comments last week about the prospect of shipping bitumen through the province.

We’ve seen similar developments on the west coast. In July, Alberta’s premier Alison Redford and British Columbia’s Christy Clark announced that they would work together to “build new markets and get the highest price possible for the resources owned by the people of our two provinces.” It’s a huge step forward as the two premiers try to resolve differences over bitumen pipelines — and it’s good news for the Enbridge Northern Gateway and the Kinder Morgan Trans Mountain Expansion proposals.

The following table helps provide an indication of some of the legacy pipelines that exist and their respective capacities, as well as the planned pipelines and what they bring to the table.

Chart: Major Existing Crude Oil Pipelines and Proposals Exiting the WCSB

Pipeline Capacity   (000s b/d) Target   In-Service
Enbridge Mainline 2,500 Operating since 1950
Kinder Morgan Trans


300 Operating since 1953
Spectra Express 280 Operating since 1997
TransCanada Keystone


591 Operating since 2010
Enbridge Alberta Clipper



+120 Q3 2014
TransCanada Keystone XL +830 Q4 2015
Enbridge Alberta Clipper



+230 Q1 2016
Trans Mountain Expansion +590 Q4 2017
Enbridge Northern


+525 Q4 2017
TransCanada Energy East 1,100 Q4 2017

Source: CAPP Crude Oil Forecast, Markets & Transportation

and last but not least

The nation’s railways have rushed in to fill the gap in pipeline transit capacity. In the space of two years, the amount of oil shipped by rail in Canada has nearly tripled to almost 300,000 barrels per day. Without new pipeline capacity, that figure will likely continue higher.

With new transit capacity emerging through pipeline and rail, Alberta’s bitumen will find a market and the spread isn’t likely to widen further.


Of course, there’re some obvious roadblocks in this optimistic assessment. Many of the options listed above are still proposals. Northern Gateway and the Trans Mountain Expansion still face a long political battle and it’s still too early to tell how Energy East will play out. Fears of a crude-by-rail slowdown related to July’s Lac-Megantic derailment have also shaken the public’s confidence in rail transit safety. And, surging production from the North Dakota Bakken is outcompeting Canadian producers for pipeline space.

If the bitumen bubble were to re-emerge, it would be non-integrated names like Canadian Natural Resources (TSX: CNQ, NYSE: CNQ) that would be the most negatively impacted. Unlike Suncor or Cenovus, Canadian Natural Resources has little upgrading or refining capacity to hedge against a wider differential. Given that that company exports mostly raw bitumen, it’s more exposed to the changing spread than its integrated peers.

Foolish bottom line

Investors shouldn’t be too concerned about the Alberta government’s oil price projections. The province has been routinely criticized for its over-optimistic guidance before. These cautious estimates are probably an attempt to address those criticisms.

However, the fate of the oil sands will rest on the industry’s ability to access the market. Therefore, investors should pay less attention to the production reports from Fort McMurray, but rather the political rhetoric out of Vancouver, Montreal, and Ottawa.

Should all of the proposed pipelines come to fruition, it’s not a stretch to think that oil from Canada could one day make its way to China. But what many don’t realize is that Canada is already helping to power China by way of uranium – the key ingredient for nuclear power. To clue you into two of the best uranium companies in Canada, the Motley Fool has prepared a special FREE report titled “Fuel Your Portfolio With This Energetic Commodity”.  To receive your copy at no charge simply click here now!

The Motley Fool’s purpose is to help the world invest, better. Click here now for your free subscription to Take Stock, The Motley Fool Canada’s free investing newsletter. Packed with stock ideas and investing advice, it is essential reading for anyone looking to build and grow their wealth in the years ahead.

Follow us on Twitter and Facebook for the latest in Foolish investing.

Fool contributor Robert Baillieul does not own shares in any of the companies mentioned.  The Motley Fool does not own shares in any of the companies mentioned. 

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

More on Investing

Bank Stocks

3 Reasons I’m Buying Royal Bank Stock Today

Royal Bank (TSX:RY) stock has shown signs of strength and yet still put aside $720 million in provisions for loan…

Read more »

Business success with growing, rising charts and businessman in background
Tech Stocks

Growth Stocks: A Once-in-a-Lifetime Opportunity to Get Rich

Here's why investing in quality growth stocks such as Docebo and Datadog may allow you to generate sizeable returns.

Read more »

Question marks in a pile
Dividend Stocks

Should You Buy BMO Stock for its 5.2% Dividend Yield?

BMO stock has outpaced the broader markets in the past two decades. But is this blue-chip TSX bank stock a…

Read more »

Mature financial advisor showing report to young couple for their investment
Bank Stocks

3 Top Financial Stocks to Buy on the TSX Today

The top financial stocks to buy on the TSX today are two small lenders and one Big Bank.

Read more »

Pot stocks are a riskier investment
Cannabis Stocks

Canopy Growth Corp: Will it Ever Be a Buy?

Canopy Growth Corp (TSX:WEED) keeps going lower. Will it ever find a bottom?

Read more »

analyze data
Tech Stocks

Buy the Dip: 3 TSX Stocks and ETFs Worth Your Attention

As the year nears the end, it is time to buy some stocks and ETFs at the dip and book…

Read more »

data analyze research
Dividend Stocks

Better Dividend Stock for Passive Income: NorthWest REIT or Nexus REIT?

These two dividend stocks offer passive income above 8%, but which is the better (and safer) buy on the TSX…

Read more »

Dividend Stocks

Is Enbridge Stock a Buy Just for the 7.7% Dividend Yield?

Enbridge is moving higher after a prolonged pullback. Has the stock bottomed?

Read more »