Why Smart Investors Hate Dividends

Smart investors, including Warren Buffett, are actually against them altogether.

| More on:
The Motley Fool
You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s premium investing services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn more

Central bankers have brought about the investment apocalypse! Around the world, zero-interest rate policies have doomed the retirement plans of many investors. Now, like an army of zombies, they roam the investment landscape in a desperate hunt for bbrrraaaiiinnssss, er, yyyiiiieeelllddd.

Kidding aside, it’s no surprise that investors have turned to dividend-paying stocks as an alternative to low yielding bonds. Income investing is suddenly in vogue. And financial marketers have responded with a host of new products such as the iShares Dow Jones Select Dividend Index Fund (TSX: XDV) or the iShares Canadian Dividend Aristocrats Index Fund (TSX: CDZ).

But in reality, dividends may be a bad idea. Smart investors led by Warren Buffett are actually against them altogether. How can that be? Let me explain.

Dividends hurt returns
To explain why dividends are a bad idea, I’m going to need to use a little math. But I promise it will be quick and painless.

Let’s consider a hypothetical investment in Tim Horton’s (NYSE:THI). In this scenario, I’ll assume that Tim’s earns $1.00 per share each year and that investors are willing to pay 10 times earnings for each share of stock. For simplicity, I’m not going to include the effects of taxes or reinvestment requirements.

In scenario one, let’s imagine if Tim’s paid out all of its earnings as dividends to investors. You will receive a $1.00 cheque every year. Of course, without any funding for expansion Tim’s earnings will remain constant. At the end of 10 years, the stock is worth $10.00 per share and you will have received $10.00 in dividends cheques. Not a bad haul.

Reinvestment Rate Year 10 EPS Year 10 Share Price Total Return*

0%

$1.00

$10.00

$10.00

50%

$2.06

$20.61

$17.68

100%

$4.05

$40.46

$30.46

Total Return is equal to capital gains plus accumulated dividends. 

But there’s a better alternative. Let’s now assume that any profits Tim’s keeps can be reinvested at a 15% rate of return. Now if Tim’s management halts its dividend program and reinvests its profits back into the business, within 10 years the company will generate $4.05 in earnings per share. Assuming investors will pay the same multiple for the company in the future (remember 10 times earnings), the stock will now be worth $40.46 per share. That’s a much better outcome.

Okay, the math lesson is over. But the point is: if you’re invested in a wonderful business like Tim Horton’s, you would be better off  letting the company’s management keep your capital.

Nope, not buying it
Savvy readers may have one objection to my thesis above: what if the business can’t generate a satisfactory rate of return on new investment?

Indeed, the real world Tim Horton’s is a great example to look at. Outside of Alberta and Quebec, the company has almost completely saturated the Canadian marketplace. The firm’s attempts to expand into the United States have been mixed at best.

It may not be reasonable to assume that Tim’s can generate that 15% return. If, for example, Tim Horton’s halts its dividend and can only generate a 5% rate of return on new investments, the future value of the stock is only $16.29 per share. That’s worse than if the company just paid everything out to shareholders.

In this case, Tim’s should return capital to shareholders rather than persuse new expansion opportunities. But even if this is true, I’d much prefer that this be done through a buyback as opposed to a dividend. I’ll give you two reasons why.

First, the taxation issue. A buyback allows me to avoid taxes until I sell my shares. Dividends, in contrast, are taxed immediately and at a higher rate.

Second, I just want to avoid the hassle. After cashing a dividend cheque, investors now have to find another wonderful business at a reasonable price. Not an easy thing to do.

Older investors with an immediate need for income may disagree. But remember, you can always sell a portion of your shares for cash flow. Why force this burden on every shareholder in the company?

Foolish bottom line
This is not to say dividend paying stocks are bad investments per se. Rising payouts are a sign that management is looking out for the interests of shareholders. Paying a dividend also installs discipline. It’s harder for executives to fund ego-boosting, low return expansion projects. Dividend aristocrats, therefore, serve as a pretty good proxy for identifying great companies.

But savvy investors understand that dividends aren’t the best way to reward shareholders. They would much prefer reinvestments and buybacks.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Disclosure: Robert Baillieul has no positions in any of the stocks mentioned in this article. 

More on Investing

A solar cell panel generates power in a country mountain landscape.
Top TSX Stocks

3 TSX Stocks You Can Hold for the Next 3 Decades

While the market faces significant headwinds, it's crucial to ensure that you can commit to the TSX stocks you're holding…

Read more »

energy oil gas
Dividend Stocks

2 High-Yield Energy Stocks to Buy as Recession Approaches

Energy stocks such as TC Energy and Canadian Natural Resources allow investors to generate income even in recessionary times.

Read more »

green power renewable energy
Dividend Stocks

3 Top Dividend Stocks to Drive Your Passive Income

These three high-yielding, safe dividend stocks could boost your passive income.

Read more »

Dial moving from 4G to 5G
Tech Stocks

TFSA Investors: 2 Canadian Stocks With Unbelievable Staying Power 

Amid economic uncertainty, investors look for stocks that can thrive in any crisis and grow long term. Here are two…

Read more »

protect, safe, trust
Dividend Stocks

TFSA Wealth: How to Earn $363 in Monthly Passive Income for Life

Canadian investors can harness the power of the TFSA to generate steady tax-free passive income for decades.

Read more »

Canadian Dollars
Dividend Stocks

TFSA Millionaire: How to Turn $40,000 Into $1.2 Million for Retirement

Here's how TFSA investors are using the power of compounding to buy top Canadian dividend stocks to build retirement wealth.

Read more »

potted green plant grows up in arrow shape
Stocks for Beginners

3 Superb Income and Growth Stocks for Every Portfolio

The market is full of superb income and growth stocks, but not all belong in your portfolio. Here are three…

Read more »

stock market
Stocks for Beginners

Worried About Stagflation? 2 Canadian Stocks for All Market Cycles 

Stagflation delays economic recovery. You can keep your portfolio stagflation ready with these Canadian stocks that are suitable for all…

Read more »