Agrium Inc. vs. PotashCorp./Saskatchewan: Which Offers Better Value and Potential Returns?

The fertilizer industry will be strong in the long term, so what’s the best way to gain exposure: Agrium Inc. (TSX:AGU)(NYSE:AGU) or PotashCorp./Saskatchewan (TSX: POT)(NYSE: POT)?

The Motley Fool

The facts are simple: Over the next 30 years, the United Nations predicts the global population will rise by approximately 3 billion. This, coupled with increasing life expectancies, will result in an estimated doubling of world food population over the same period to meet demand.

Food production and demand for fertilizer are strongly linked, and with arable land declining due to climate factors and industrialization, fertilizer production will need to rapidly increase. The fundamental long-term economic factors driving both fertilizer production and price are strong, and it is an excellent industry to invest in for investors with a long-term focus, as part of a diversified portfolio.

The question then becomes how can you best profit from this industry? Canada’s two main players are Agrium Inc. (TSX: AGU)(NYSE: AGU) and PotashCorp./Saskatchewan (TSX: POT)(NYSE: POT). Let’s take a look at both.

Business model and strategy

The fertilizer industry has suffered through difficult conditions recently as a result of the dissolution of the joint potash marketing cartel between Russian-based Uralkali and Belarus-based Belaruskali, which will result in increased volumes and decreased prices for potash fertilizer. This caused potash prices to drop by $100 from roughly $400 to $300 per metric ton in mid 2013, and they have yet to recover.

This has influenced share prices of both Agrium and Potash Corp., and resulted in Potash Corp. initially laying off 18% of its workforce. Although this weakness is expected to continue, with the Bank of Nova Scotia predicting a decline in potash demand in 2015, Agrium is far more capable of surviving and thriving in these conditions due to its highly diversified portfolio.

A quick look at Agrium’s and Potash Corp.’s 2013 gross profit sources reveals this diversity. In 2013, Agrium received 34% of its gross profits from nitrogen, 14% from potash, and 3% from phosphate. Potash Corp received 57% of its sales from potash in 2013, 32% from nitrogen, and 11% from phosphate.

It is clear from this that in 2013, only 51%of Agrium’s gross profits came from actual fertilizer sales, with the other half coming from Agrium’s highly profitable and growing retail division. While Potash Corp receives 100% of its gross profits from currently weak fertilizer sales, Agrium receives half of its gross profits from its retail segment, which sells crop protection products, nutrient products, and seeds, and is currently the largest agricultural retailer in the world.

From 1997 to 2005, retail EBITDA rose from 50$ million to 110$ million, increasing annually, and from 2005 to 2013, retail EBITDA has increased 10x from $110 million to $1 billion. This provides Agrium a huge competitive edge over Potash Corp. during periods of weak fertilizer prices.


Agrium is currently trading at a discount to Potash Corp on several measures. Despite the fact that Agrium and Potash Corp are exposed to the same industry risks and weakness, Agrium still trades at an irrational discount, likely due to the fact it suffered production disruptions and was unusually affected by the harsh winter of 2014.

This implies that Agrium is likely undervalued, and investing in Agrium would represent a lower-risk, higher-reward option than investing in Potash Corp. Below is a chart comparing Agrium and Potash Corp. on price-to-earnings ratios, price-to-book ratios, and price-to cash flow ratios.

Agrium 16.3 1.80 5.8
Potash Corp. 21.6 3.2 11.6


More interestingly, analyst consensus gives Agrium a long-term growth rate of 7.82% vs. Potash Corp.’s 7.26%, which implies similar long-term prospects for both companies. This implies Potash Corp. is likely too expensive for its growth rate, and that Agrium represents better value for money.

With the long-term outlook for the fertilizer industry sunny, Agrium currently represents a better option than Potash Corp. for exposure to this area, due to its strong retail sector and excellent valuation.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Adam Mancini has a position in Agrium. The Motley Fool owns shares of PotashCorp. Agrium is a recommendation of Stock Advisor Canada.

More on Investing

Senior housing

3 Lesser-Known Reasons to Invest in an RRSP

The RRSP has so many more benefits that investors might be unaware of, and can be used for your benefit…

Read more »


TFSA Blueprint: 4 Canadian Stocks to Secure Your Future

Successful TFSA investing requires four steps and four Canadian stocks to secure your future.

Read more »

gas station, car, and 24-hour store
Energy Stocks

Is it Too Late to Buy Suncor Stock?

Suncor Energy stock has rallied big in the last year, but expect it to move higher as efficiencies keep rolling…

Read more »

Payday ringed on a calendar
Dividend Stocks

TFSA Monthly Money: How to Generate Consistent Tax-Free Passive Income

Adding these two attractive Canadian dividend stocks to your TFSA now could help you earn reliable monthly passive income for…

Read more »

analyze data
Dividend Stocks

3 Magnificent TSX Dividend Stocks to Buy and Hold Forever

Do you want to hold some quality dividend stocks for the decades ahead? Here are three stocks worth holding for…

Read more »

Double exposure of a businessman and stairs - Business Success Concept
Tech Stocks

Up 51% This Year: This Canadian AI Stock is Still Down 65% From Its Highs – Time to Buy?

Copperleaf Technologies (TSX:CLPF) stock has shown positive momentum as the AI stock attempts a recovery. Can shares rise 180% to…

Read more »

Oil pipes in an oil field
Energy Stocks

TSX Energy Sector: Best Stocks to Buy in May 2024

Energy stocks like Suncor are generating massive amounts of cash flows and paying out significant dividends.

Read more »

Dividend Stocks

How Much Will Canadian Utilities Pay in Dividends This Year?

Investors can stabilize their long-term stock portfolio returns by accumulating quality utility stocks on meaningful dips.

Read more »