Should Bombardier, Inc. Lose its Dual-Class Share Structure?

It’s been suggested that Bombardier, Inc. (TSX:BBD.B) dismantle its dual-class share structure if any federal aid money comes in.

| More on:
The Motley Fool

As the federal government mulls over whether to make an investment in Bombardier, Inc. (TSX:BBD.B), we’re hearing a lot of people come out against the idea. And I’m not just talking about right-wing commentators from The National Post either. Left-wing critics are painting the idea as a bailout for the wealthy Bombardier/Beaudoin family.

That said, Canada cannot simply let Bombardier go under. The company employs nearly 20,000 people in the province of Quebec alone, and this is an industry where all major participants receive government assistance.

This puts the government in a serious bind, and whatever decision Justin Trudeau makes, it will upset a lot of people. In a previous article, I suggested that Mr. Trudeau should wait for Bombardier to fail and then oversee a restructuring, not unlike what happened with the auto companies in 2009.

But there’s another solution–one that isn’t quite so harsh. It would benefit Bombardier’s shareholders, and it could also set the company on the right course. So is it a good idea?

A break up of the structure

Bombardier has a dual-class share structure, one that gives voting control to the Bombardier/Beaudoin, even though they own less than 20% of the equity. It’s a structure that’s widely regarded as unfair and undemocratic.

Defenders of the system argue that it protects a company from predators and allows for more long-term thinking. But those arguments evaporate when a company underperforms as badly as Bombardier has. And it was the family that made the terrible decision to proceed with the CSeries.

So in a Report on Business article (available to subscribers only) one Bombardier shareholder argued that any federal money should come with one key condition: break up this structure.

What would happen if the structure were broken?

This would be a fantastic outcome for Bombardier shareholders, because it would open up a world of possibilities for the company. For example, a hedge fund could step in and demand a breakup of the company with some parts (such as Bombardier Transportation or the CSeries program) being sold to foreign competitors.

Such moves would be fantastic for shareholders, but not so good for Bombardier’s employees. Many of their jobs would be at risk of leaving the country. And that wouldn’t be good for the province of Quebec either. This is why Bombardier was able to get US$2.5 billion of public money in Quebec–the government was afraid of jobs leaving the province.

Should Mr. Trudeau do this?

I agree that this is a better option than any “no strings attached” aid money. But it still has its flaws.

After all, Bombardier could simply take the money and do away with its dual-class share structure, only to see hedge funds come in and break up the company. Then Canada will have committed taxpayer dollars towards saving a Canadian company only to see jobs cut anyway.

At the end of the day, there aren’t really any good ideas. Mr. Trudeau has his work cut out for him.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Benjamin Sinclair has no position in any stocks mentioned.

More on Investing

Caution, careful
Stocks for Beginners

Don’t Get Taxed by Surprise: The TFSA’s Dirty Little Secret

Did you know that you can be taxed in a Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA)? It’s not common knowledge, but it’s …

Read more »

Question marks in a pile
Stocks for Beginners

New Investors: Do You Need Bonds in Your Investment Portfolio?

The traditional investment portfolio would have a bond and equity component. Do you really need bonds in your investment portfolio? …

Read more »

Top view of people having party, gathering, celebrating together

Plant-Based Foods Growth: Why I’m Buying This TSX Stock on the Dip

SunOpta (TSX:SOY) is a Minneapolis-based company that manufactures and sells plant-based and fruit-based food and beverage products to a variety …

Read more »

Coronavirus written newspaper close up shot to the text.
Tech Stocks

The 2 Best Tech Stocks to Buy Today for Low-Risk Investors

Overvalued tech stocks are undergoing a major correction after inflating on the back of high liquidity from fiscal stimulus packages. …

Read more »

crypto blockchain

How Cheap Can Crypto Mining Stocks Get Before They Are Worth a Buy?

Over the last two years, during the significant rallies in the crypto industry, some of the biggest gainers and best …

Read more »

Aircraft wing plane

Air Canada (TSX:AC): Is $22/Share Cheap or Expensive?

The TSX Composite Index corrected 2.3% since December 30, 2021, as tech stocks saw a huge selloff over the anticipation …

Read more »

exchange traded funds
Energy Stocks

3 Sector-Specific ETFs to Consider

Exposure to a specific sector doesn’t make sense from a diversification perspective, but it is often a good way to …

Read more »

silver metal
Metals and Mining Stocks

1 Reeling Silver Stock to Consider Today

Aya Gold & Silver (TSX:AYA) is a Montreal-based company that is engaged in the acquisition, exploration, evaluation, and development of …

Read more »