1 Analyst Firm Sees Agrium Inc. Shares Dropping in Half: Is it Time to Sell?

Agrium Inc. (TSX:AGU)(NYSE:AGU) was recently the subject of a report by analyst firm Hedgeye, which suggested shares were due to drop in half and recommended that investors short the stock. Should investors be worried?

The Motley Fool

Recently, the idea that Agrium Inc. (TSX:AGU)(NYSE:AGU) is becoming overvalued has made some headlines in financial media. A recent report by analyst firm Hedgeye, for example, claimed that Agrium shares are shockingly worth half of what they are today.

This thesis is based on the fact that Agrium’s retail business is due to suffer from severely contracting margins because of a cyclical downturn in the agricultural space that is currently underway. For example, corn prices have fallen from $8/bushel to around $4.30/bushel due to a few years of record crop production. The Hedgeye report suggests that similar to the historic agriculture downturn in the 1980s, the current downturn is only halfway through.

In the 1980s, retail businesses like Agrium suffered from major margin contraction due to farmer debt levels increasing and farmer incomes declining, and Hedgeye suggests this is re-occurring. At the same time, Agrium is currently trading at a forward EV/EBITDA of 9.5 times compared with its historical average of 7.1 times.

The agricultural market is not as bearish as Hedgeye suggests

Agrium is certainly expensive, and this historically expensive valuation would only be justified if the market views the current agricultural downturn as being cyclical rather than structural. If the market views the current weakness as being near a trough with a rebound imminent, the higher-than-normal valuations would be justifiable, especially given that Agrium sees growing free cash flow, growing dividends, and has a clear and demonstrated growth strategy for its retail business.

On its recent conference call, Agrium pointed out several key differences between the historic 1980s agricultural downturn and the current downturn.

Firstly, the 1980s downturn was preceded by a period of high inflation (over 15%), which resulted in the Federal Reserve needing to tighten policy by hiking interest rates (the prime lending rate rose from 6.8% in 1976 to over 20% in 1981). The result was that farmers were paying more for interest expenses at the time than their entire costs for seeds, crop protection, and fertilizers.

The situation today is different. While farmer incomes have dropped, there are several factors that are supportive to farmer incomes. Fertilizer costs, for example, have dropped substantially and are currently significantly below the 10-year average as a percentage of revenue. The 10-year average is 16.5%, and fertilizer costs are currently only 12-13% of revenue with the trend being down.

In addition to this, Agrium should benefit from how farmers choose to prioritize the spending they do have available. When farmers have limited income, they will typically put nitrogen and seed purchases ahead of potash or phosphate fertilizers, for example. Demand for nitrogen is relatively inelastic, since it is released every harvest and farmers need to continually reapply it or else crop yields will suffer.

Nitrogen is Agrium’s primary product in its wholesale division, and corn is a key product that Agrium’s retail segment is involved in (corn requires more nitrogen usage than soybeans, for example).

Agrium’s resiliency shows in the numbers

While Hedgeye suggests that Agrium’s retail margins are set to decline heavily, the evidence simply does not suggest this is happening so far. Agrium’s first-quarter crop-nutrient margins were the highest they’ve been in five years, and its crop-protection margins were the highest they’ve been in three years (despite corn prices plunging and farmer incomes declining).

In addition to this, Agrium’s return on capital employed has actually improved, climbing from 9% to 10%. From 2011 to present, despite corn prices being in a steady decline, Agrium’s overall retail gross margins have steadily risen, and EBITDA has shown steady growth as Agrium continues to pursue tuck-in acquisitions as well as build new facilities and sell higher-margin products.

The end result is that Hedgeye’s worst-case scenario for Agrium is unlikely.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Adam Mancini has no position in any stocks mentioned. Agrium is a recommendation of Stock Advisor Canada.

More on Investing

A cannabis plant grows.
Cannabis Stocks

Canopy Growth Stock Is Rising But I’m Worried About This One Thing

Canopy Growth stock is soaring as the legalization effort makes real progress in both Germany and the United States.

Read more »

young woman celebrating a victory while working with mobile phone in the office
Investing

3 Roaring Stocks to Hold for the Next 20 Years

These top TSX stocks are excellent long-term buys, given their multi-year growth potential and solid underlying businesses.

Read more »

Two seniors float in a pool.
Dividend Stocks

TFSA: How to Earn $1,890 in Annual Tax-Free Income

Plunk these investments into your TFSA to earn passive income and avoid the taxman.

Read more »

grow dividends
Investing

Here’s My Top 3 TSX Stocks to Buy Right Now

Even though the TSX has been rising, there are still some good bargains out there. Here are three top compounding…

Read more »

Target. Stand out from the crowd
Investing

Prediction: This Canadian Growth Stock Could Double by 2030

Alimentation Couche-Tard (TSX:ATD) is a top growth stock that could do well over the next six or so years.

Read more »

Businessman holding AI cloud
Tech Stocks

Could Investing $20,000 in Nvidia Make You a Millionaire?

Nvidia stock has made investors millionaires in the last 10 years. Is it too late to invest to become a…

Read more »

Engineers walk through a facility.
Dividend Stocks

1 TSX Stock I Wouldn’t Touch With a 10-Foot Pole

AtkinsRéalis (TSX:ATRL) is one TSX stock I'd never invest in.

Read more »

money cash dividends
Stocks for Beginners

Have $500? 3 Absurdly Cheap Stocks Long-Term Investors Should Buy Right Now

If you're looking for cheap stocks, these three have a huge future ahead of them, all while costing far less…

Read more »