Hudson’s Bay Co: A Classic Case of Misunderstanding Risk

U.S. department stores had lousy holiday sales, reminding Hudson’s Bay Co (TSX:HBC) investors just how much risk comes with owning cheap stocks.

The Motley Fool

The following title says it all:

Amazon worth more than Sears, Macy’s and Target combined.”

CNN Money Digital correspondent Paul LaMonica’s January 6th story said that the headline didn’t include seven other retailers, four of which are department stores.

That’s right, Amazon is worth more in terms of market cap than 10 well-known U.S. retailers combined.

Now, to be fair to the retailers, Amazon has a cloud business (Amazon Web Services) that is responsible for 35% of that market cap — a business that has everything to do with technology and very little to do with retail.

That said, I think we all get Mr. LaMonica’s point.

Brick-and-mortar retail independent of online retail is a thing of the past. Department stores, such as Hudson’s Bay Co (TSX:HBC) and the ones mentioned above, have been woefully slow to respond to the challenges posed by Amazon in the fight for online supremacy.

Unfortunately for department stores, it’s not just a lack of online panache that’s put most North American firms on the endangered list. A poor understanding of what clients are looking for in the way of apparel purchases has them two steps behind the H&Ms and Zaras of the world, resulting in heavy discounting, which in turn creates a customer who only wants cheap.

That’s a recipe for disaster.

I am a fan of Richard Baker, the majority owner of Hudson’s Bay.

A combination of timely asset sales (Zellers) mixed in with some smart real estate partnerships with RioCan and Simon Property Group, and the hiring of some of the best retail talent anywhere has created a buzz around the company that hadn’t been present for many years.

But, as they say about the markets, you can’t fight the trend. Right now, department stores, and most retail, for that matter, are the rotten apples of the services sector; their low stock prices are the proof that this is true.

In early December, I called Hudson’s Bay the best deep-value play on the TSX. Since then, HBC stock has declined by almost 13% and sits perilously close to dropping below $12 — significantly less than the $30-per-share analyst estimate for its real estate holdings.

In other words, in the eyes of the market, it’s worth more dead than alive. Both Sears and Yahoo fit into this category. When a public company reaches this stage of its life cycle, the risk to investors is ratcheted up tenfold.

So let me be very clear.

If you go to The Motley Fool Canada website and do a search for Hudson’s Bay, the first three stories you will find are all positive about the company’s future, and while you can definitely add me to that camp, you must understand that this is not an investment for the faint of heart.

Consider for a moment the $30-per-share valuation by analysts for HBC’s real estate holdings. Management pegs that number even higher at $36 per share. As we’ve seen with the Sears debacle in the U.S., value is in the eyes of the buyer, not the seller.

Sears announced January 6 that it had reached an agreement to sell its Craftsman brand to Stanley Black & Decker for US$900 million. Last May, when Sears announced it would put its Craftsman, Kenmore, and DieHard brands up for sale, Bloomberg pegged Craftsman’s value at US$2 billion.

Either Stanley Black & Decker got a great deal, or the brand was never anywhere near that value. I think we know the answer to that one.

So, the risk to HBC investors is that future buyers of its real estate don’t hold the same opinion of its true intrinsic value. After all, to buy and repurpose the real estate costs money; plus, you need to have a workable idea to fill the space. Given that retail in North America is generally considered overdone in terms of square footage, it’s not a slam dunk for any buyer.

HBC stock might be cheap, but before buying, do yourself a favour and really think hard about the risk and if you can stomach it because it could get a lot worse before it ever gets better.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Will Ashworth has no position in any stocks mentioned. David Gardner owns shares of The Motley Fool owns shares of

More on Investing

Modern buildings in business district
Bank Stocks

TD and CIBC Stock: 2 Top Banks to Buy for Big Yields

TD Bank (TSX:TD)(NYSE:TD) stock is a dividend juggernaut that's a must-buy for its cheap yield.

Read more »

Gold bars
Metals and Mining Stocks

Gold Stocks That Could Soar if the Fed Pauses Rate Hikes

In choppy waters, two gold heavyweights look too good to pass up right now given their lowered entry points, dividend…

Read more »

Clean energy
Energy Stocks

Better Buy: Renewable Energy or Uranium Stocks?

The world is shifting towards clean energy sources, creating investment opportunities in the renewables sector. What's a better bet: environmental…

Read more »

retirees and finances
Energy Stocks

These 3 Stocks Can Help Make You Richer by Retirement

Future retirees can be rich in their sunset years with the help of three distinguished dividend-payers on the TSX.

Read more »

A worker uses the cloud for paperless work. tech
Tech Stocks

Why I Think Constellation Software (TSX:CSU) Stock Has Market-Beating Potential

Constellation Software (TSX:CSU) could outperform the market over the next few years.

Read more »

data analytics, chart and graph icons with female hands typing on laptop in background

Got $5,000? These Are 2 of the Best TSX Growth Stocks to Buy Right Now

Canadian investors with some extra cash on hand should look to snatch up TSX growth stocks like goeasy Ltd. (TSX:GSY)…

Read more »

Senior Couple Walking With Pet Bulldog In Countryside
Dividend Stocks

Retirees: 2 On-Sale TSX Dividend Stocks to Buy Now for Passive Income

These top TSX dividend stocks now offer 6% yields.

Read more »

Electric car being charged

Forget Rivian: This Canadian EV Stock Is Cheaper and Safer

If you're still tempted to buy EV stocks, Magna International (TSX:MG) is probably safer than Rivian (NASDAQ:RIVN).

Read more »