Is it Better to Hold Stocks or ETFs in a Downturn?

What’s the difference between investing in a quality stock, such as Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc. (TSX:ATD.B) and specific ETFs?

When the stock market falls, there’s really nowhere to hide. It doesn’t matter if you hold exchange-traded funds (ETFs) or stocks. However, there are key differences in investing in them.

Investing in ETFs

When you invest in ETFs, it’s a passive way to invest. Additionally, you might feel more at ease because ETFs essentially match the performance of the underlying indices (while the indices’ performance is based on the weighted average performance of the underlying equities or bonds). Because ETFs hold a basket of things, they are generally less volatile than individual stocks.

Moreover, when investing in ETFs, you can look for industries or sectors that offer good value, income, or growth. For example, you might find iShares S&P TSX Capped Energy Index ETF (TSX: XEG) to be a good value play, as it trades near its 12-year low and oil prices have improved and stabilized above US$60 per barrel, while oil and gas producers have generally lowered their costs and improved their efficiency since the oil price collapse in 2014.

Notably, about 48% of the fund is in Suncor Energy and Canadian Natural Resources, which are stable and large-cap players.

 

question mark

Investing in stocks

Investing in individual stocks requires active management on your part. By investing in individual stocks, you can get fabulous, outperforming returns in Alimentation Couche-Tard (TSX:ATD.B). An investment in Couche-Tard shares in 2007 right before the recession, which was triggered by a financial crisis in 2008-2009, would have delivered annualized returns of about 24%. That beats any benchmark ETF you might use as a comparison.

However, buying ZCL Composites would have been a wildly different story. It delivered annualized returns of about -2% in the period.

Investors must be reminded that behind each stock is a business. Other than being aware of the nature of the business (e.g., if is cyclical), investors must also be aware of the valuation of the stock they’re paying. Moreover, the valuation of a stock changes as the business changes. If the profitability of a company falls, the stock might have become more expensive despite a price drop.

Investor takeaway

When investing in ETFs, look for areas of value, income, or growth. For example, you might find value in an energy fund, income from a utility fund, and growth from a tech fund.

When investing in individual stocks, it requires much more active management in that you can tweak your portfolio to your specific liking, whether your focus is on total returns, income, quality, stability, or a combination of all of the above. If you build your diversified portfolio properly with the above qualities, it could fare better in a market downturn than ETFs.

Fool contributor Kay Ng owns shares of ALIMENTATION COUCHE-TARD INC. Alimentation Couche-Tard is a recommendation of Stock Advisor Canada.

More on Dividend Stocks

a person watches a downward arrow crash through the floor
Dividend Stocks

A TFSA Loss Doesn’t Create New Room: Here’s the Rebuilding Plan I’d Use

A falling investment won’t create TFSA contribution room. I’d rebuild using the room I actually have and a portfolio that…

Read more »

Forklift in a warehouse
Dividend Stocks

A 7.9% Dividend Stock for Monthly Retirement Income

This Canadian REIT trades at a 38.8% discount to a key valuation measure, and offers a 7.9% yield, paid monthly,…

Read more »

hand stacks coins
Dividend Stocks

Building a $1,000-a-Month Dividend Income Stream: What It Actually Takes

Wondering what it takes to earn $1,000/month in dividends? Here's some different scenarios and stocks that can help get you…

Read more »

A series of red ladders lead to successively higher levels
Dividend Stocks

Colliers Stock: The Engineering Business Behind the Real Estate Name

Colliers still earns from real estate, but engineering now gives investors a second business to follow.

Read more »

shopper checks her receipt
Dividend Stocks

2 Safe Canadian Stocks to Buy With $7,000

Loblaw (TSX:L) and another safety play that could be a great fit for Canadian investors seeking lower betas and greater…

Read more »

dreaming of financial success
Dividend Stocks

Telus vs. Fortis: Which Stock Would I Choose for a More Dependable Payout?

Telus pays more today after its reset. I’d choose Fortis for the payout I’d rather count on over several years.

Read more »

a person looks out a window into a cityscape
Dividend Stocks

This 3% Dividend Stock Pays Cash Out Every Month

Boardwalk REIT pays $0.15 a unit every month, a yield near 3%. See Q3 results, the buyback story and the…

Read more »

shoppers in an indoor mall
Dividend Stocks

2 Top TSX Dividend Stocks With High Yields Worth Considering Now

These TSX stocks offer high yields of over 5.5%, have sustainbale payouts, and are well-positioned to keep paying their dividends.

Read more »