2 Stocks on the TSX Index That Are Yielding More Than 9%: 1 I’d Buy and 1 I’d Avoid

Is the 10% dividend of Torstar Corporation (TSX:TS.B) a buy at these levels? There’s another company yielding 9% I like better.

| More on:

Stocks offering investors high annual dividend payouts are great.

Not only can those dividend streams help to pay for investors’ living expenses — particularly in the case of retirees — but they can also be reinvested in investors’ portfolios and put towards future stock purchases.

But the risk in pursuing the shares of companies that pay their owners a high dividend payout is, sometimes there’s a catch — namely, that the payout won’t be sustainable for the company over the long term.

The yield on the stock of a company, like, for example, TorStar (TSX:TS.B) might be 10.10% right now, but if it can’t sustain its current earnings, then the board of directors might have to cut that payout to a significantly smaller figure.

While investors may think they’re paying for a 10.10% yield right now, by next year they could find out that they’re now getting 4%. In cases like that, those investors would have probably been better off avoiding the “chase for yield” and looking for the best yield offered by a company that still has decent prospects for growth.

TorStar, which owns and publishes one of Toronto’s most popular daily newspapers had faced difficulties, like so many other traditional media outlets, in adapting and competing with the threat of emergent online and digital media. The result has been declines in sales for each of the past three years with that trend more than likely expected to continue this year as well.

Meanwhile, TorStar hasn’t posted an annual profit dating back to 2014.

While its cash flows have fared slightly better than its reported GAAP earnings, the company’s $2 million annual dividend is certainly at the risk of being unsustainable.

Meanwhile, there’s another company whose shares currently yield an almost-as-good 9.03% annual dividend, which, in my view, at least, isn’t facing nearly the same type of existential threat.

Granted, it’s been a tough couple of years for active managers in the investment industry, as funds have precipitously flowed into passively managed pools like low-fee exchange-traded-funds.

Asset managers like Gluskin Sheff + Associates (TSX:GS) and others have found themselves down in the dumps.

Gluskin Sheff stock is down 27% so far this year and down 33% since the beginning of September. That’s left GS stock yielding a little more than 9%.

While Gluskin Sheff’s 9% dividend still looks reasonably sustainable at a payout ratio of just a little more than 80%, it’s the sell-off in the company’s stock and the recent trend toward passive investing that actually looks unsustainable, at least in my opinion.

The premise behind passive investing, after all, is the belief in the “efficient market theory” and the assumption that assets are fairly priced all the time.

Well, that assumption is squarely based on the premise that market participants like Gluskin Sheff’s portfolio managers are constantly monitoring company valuations and their actions, buying the winners and selling the losers, to ensure that those asset prices are indeed “fairly priced.”

By definition, if there were no active managers like Gluskin Sheff that were acting in the market to perform this function, then passive investing as a formidable strategy would simply cease to exist.

All of this goes to say that what goes around usually comes back around again.

The past decade has been largely characterized by a historically low interest rate environment and all but absent volatility in the publicly traded markets.

Should central banks from Canada, the United States, and around the world continue on their current path towards normalizing interest rates, that will likely be accompanied by a return to more normalized volatility in the markets.

That should create more value of active managers like Gluskin Sheff, their clients, and their shareholders.

Fool on.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Jason Phillips has no position in any of the stocks mentioned.

More on Dividend Stocks

woman retiree on computer
Dividend Stocks

Should You Buy Telus Stock at $20?

Down 40% from all-time highs, Telus is a beaten-down TSX dividend stock that trades at a discount to consensus price…

Read more »

top TSX stocks to buy
Dividend Stocks

Here’s Exactly How $15,000 in a TFSA Could Grow Into $200,000

Canadians with sizeable TFSA balances today have utilized the full potential of the investment vehicle.

Read more »

TFSA (Tax-Free Savings Account) on wooden blocks and Canadian one hundred dollar bills.
Dividend Stocks

The 1 Canadian Stock I’d Buy and Hold Forever in a TFSA

Don't get complicated. Consider this Canadian stock as a long-time buy.

Read more »

Man data analyze
Dividend Stocks

A Top-Performing U.S. Stock That Canadian Investors Really Should Own

This top US tech stock is something you cannot miss out on, and there’s another from Canada that you need…

Read more »

how to save money
Dividend Stocks

3 Premium TSX Dividend Stocks Worth Loading Up On

These three premium TSX dividend stocks remain among the best bets for long-term investors seeking stable total returns.

Read more »

Hand Protecting Senior Couple
Dividend Stocks

3 Canadian Dividend Stocks Perfect for Retirees

These three Canadian stocks are ideal for retirees.

Read more »

Middle aged man drinks coffee
Dividend Stocks

Should You Buy Goeasy Stock While It’s Below $170?

Goeasy stock still looks like a winner, so why is the stock price down below $170?

Read more »

Piggy bank with word TFSA for tax-free savings accounts.
Dividend Stocks

Maximizing Your TFSA: Smart Investment Moves for 2025

Stocks like Enbridge provide significant dividend income, which is ideal for tax-savings within your TFSA.

Read more »