Could “Buy Now Pay Later” Replace Credit Cards?

“Buy now, pay later” services give cash-strapped Canadians the option of spreading payments on purchases across numerous months, even years.

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s premium investing services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn more

Over the last decade and a half, e-commerce has seen an explosive amount of growth. Fueled by lockdowns and shelter-in-place mandates, tech companies and startups have captured consumers with products and services that made life in the pandemic feel, well, less stressful.

One is “buy now, pay later” (BNPL). BNPL services give cash-strapped Canadians the option of spreading payments on purchases across numerous months, even years. Pay a little now, a little more next month, and a little more the month after, and you can afford that Peloton today.

Though the BNPL concept isn’t new (installment loans have existed for decades), the recent wave of BNPL services has a new feature: “no interest” financing. As long as you make payments on time, you only pay what the item costs and not a cent more.

That alone has given BNPL services a major boost in Canada. Its rapid growth, in fact, has left many wondering if BNPL will replace (or eclipse) credit cards.

I’m skeptical. Here’s why.

1. BNPL services could hurt your credit score

The more BNPL services you apply for, the more you could potentially hurt your credit score. That’s because some BNPL companies run a hard inquiry on your credit to determine if you’re eligible for their services (whenever a BNPL service asks you for your Social Insurance Number, that’s an indicator they’ll check your credit).

Credit inquires make up 10% of your credit score, and they can stay on your report for up to 12 months. One or two won’t crush your credit. Any more than that, and you’ll start knocking your score down.

Some BNPL companies, like Afterpay, won’t run a credit check. In fact, in the case of Afterpay, borrowing money doesn’t affect your credit score at all. That can be another problem: if the BNPL company doesn’t report borrowing activities to major crediting bureaus, you won’t build a credit score.

2. Credit cards have more lucrative rewards

Credit cards have a leg up in one key area: rewards programs.

As long as you pay your credit card balance each month, you can accumulate a surprising number of rewards points, travel miles, and cash back on rewards cards.

While a sprinkling of BNPL services, like Klarna, are trying their hand at rewards programs, the majority do not have one. If you’re only trying to afford a big purchase now, that may not matter. But if you become dependent on the BNPL model, using it for purchases you could easily afford, you could miss out on lucrative credit card rewards.

3. Credit cards are more widely accepted

The big problem with BNPL services — they’re so new, many small retailers don’t offer them. Even big retail stores don’t accept all BNPL services (and trust me: there are lots of them), meaning you could end up managing numerous BNPL accounts.

4. BNPL services still have fees

Yes, BNPL companies offer “no-interest” borrowing. But don’t think they care about your personal finances that much.

Most BNPL companies will charge fees and interest on late or missed payments. These charges range from company to company, but more often than not, the interest charges will be similar to the APR on a credit card.

5. Credit cards have more perks

Finally, credit cards have numerous built-in rewards that BNPL services have yet to match. Travel insurance, purchase protection, extended warranty on certain purchases, price protection, and rental car insurance are just a few of a credit card’s perks.

Bottom line

Though BNPL services are growing, I doubt they’ll overtake the credit card industry. Until BNPL companies find a way to match or surpass the rewards, perks, and credit-building capacity of plastic, credit cards will live another day.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

More on Investing

Glass piggy bank

4 Dividend Stocks to Hold in Your RRSP Forever

Inflation and volatility should spur RRSP investors to buy dependable dividend stocks like Hydro One Ltd. (TSX:H) and others right…

Read more »

protect, safe, trust
Dividend Stocks

3 Safe Stocks for Beginners Amid Rising Volatility

Given their stable cash flows and healthy growth potential, these three safe stocks are excellent buys for beginners.

Read more »

edit Four girl friends withdrawing money from credit card at ATM
Bank Stocks

3 Cheap Bank Stocks to Buy Today

Canadians may want to snatch up top bank stocks like Bank of Montreal (TSX:BMO)(NYSE:BMO) that look undervalued today.

Read more »

calculate and analyze stock
Stocks for Beginners

Top TSX Stocks for Beginners in July 2022

Buying these top TSX stocks in July 2022 could help stock market beginners receive handsome returns on their investments in…

Read more »


Stocks, Bonds, or Real Estate: What’s the Best Way to Prepare for a Recession?

Recession worries could push investors to bonds.

Read more »

Oil pumps against sunset
Energy Stocks

How Would a Price Cap on Russian Oil Impact Canadian Energy Stocks?  

Canadian energy stocks surged in the last three days, as G7 countries proposed a plan to impose a price cap…

Read more »

Business success with growing, rising charts and businessman in background
Tech Stocks

3 Growth Stocks Worth Buying Today

With the volatility of the stock market, many investors continue to avoid growth stocks. However, here are three stocks worth…

Read more »

money cash dividends
Dividend Stocks

Market Correction: 2 Oversold TSX Dividend Stocks to Buy for Total Returns

These top value stocks pay attractive dividends and look cheap to buy for a TFSA or RRSP focused on total…

Read more »