S&P 500 vs. S&P/TSX 60: Which 1 Is the Better Long-Term Investment?

The U.S.’s top stock market index goes head to head with Canada’s. Here’s how they stack up.

| More on:
question marks written reminders tickets

Image source: Getty Images

I’m a big proponent of passive investing. Countless studies have demonstrated the inability of most stock pickers to beat the market consistently, especially when benchmarked against the long-term performance of a simple index fund.

Indexes like the S&P 500 and the S&P/TSX 60 are regarded as barometres of U.S. and Canadian stock market performance, respectively. The aggregate performance of their underlying stocks is considered to reflect the average market return over long periods of time.

For Canadian investors, implementing a passive buy-and-hold strategy with either of these indexes is a great idea. You can do so using exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that track each index. The question is, which one should you buy? Each index has its own pros and cons, and today we’ll be exploring those.

The S&P 500

The S&P 500 is a market cap-weighted stock market index that tracks the 500 large-cap stocks listed on U.S. exchanges, such as Microsoft, Apple, Alphabet, JPMorgan, and Amazon. It spans the technology, healthcare, financials, communications, consumer staples, consumer discretionary, industrial, and energy sectors.

To track the S&P 500, you can buy Vanguard S&P 500 Index ETF (NYSE:VOO). This ETF is extremely cheap, with a management expense ratio (MER) of just 0.03%. The fund has high assets under management and good daily trading volume, making it a popular choice for retail investors.

However, VOO is denominated in USD, so you’ll need to convert CAD over. This will cost you a currency conversion fee, unless you’re using Norbert’s Gambit. As well, U.S.-listed ETFs incur a 15% foreign withholding tax on the dividend yield unless held in an RRSP, so you’ll need to account for that.

The S&P/TSX 60

The S&P/TSX 60 is a market cap-weighted index of the 60 largest stocks trading on the Toronto Stock Exchange (TSX). Its top holdings consist of blue-chip stocks such as Royal Bank of Canada, Shopify, Enbridge, and Canadian National Railway. Compared to the S&P 500, the S&P/TSX 60 is more heavily weighted towards the financial and energy sectors.

To track the S&P/TSX 60, you can buy iShares S&P/TSX 60 Index ETF (TSX:XIU). This ETF is the oldest one in Canada, with assets under management of more than $11 billion and high liquidity. XIU is more expensive than VOO, with a MER of 0.20%. This is still considered inexpensive for an ETF though.

XIU also pays a respectable dividend, thanks to its many underlying Dividend Aristocrat stocks in the energy, banking, telecom, and utilities sectors. Currently, the 12-month trailing yield stands at 2.41% and is paid quarterly. Reinvesting this dividend can significantly boost your returns.

Which is better?

A word of caution: the backtest results provide below are hypothetical in nature, do not reflect actual investment results, and are not guarantees of future results. Hypothetical returns do not reflect trading costs, transaction fees, or actual taxes due on investment returns.

That being said, from 2000 to present, with all dividends reinvested, VOO and XIU were neck and neck, with similar returns, volatility, drawdowns, and Sharpe ratio.

The answer here is to buy both. The U.S. and Canadian markets take turns outperforming. New investors might only remember the bull run the S&P 500 had during the last decade. Older investors will remember the “lost decade,” where the S&P/TSX 60 beat the S&P 500 handily. Buying both VOO and XIU will mitigate that risk.

Good investors avoid putting their eggs in a single (geographical) basket. The recent spell of U.S. outperformance might mean it’s a good time to buy the Canadian index while its still low in comparison. Over time, the difference will narrow, and you’ll minimize your chance of being stuck with years of poor results.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

JPMorgan Chase is an advertising partner of The Ascent, a Motley Fool company. Suzanne Frey, an executive at Alphabet, is a member of The Motley Fool’s board of directors. John Mackey, CEO of Whole Foods Market, an Amazon subsidiary, is a member of The Motley Fool’s board of directors. Fool contributor Tony Dong has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool owns and recommends Shopify. The Motley Fool recommends Alphabet (A shares), Alphabet (C shares), Amazon, Apple, Canadian National Railway, Enbridge, and Microsoft.

More on Investing

Canadian stocks are rising
Dividend Stocks

Looking for Big Passive Income? 2 Easy REITs to Consider

H&R REIT (TSX:HR.UN) and SmartCentres REIT (TSX:SRU.UN) could help fund your retirement.

Read more »

Businessman holding AI cloud
Tech Stocks

AI Will Transform Everything: Investors, Be Early Adopters and Buy These 3 Stocks

Investors looking to invest in companies doing big things in AI should consider these three stocks for their portfolios.

Read more »

Family relationship with bond and care
Dividend Stocks

CPP Pension: 1 Move to Increase Your Payouts by $6,877 Per Year

Canadian retirees can consider boosting their CPP payouts by delaying the benefit and investing in blue-chip dividend stocks.

Read more »

stock research, analyze data
Tech Stocks

Forget Shopify: These Unstoppable Stocks Are Better Buys Today 

Should you consider buying Shopify stock while rivals consider a buyout or should you go for stocks with a stronger…

Read more »

A close up image of Canadian $20 Dollar bills
Dividend Stocks

This 8.6% Dividend Stock Pays Cash Every Month

Diversified Royalty is a high-dividend stock that offers a tasty yield in 2024. Is the TSX dividend stock a buy…

Read more »

energy industry
Energy Stocks

2 TSX Energy Stocks to Buy Hand Over Fist Now

These two rallying TSX energy stocks can continue delivering robust returns to investors in the long term.

Read more »

rain rolls off a protective umbrella in a rainstorm
Dividend Stocks

3 Safe Canadian Dividend Stocks to Buy and Hold Forever

Here are three of the safest Canadian dividend stocks you can buy now and hold as long as you want.

Read more »

Man holding magnifying glass over a document
Investing

Buy the Dip: 2 Top Stocks to Watch in April

Shopify (TSX:SHOP) and another tech-driven growth stock that looks like screaming buys on the dip right now.

Read more »