ZEO vs. XEG: Which Energy Sector ETF Is the Better Buy for Canadian Investors?

Canada’s two most popular energy sector ETFs go head to head.

Welcome to a weekly series where I break down and compare some of the most popular exchange-traded funds (ETFs) available to Canadian investors!

The energy sector outperformed in 2021 and 2022 thanks to high inflation and soaring commodity prices. Both BlackRock and BMO Global Asset Management provide a set of low-cost, high-liquidity ETFs that offer exposure to a portfolio of TSX energy sector stocks.

The two tickers up for consideration today are iShares S&P/TX Capped Energy Index ETF (TSX:XEG) and BMO Equal Weight Oil & Gas Index ETF (TSX: ZEO). Which one is the better option? Keep reading to find out.

XEG vs. ZEO: Fees

The fee charged by an ETF is expressed as the management expense ratio (MER). This is the percentage that is deducted from the ETF’s net asset value (NAV) over time and is calculated on an annual basis. For example, an MER of 0.50% means that for every $10,000 invested, the ETF charges a fee of $50 annually.

XEG has an MER of 0.61%, identical to ZEO. The ETFs are therefore tied when it comes to their fees, with both costing you about $61 annually on a $10,000 portfolio.

XEG vs. ZEO: Size

The size of an ETF is very important. Funds with small assets under management (AUM) may have poor liquidity, low trading volume, high bid-ask spreads, and more risk of being delisted due to lack of interest.

XEG has attracted AUM of $2.15 billion, whereas ZEO has AUM of $253 million. Although both are sufficient for a buy-and-hold investor, XEG is currently the more popular ETF among Canadian investors.

XEG vs. ZEO: Holdings

XEG tracks the S&P/TSX Capped Energy Index, which tracks the performance of 22 TSX energy stocks. Each stock in XEG is subjected to a 25% cap on their weight. The top five holdings of XEG include Canadian Natural Resources, Suncor Energy, Cenovus Energy, Tourmaline Oil, and Imperial Oil, with the first two stocks at 24.89% and 24.07% each.

ZEO tracks the Solactive Equal Weight Canada Oil & Gas Index, which tracks the performance of 10 TSX energy stocks. ZEO is equally allocated between 10 stocks, which include Canadian Natural Resources, Suncor Energy, Cenovus Energy, Tourmaline Oil, Imperial Oil, Arc Resources, TC Energy, Pembina Pipeline, Enbridge, and Keyera.

XEG vs. ZEO: Historical performance

A cautionary statement before we dive in: past performance is no guarantee of future results, which can and will vary. The portfolio returns presented below are hypothetical and backtested. The returns do not reflect trading costs, transaction fees, or taxes, which can cause drag.

Here are the trailing returns from 2011 to present:

Here are the annual returns from 2011 to present:

ZEO outperformed XEG over the last decade. I attribute this to ZEO’s equal weighting, which reduced the risk of a single large holding tanking its performance. XEG is way too concentrated with 50% of its holdings in just two stocks, which makes it more volatile, especially during crashes.

The Foolish takeaway

If I had to choose one ETF to buy and hold, it would be ZEO. Both ETFs have identical MERs, XEG has more AUM, but when it comes to holdings, I feel more comfortable buying an equal-weighted ETF, especially when it comes to a cyclical sector like energy.

XEG poses too much concentration risk, as half of the ETF is basically Suncor Energy and Canadian Natural Resources. When I buy a sector specific ETF, I want to own the sector and not just a few select companies. For this reason, ZEO is my pick for betting on the TSX energy sector.

Fool contributor Tony Dong has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends CDN NATURAL RES, Enbridge, KEYERA CORP, and PEMBINA PIPELINE CORPORATION.

More on Energy Stocks

Oil industry worker works in oilfield
Energy Stocks

I Found the Ideal Retirement TFSA Stock Paying 6.4%

Looking for an ideal retirement TFSA stock? Freehold Royalties stock pays a 6.4% monthly dividend backed by a low payout…

Read more »

boy in bowtie and glasses gives positive thumbs up
Energy Stocks

Enbridge: My Verdict Is Buy – Here’s the Dividend $6,000 Would Collect

Unpack the financial dynamics at Enbridge, including its stock performance and pressures from rising debt and investment needs.

Read more »

Trans Alaska Pipeline with Autumn Colors
Energy Stocks

How Much Would You Need in Pembina to Average $300 a Month?

Pembina pays quarterly. Averaging $300 a month at its latest rate would take about $85,000 at writing.

Read more »

electrical cord plugs into wall socket for more energy
Energy Stocks

What $12,000 in Canadian Utilities Could Add to Your Annual Income

At its recent price, Canadian Utilities could turn a $12,000 budget into about $418 a year in dividends.

Read more »

financial chart graphs and oil pumps on a field
Energy Stocks

My Top Canadian Dividend Stock to Own Going Into 2027

An energy major that is poised to have a sizeable footprint after a multi-billion-dollar deal is the top Canadian dividend…

Read more »

Business doodle about dividends on chalkboard
Energy Stocks

Your RRIF Needs Cash, Not Just a Big Balance: Here’s the Dividend Plan I’d Use

A big RRIF balance doesn’t tell you how much cash you’ll have when the minimum withdrawal comes due. I’d build…

Read more »

Oil industry worker works in oilfield
Energy Stocks

Canadian Natural Resources Has Raised Its Dividend for 26 Straight Years: Here’s Why It Stands Out

Canadian Natural Resources has raised its dividend for 26 straight years. Explore the assets and cash flow supporting its growing…

Read more »

data center server racks glow with light
Energy Stocks

Hammond Power Stock: A Different Way to Invest in the Electricity Buildout

New power demand can mean more work for transformer makers. Hammond’s order book shows the opportunity, and its share price…

Read more »