VOO vs. VTI: Should Investors Buy the S&P 500 Index or Total U.S. Stock Market?

Both are great long-term passive investment choices, but which one is the best?

Most investors (including me) will find it very difficult to beat the market consistently. While some investors can get lucky and outperform it in the short term, many will fail to over the long run. Even fund managers and stock pickers often underperform a simple index fund over time. The market is efficient, and the various stock market indexes out there are notoriously difficult to beat.

The S&P 500 Index

The most famous index, and the benchmark many professional investors measure themselves against is the S&P 500. The S&P 500 tracks the largest 500 companies listed on U.S. exchanges and is widely seen as a barometre for overall U.S. stock market performance. It makes for a great passive investment.

If you are comfortable with using Norbert’s Gambit to convert CAD to USD for cheap (which I covered earlier with a how-to guide) and are investing in your Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP), you can save significantly by using a U.S.-denominated S&P 500 exchange-traded fund (ETF) like Vanguard S&P 500 Index ETF (NYSE:VOO).

VOO is as cheap as it gets for ETFs, costing just 0.03% per year in management expense ratios (MER). That’s around $3 per year for a $10,000 investment, making VOO a perfect low-cost vehicle for tracking a well-known, high-performing index.

The total U.S. stock market

That being said, the U.S. stock market doesn’t end at just the S&P 500. Beyond the index, there are another +3,000 mid-, small-, and micro-cap stocks out there worth investing in. These stocks often have different risk/reward profiles, and their volatility can help boost long-term returns.

By market capitalization, the S&P 500 accounts for around 82% of the U.S. stock market’s weight. That means there’s another 18% of stocks out there unaccounted for. To track these stocks, investors can turn to the CRSP U.S. Total Market Index.

To track this index, consider buying Vanguard Total Stock Market Index ETF (NYSE:VTI). Compared to VOO, VTI holds over 3,000 more mid-, small-, and micro-cap stocks. Roughly 82% of VTI is VOO, making their performance and composition somewhat similar. Surprisingly, VTI is just as inexpensive as VOO is, costing just 0.03% in MER.

Head to head

Over very long periods of time, VTI can be expected to perform very similarly to VOO, but with higher volatility. Because 82% of VTI is VOO, its performance is still highly correlated to the S&P 500. The remaining 12% of mid- and small-cap stocks adds some volatility, which can boost returns but also increases risk.

I’ve backtested the returns of the S&P 500 vs. the total U.S. stock market from 1972 below. A cautionary statement before we dive in: past performance is no guarantee of future results, which can and will vary. The portfolio returns presented below are hypothetical and backtested. The returns do not reflect trading costs, transaction fees, or taxes.

Trailing returns are virtually identical, with VTI having slightly more volatility but also higher returns.

Annual returns are similar too, with VTI outperforming some years, and VOO in others. I attribute this to the cyclical nature of small- and large-cap stocks, which take turns outperforming.

The Foolish takeaway

My pick here is VTI. We don’t know whether small or large caps will do better in the future. The evidence suggests that both are cyclical. Large caps did particularly well in the last decade, but small caps outperformed in the years following the dot-com bubble. While the S&P 500 is a solid investment, investors seeking a truly passive approach should buy the total U.S. stock market. This is all the more compelling when you consider that VOO and VTI cost the same MER.

Fool contributor Tony Dong has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned.

More on Investing

a person watches a downward arrow crash through the floor
Dividend Stocks

A TFSA Loss Doesn’t Create New Room: Here’s the Rebuilding Plan I’d Use

A falling investment won’t create TFSA contribution room. I’d rebuild using the room I actually have and a portfolio that…

Read more »

Forklift in a warehouse
Dividend Stocks

A 7.9% Dividend Stock for Monthly Retirement Income

This Canadian REIT trades at a 38.8% discount to a key valuation measure, and offers a 7.9% yield, paid monthly,…

Read more »

hand stacks coins
Dividend Stocks

Building a $1,000-a-Month Dividend Income Stream: What It Actually Takes

Wondering what it takes to earn $1,000/month in dividends? Here's some different scenarios and stocks that can help get you…

Read more »

A series of red ladders lead to successively higher levels
Dividend Stocks

Colliers Stock: The Engineering Business Behind the Real Estate Name

Colliers still earns from real estate, but engineering now gives investors a second business to follow.

Read more »

shopper checks her receipt
Dividend Stocks

2 Safe Canadian Stocks to Buy With $7,000

Loblaw (TSX:L) and another safety play that could be a great fit for Canadian investors seeking lower betas and greater…

Read more »

dreaming of financial success
Dividend Stocks

Telus vs. Fortis: Which Stock Would I Choose for a More Dependable Payout?

Telus pays more today after its reset. I’d choose Fortis for the payout I’d rather count on over several years.

Read more »

a person looks out a window into a cityscape
Dividend Stocks

This 3% Dividend Stock Pays Cash Out Every Month

Boardwalk REIT pays $0.15 a unit every month, a yield near 3%. See Q3 results, the buyback story and the…

Read more »

shoppers in an indoor mall
Dividend Stocks

2 Top TSX Dividend Stocks With High Yields Worth Considering Now

These TSX stocks offer high yields of over 5.5%, have sustainbale payouts, and are well-positioned to keep paying their dividends.

Read more »