ZAG vs. VAB vs. XBB: Which Aggregate Bond ETF Is the Better Buy for Canadians?

Canada’s most popular aggregate bond ETFs go head to head.

| More on:
exchange-traded funds

Image source: Getty Images

Welcome to a series where I break down and compare some of the most popular exchange-traded funds (ETFs) available to Canadian investors!

Canadian investors looking for a hands-off, “buy-the-haystack” approach to their portfolio’s bond allocation can opt for a broadly diversified aggregate domestic bond fund, which includes investment-grade government and corporate debt of all maturities.

Fund managers like Vanguard, iShares, and BMO Global Asset Management provide a set of low-cost, high-liquidity ETFs that offer exposure to a portfolio of these bonds.

The three tickers up for consideration today are Vanguard Canadian Aggregate Bond Index ETF (TSX:VAB), iShares Core Canadian Bond Index ETF (TSX:XBB), and BMO Aggregate Bond Index ETF (TSX:ZAG). Which one is the better option? Keep reading to find out.

VAB vs. XBB vs. ZAG: Fees

The fee charged by an ETF is expressed as the management expense ratio (MER). This is the percentage that is deducted from the ETF’s net asset value (NAV) over time, calculated on an annual basis. For example, an MER of 0.50% means that for every $10,000 invested, the ETF charges a fee of $50 annually.

VAB and ZAG both have an MER of 0.09% vs. 0.10% for XBB. All three are extremely cheap, costing around $9-10 in fees annually for a $10,000 portfolio. If we had to pick a winner, it would be either VAB or ZAG here.

VAB vs. XBB vs. ZAG: Size

The size of an ETF is very important. Funds with small assets under management (AUM) may have poor liquidity, low trading volume, high bid-ask spreads, and more risk of being delisted due to lack of interest.

VAB currently has AUM of $3.2 billion, XBB has $4.5 billion, and ZAG has $5.9 billion. All three are more than sufficient for long-term, buy-and-hold picks. If we had to pick a winner, it would be ZAG.  

VAB vs. XBB vs. ZAG: Holdings

When selecting a bond ETF, investors should pay attention to three considerations. First, check the credit quality of the bonds. Ideally, we want bonds rated A, AA, and AAA (investment grade). We don’t want junk bonds, as our goal here is to reduce volatility, not increase it.

VAB, XBB, and ZAG each contain 36%, 37%, and 37% AAA-rated debt, with another 35% each allocated to AA, and the rest spread evenly along A and BBB. All three funds are evenly split between federal, provincial, and corporate bonds, offering a balanced mix of protection and yield.

Two, check the effective duration of the bond. This is a measure of how sensitive the bond is to interest rate movements. Bond prices move inverse to interest rates. For example, a bond with an effective duration of 2.46 years would lose approximately 2.46% if interest rates rose by 1%. VAB, XBB, and ZAG have average durations of 7.6, 7.4, and 7.5, respectively, making them virtually identical.

Finally, we look at the weighted average yield to maturity (YTM) of the bonds, which is the total return anticipated on a bond if held until maturity. This is influenced by the face price of the bonds as well as their coupon payments. VAB, XBB, and ZAG have YTMs of 3.4%, 4%, and 3.5%, respectively.

VAB vs. XBB vs. ZAG: Historical performance

A cautionary statement before we dive in: past performance is no guarantee of future results, which can and will vary. The portfolio returns presented below are hypothetical and backtested. The returns do not reflect trading costs, transaction fees, or taxes, which can cause drag.

Here are the trailing returns from 2013 to present:

Here are the annual returns from 2013 to present:

All three aggregate bond ETFs performed virtually identical, barring some minor tracking error in various years. I expect their performance to be nearly identical over time.

The Foolish takeaway

It’s a coin toss between VAB or ZAG for me, simply because either are just a hair cheaper (0.01%) than XBB. All three ETFs are highly liquid and popular and make great passive buy-and-hold picks for a long-term, balanced portfolio.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Tony Dong has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned.

More on Investing

Dollar symbol and Canadian flag on keyboard
Dividend Stocks

3 of the Best Canadian Stocks I’d Buy and Hold Forever

These three stocks have always done well for me and should continue well into the future -- especially with dividends…

Read more »

edit Taxes CRA
Dividend Stocks

Tax Refund: How to Get More Money Back This Year

Resourceful taxpayers will try to find out available tax credits and tax refunds to get their money back in this…

Read more »

protect, safe, trust
Dividend Stocks

How to Build a Bulletproof Monthly Passive Income Portfolio With Just $10,000

The market turned bearish on dividend stocks. Now is the time to buy them at their dip and bulletproof your…

Read more »

edit Person using calculator next to charts and graphs
Investing

The 2 Most Interesting Stocks on the RBC Quant Top 40 List

Quebecor (TSX:QBR.B) and another top stock are among my favourite from RBC's latest quant top-40 list.

Read more »

Businessman holding tablet and showing a growing virtual hologram of statistics, graph and chart with arrow up on dark background. Stock market. Business growth, planning and strategy concept
Dividend Stocks

1 Hidden Catalyst That Could Ignite BCE Stock

BCE (TSX:BCE) stock has been cutting and cutting some more, but it needs to add to its already strong arsenal…

Read more »

Retirement
Dividend Stocks

Got $5,000? Buy and Hold These 3 Value Stocks for Years

Given their healthy growth prospects and attractive valuations, these three stocks offer attractive buying opportunities.

Read more »

Senior Man Sitting On Sofa At Home With Pet Labrador Dog
Dividend Stocks

Should You Take CPP at 65 or 70? Here’s What Research Says

If you take CPP at age 70, you may supplement your income with dividend stocks like Brookfield Asset Management (TSX:BAM)…

Read more »

Increasing yield
Dividend Stocks

Boost Your Passive Income With These 3 High-Yielding Dividend Stocks

These three high-yielding dividend stocks could boost your passive income.

Read more »