Gold vs. Silver: Which Is the Better Buy?

Should you invest in silver stocks or in gold stocks like Barrick Gold (TSX:ABX)(NYSE:GOLD)?

| More on:

Gold and silver are two of the most popular metals on earth. Both have been used as money since ancient times, and both are used extensively in industry today. Gold is used in electronics due to its excellent electrical conductivity (i.e., tendency to conduct electricity), while silver is used to make high-quality cutlery, among other things.

Gold and silver have different uses. But in one way, they’re very similar: they’re both popular investments. Investors have always speculated on gold and gold stocks; many are betting on silver today, too. There are many different ways to invest in either of these metals. The question is, which is a better buy?

The case for silver

One advantage of silver over gold is that it’s more useful for bartering with. Gold is so valuable that it’s not really practical to trade for small items. A single gold coin costs about $2,300 these days, you’d have to break it down into tiny fragments in order to barter it for day-to-day purchases. A silver coin could easily be traded for $50 or $100 worth of goods. If you’re interested in precious metals, not for expected returns, but for “collapse of civilization” insurance, silver makes more sense than gold.

The case for gold

There are many advantages of investing in gold over silver.

If you’re looking to buy physical metal, you’ll find that gold isn’t anywhere near as “marked up” as silver is. Because silver is not all that expensive, coin makers have to mark up its price to turn a profit on it. Often, silver coins are more expensive to buy from vendors than the silver market price would indicate. There’s a mark-up with gold too, but not nearly as much. Gold coins sell for thousands of dollars, so you don’t need to mark them up as much to earn a profit.

Also, if you want to bet on precious metals in the form of stocks, gold gives you more options than silver does. Gold mining stocks are extremely well covered and well known.

Barrick Gold (TSX:ABX)(NYSE:GOLD) has been trading on the TSX for decades. With a $28 billion market cap, it’s a fairly large company. You’ll have no trouble finding news, analysis, and data on a big company like Barrick. With silver stocks, you might have a harder time getting to the bottom of the story. Many of Canada’s silver stocks are smaller companies trading on the TSX venture exchange — an exchange comprised of stocks too small to list on the TSX. It’s a much less liquid market, and the stocks on it are generally riskier than the likes of Barrick Gold.

Foolish takeaway

The bottom line on gold and silver is that your choice to invest in either one is personal. Silver is probably better as a form of disaster insurance, gold if you’re looking to make gains in the stock market. In any case, it wouldn’t hurt to diversify your portfolio into precious metals, just in case the stock market disappoints.

Fool contributor Andrew Button has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned.

More on Metals and Mining Stocks

gold prices rise and fall
Metals and Mining Stocks

Down 1% After Earnings, Is Franco-Nevada a Good Stock to Buy Now?

Franco-Nevada stock could be a good long-term hedge for fiat currency and inflation, especially when the stock pulls back meaningfully…

Read more »

panning for gold uncovers nuggets and flakes
Metals and Mining Stocks

Down 5% After Earnings, Is Barrick Gold a Good Stock to Buy Now?

Barrick Gold stock slid after record Q2 production and a $4 billion Newmont deal. Here's whether the pullback is a…

Read more »

bank of canada governor tiff macklem
Metals and Mining Stocks

1 Stock That Could Surge as Canada Launches Tariff Retaliation

Tariffs could tilt more Canadian steel orders toward Algoma, but only if its turnaround and new furnaces deliver in time.

Read more »

investor looks at volatility chart
Stocks for Beginners

The Best Undervalued Stocks I’d Buy Right Now

Two profitable Canadian royalty stocks have slipped into “oversold” territory (RSI below 30), potentially creating a rare clearance moment near…

Read more »

todder holds a gold bar
Metals and Mining Stocks

1 Canadian Stock I’d Buy as Trade Tensions Heat Up Again

As trade tensions between Canada and the U.S. heat up again, this Canadian royalty giant could offer investors the stability…

Read more »

Metals
Stocks for Beginners

1 Stock That Could Surge as Canada Launches Tariff Retaliation

A 25% tariff can shift buying toward Canadian suppliers, and Algoma Steel is a beaten-down way to bet on that…

Read more »

panning for gold uncovers nuggets and flakes
Metals and Mining Stocks

1 Canadian Dividend Stock Down 38% to Hold Forever

If you're searching for a top Canadian dividend stock to buy on weakness, this overlooked gold miner deserves a closer…

Read more »

The letters AI glowing on a circuit board processor.
Metals and Mining Stocks

AI Needs Power: This Canadian Stock Could Help Supply it

A pre-production Canadian uranium developer is positioning to ride the AI power boom as nuclear demand comes back.

Read more »