Better Buy: Boston Pizza Stock or Pizza Pizza Stock?

Both Pizza Pizza and Boston Pizza are excellent high-yield dividend stocks, but which is the better buy for investors in this environment?

| More on:
question marks written reminders tickets

Image source: Getty Images

The stock market offers investors tonnes of options that cater to different investor preferences. Some stocks are ideal for growth investors, and others, like restaurant royalty stocks, are made for dividend investors. For instance, Boston Pizza Royalties (TSX:BPF.UN) stock has a current dividend yield of approximately 8.1%, while Pizza Pizza Royalty (TSX:PZA) offers a yield of around 6.4%.

However, although these stocks may offer significant and attractive yields, restaurants could also face significant headwinds in the short term, especially if a major recession materializes before the end of the year.

So, it’s essential to ensure that these dividends are safe today and that these stocks have a margin of safety in case sales drop off.

While the pandemic was unprecedented and not necessarily comparable to a recession, the effect it had on many restaurant stocks goes to show that challenges in the economic environment can certainly impact their sales and income.

Luckily for investors, royalty stocks are some of the easiest stocks you can analyze due to their straightforward business models. So, let’s look at which stock is the better buy today: Boston Pizza or Pizza Pizza.

Is Boston Pizza’s 8.1% dividend safe?

Boston Pizza is an interesting stock to consider, because it’s the number one casual dining brand in Canada. While both Boston Pizza and Pizza Pizza are restaurants and both are primarily pizza places, Boston Pizza is a restaurant where most customers dine in compared to Pizza Pizza, which is more of a quick-service restaurant.

These are significant differences and could result in much different impacts on each business as the economic environment worsens.

Typically, due to the higher costs of Boston Pizza’s offerings, the restaurant stock will likely see a bigger hit to its sales as a result of a recession.

For example, at the start of the pandemic, Boston Pizza’s sales fell by over 50% in the first full quarter of the pandemic and over 30% in the first full year. In addition, it suspended its dividend entirely for the first six months of the pandemic, and when it was reinstated, its dividend was 36% lower than where it was before the pandemic.

Of course, these numbers were impacted by a slowdown in the economy but also largely due to the fact that there were lockdowns and restrictions on indoor capacity for months after the pandemic hit.

It’s also worth pointing out, though, that there was also an uptick in delivery orders during that period, allowing both stocks to offset some of their lost sales.

Nevertheless, it’s clear that Boston Pizza was impacted far greater than Pizza Pizza stock, and that looks like it would be the case again.

Not only is its yield higher than Pizza Pizza’s, suggesting that investors think the stock could have more risk, but its dividend is also just now back to the same payout it was pre-pandemic.

However, what’s positive for investors looking at Boston Pizza is that it has a payout ratio of just 83% today, giving it some margin of safety.

Is Pizza Pizza the better choice?

Although Pizza Pizza is also a discretionary restaurant stock, it does have more potential to weather a storm, as we saw in the pandemic due to the fact that it’s a low-cost option in addition to consistently innovating its menu to offer healthy options and having its own in-house delivery service, which can make it more appealing to consumers.

In fact, during the pandemic, its sales fell by just 14.5% in the first quarter and just 13.4% in the first full year, which is much less than the impact Boston Pizza saw.

Furthermore, while Pizza Pizza immediately cut its dividend by 30%, it never had to suspend it. And today, its dividend is slightly higher than where it was prior to the pandemic.

So, although both stocks have recovered well, Pizza Pizza saw a much smaller impact on its sales. With that being said, though, Pizza Pizza’s payout ratio today is 99%, leaving almost no margin of safety.

Therefore, although Boston Pizza has slightly more risk in this environment, it also has a better margin of safety with its dividend, giving it the slight edge for investors looking to buy a restaurant royalty stock today.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Daniel Da Costa has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Dividend Stocks

Aircraft wing plane
Dividend Stocks

Is Bombardier Stock a Buy After Missing its Earnings Estimates?

After going past its earnings estimates, Bombardier stock looks like an excellent holding right now.

Read more »

Businessperson's Hand Putting Coin In Piggybank
Dividend Stocks

RRSP Ready: 2 Stellar Stocks for Your Annual Contribution

Two high-yield stocks are ideal options if you plan to maximize your annual RRSP contribution limits and reduce taxable income.

Read more »

grow dividends
Dividend Stocks

3 Stocks That Could Be Easy Wealth Builders

Long-term investors would be wise to have these three Canadian stocks on their radar.

Read more »

question marks written reminders tickets
Dividend Stocks

Dividend Investors: Is BCE Stock a Buy Now?

BCE now offers a 7.9% dividend yield.

Read more »

edit Taxes CRA
Dividend Stocks

CRA Money: 2 More Days to Boost Your Tax Refund!

Dividend stocks like Toronto-Dominion Bank (TSX:TD) can be great RRSP holdings.

Read more »

grow money, wealth build
Dividend Stocks

3 TSX Dividend Stocks With Yields Above 7% (But Are They Safe?)

These three dividend stocks all have ultra-high yields, making them some of the best to buy if you're looking to…

Read more »

Light bulb with jester hat perched on top
Dividend Stocks

3 Canadian Dividend Stocks With Payouts That Are No Joke 

Here are three top Canadian dividend stocks long-term investors would be remiss to ignore, particularly at these current valuations.

Read more »

clock time
Dividend Stocks

Is it Too Late to Buy These 3 Brilliant Passive Income Stocks?         

TD Bank stock is just one of three stocks that are well positioned to continue to provide passive income for…

Read more »