Better TSX Dividend Stock: Nutrien or Barrick Gold?

Barrick Gold (TSX:ABX) stock is getting way too cheap to ignore after its latest slump.

The Canadian community scene seems rich with swelling dividend yields these days. Undoubtedly, 2022 was a year when various commodity stocks gained considerable ground over the likes of big tech, which crumbled under the pressure of Federal Reserve interest rate hikes. Now that the Fed has shown signs of slowing, the script has flipped, with tech leading while various resilient commodity plays are now dragging their feet, at least on a relative basis.

As we head into the second half of the year, I think that we could see the script flipped, yet again. Not to say technology stocks are overpriced or bubbly. Though a few names may be, I simply think there’s more upside to be had in some of the value names. If there’s a rotation back towards value once again, I’d look for the TSX Index (which is lagging behind the S&P 500 so far this year) to play catch up.

So, if you think the tech trade is getting a tad too hot, the following names may make it easier for you to sleep at night. Without further ado, consider Canadian fertilizer firm Nutrien (TSX: NTR) and gold-mining top dog Barrick Gold (TSX: ABX). Though commodity prices haven’t been as hot as they used to be, I continue to view them as worthy portfolio diversifiers for any investor who seeks to maximize their risk/reward tradeoff.

Companies like Nutrien and Barrick Gold won’t make you quick gains like tech stocks did at the start of 2023. What they can do is help expose you to areas of the market that may be in a spot to ride out market-wide turbulence. At the end of the day, a more diversified portfolio is never a bad thing.

Canada’s commodity producers (Nutrien for agricultural commodities and Barrick for precious metals) are among the best on the planet. And as negative momentum builds, I think the odds of getting a great bargain will improve with time.

Safety helmets and gloves hang from a rack on a mining site.

Source: Getty Images

Nutrien

Nutrien stock shed around half of its value from peak to trough before its latest march higher. Shares are up around 10% from their May lows and could be in a spot to gain even more ground, as investors forgive the company for its weak first-quarter result. Potash prices are down considerably from their highs. However, Nutrien continues to be one of the best-in-breed producers.

Though potash demand could continue to be weighed down in the medium term, I still find potash (and similar fertilizers) will be in high demand as the world population swells. More people means more food. To get more food, greater crop yields will be needed, and that calls for more fertilizer.

Commodities can fall into funks, and when they do, investors may wish to average into a position. At writing, Nutrien shares sport a nice 3.6% dividend yield.

Barrick Gold

Gold is a rather speculative asset, but it’s also a great hedge and portfolio diversifier for investors seeking to construct the ultimate all-weather portfolio.

Today, gold stocks are still off considerably from their highs, even as gold stabilizes in the US$1,900 range. Barrick stock is off 45% from its all-time high, and though gold seems to be retreating steadily off its latest peak, I think that once rates begin to retreat, gold may have room to run.

Further, Barrick’s dividend (yielding 2.42%) is bountiful and could grow if gold does find its footing again. As the Fed pauses, the next step may be small rate cuts. Such rate cuts could set the stage for a nice rally, in my opinion.

Better buy: ABX or NTR stock?

Barrick stock looks like a better bet here, even if the dividend yield isn’t as impressive. I’m a big fan of gold as a diversifier for those inevitable rainy days. As recession nears, there could be many more rainy days to come.

Fool contributor Joey Frenette has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Nutrien. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Metals and Mining Stocks

Stacked gold bars
Metals and Mining Stocks

2 Mining Stocks I’d Buy as Carney Courts Global Investors

As Carney courts global investors to strengthen Canada’s trade and economy, these two Canadian mining stocks offer solid financials and…

Read more »

Nuclear power station cooling tower
Metals and Mining Stocks

Cameco Stock Has Fallen 10%: But the Business Isn’t Broken, so Here’s Why I’d Buy

Down 10% on temporary maintenance, Cameco’s nuclear thesis is far from broken. Here's why this pullback is a prime buy…

Read more »

gold prices rise and fall
Stocks for Beginners

Gold May Be Pulling Back From Record Highs, but I’d Still Buy This Royalty Stock

Franco-Nevada offers precious-metal exposure without taking on every expense of running a mine.

Read more »

nugget gold
Stocks for Beginners

Gold is Back Above US$4,000: This Streamer Down 15% in a Month Could be a Steal

Wheaton's falling share price offers a fresh look at a business that earns from precious metals without operating the mines.

Read more »

Investor reading the newspaper
Stocks for Beginners

Steel is Back in the Headlines: This Iron Ore Royalty Pays You to Watch

Labrador Iron Ore Royalty offers a variable dividend, with mine recovery carrying more weight than steel-policy headlines.

Read more »

financial chart graphs and oil pumps on a field
Dividend Stocks

This TSX Royalty Stock Pays Its Monthly Dividend Today: The Payout Math Behind It

Freehold pays eligible shareholders today, with a $10,000 investment offering about $52 monthly at the current dividend.

Read more »

panning for gold uncovers nuggets and flakes
Stocks for Beginners

Gold Pulled Back From Its Record: This Royalty Stock Raised Its Dividend 18%

OR Royalties offers a different way to own gold exposure, with strong dividend coverage and a modest starting yield.

Read more »

gold prices rise and fall
Stocks for Beginners

Gold is Near $4,200: This Miner Pays You to Wait

Agnico's cash position supports its dividend, but gold-price sensitivity and a modest starting yield define what investors actually receive.

Read more »