Better Buy: Nutrien Stock or Mosaic Stock?

Nutrien stock offers a better dividend yield and wider fertilizer market exposure. However, Mosaic stock has attractive qualities, too.

| More on:
Safety helmets and gloves hang from a rack on a mining site.

Source: Getty Images

Fertilizer stocks entered a protracted decline in 2023 as crop nutrients’ prices normalized following a surge triggered by Russian aggression over Ukraine (and subsequent international responses to the conflict). However, industry stocks are back in focus in October following Hamas’ surprise attacks on Israel. Nutrien (TSX:NTR) stock gained 7% within a week, and Mosaic Company (NYSE:MOS) stock is up 8.4% during the same period.

Market players are concerned that a new war in Israel could draw Iran into the conflict and cause another wave of disruptions to global fertilizer supply chains. Iran was the world’s 11th-biggest chemical fertilizer exporter during the 2021-2022 farming season.

Naturally, I do not seek to profit from wars; however, the fertilizer market is a key primary market and remains a promising investment destination for intergenerational wealth builders as the industry strives to feed a growing global population.

Nutrien and Mosaic are potentially high-rewarding, long-term investments to consider in a retirement account. Let’s have a closer look at each fertilizer stock with a view to buying the best among the two.

Nutrien stock

At US$45.1 billion in revenue during the past 12 months, Nutrien is a big player in the fertilizer and crop inputs trade, and it’s one of the 500 largest companies by annual revenue globally. The company gained market share internationally following a Russian fallout with several trading partners. Its expansionary acquisitions in Brazil could be sources of new growth over the long term.

That said, softer global fertilizer markets in 2023 necessitated significant asset impairments and goodwill write-downs during the second quarter of this year — an acknowledgment that acquired assets aren’t likely to perform as originally expected. Nutrien impaired the book value of one of its mines (which has a shorter life span) by US$233 million and acknowledged a US$ 465 million goodwill write-down — mostly on its recently acquired retail assets in South America in August.

Although Nutrien’s revenue of US$17.8 billion during the first half of 2023 printed a 19.9% year-over-year decline, competitors, including Mosaic, have seen worse declines. The industry giant has a resilient business that continues to generate positive free cash flow during the softer market, and management remains committed to share repurchases and dividend raises.

New investors in Nutrien stock today may earn quarterly dividends that yield 3.4% annually before expected raises next year. Bay Street analysts rate Nutrien stock a Buy with an average analyst price target of $107.94, which implies a 31% potential upside over the next 12 months.

Nutrien stock trades cheaply at a forward price-to-earnings (P/E) multiple of 11.6 times next year’s expected earnings per share.

Mosaic stock

Phosphate and potash producer Mosaic is a United States-based US$11.8 billion company that generated US$16.8 billion in revenue over the past 12 months. Mosaic rode the wave of a fertilizer market boom in 2022 to post a 54% annual revenue growth for the year. However, revenue dropped by 24.7% year over year during the first half of 2023, and margins have contracted.

Unlike Nutrien, which recognized significant goodwill write-downs this year, Mosaic hasn’t touched its US$1.1 billion goodwill balance yet. Management still believes that acquired assets have the capacity to generate revenue, operating earnings, and cash flows well in line with previous estimates.

An investment in Mosaic stock could generate about 2.2% in annual dividend yield. The non-Canadian company’s dividend may not be eligible for Canadian tax credits, and its net yield may fall further behind Nutrien’s nominal 3.4% dividend yield once Canadian taxes kick in.

Wall Street analysts recommend investors Hold onto their Mosaic stock, with an average analyst price target of US$45.30, which implies more than 26% in potential upside over the next 12 months.

Most noteworthy, Mosaic stock trades cheaper than Nutrien stock, given a forward P/E of 10.5.

Which fertilizer stock to buy?

Nutrien stock offers wider exposure to the global agricultural inputs market and pays a marginally higher dividend yield out of the bat. Future dividend raises may get investors to a 5% annual yield faster than Mosaic stock can.

That said, Mosaic stock is a tad cheaper than Nutrien stock, given its lower earnings multiples.

Most noteworthy, although both stocks pay U.S. dollar-denominated dividends, Mosaic is a U.S. stock that carries added currency-related risks than Nutrien since it’s a foreign stock that trades in U.S. dollars on an American exchange.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Brian Paradza has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Nutrien. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Metals and Mining Stocks

tsx today
Metals and Mining Stocks

TSX Today: What to Watch for in Stocks on Friday, November 10

Renewed expectations of more interest rate hikes and corporate earnings are likely to keep the TSX index volatile today.

Read more »

Businessman holding tablet and showing a growing virtual hologram of statistics, graph and chart with arrow up on dark background. Stock market. Business growth, planning and strategy concept
Dividend Stocks

Rate-Proof Your Returns: The Best Defensive Stocks for Canadians in a Rising Interest Rate Climate 

Has your portfolio lost value in the last two years from aggressive interest rate hikes? Here’s a way to rate-proof…

Read more »

Gold king in chess game face with the another silver team on black background (Concept for company strategy, business victory or decision)
Metals and Mining Stocks

4 Top Precious Metals Stocks to Buy on the TSX Today

Precious metals stocks are safe havens but one small-cap and three large-cap mining stocks are the top buys today.

Read more »

tsx today
Metals and Mining Stocks

TSX Today: What to Watch for in Stocks on Wednesday, November 8

The Fed’s chair Jerome Powell’s speech, corporate earnings, and volatile commodity prices will remain on TSX investors’ radar today.

Read more »

tsx today
Metals and Mining Stocks

TSX Today: What to Watch for in Stocks on Tuesday, November 7

The ongoing weakness in crude oil and precious metals prices could pressure the TSX index at the open today.

Read more »

People walk into a dark underground mine.
Metals and Mining Stocks

2 Top TSX Mining and Materials Stocks to Buy for November 2023

Agnico Eagle Mines (TSX:AEM) and another mining play are looking stupidly cheap going into the year's end.

Read more »

tsx today
Metals and Mining Stocks

TSX Today: What to Watch for in Stocks on Thursday, November 2

The ongoing earnings season could keep TSX stocks volatile today, as investors continue to assess the Fed’s latest monetary policy…

Read more »

tsx today
Metals and Mining Stocks

TSX Today: What to Watch for in Stocks on Wednesday, November 1

The Fed’s monetary policy event, corporate results, and several other key economic releases could keep TSX stocks highly volatile today.

Read more »