Better Buy Today: TD Stock or CIBC Shares?

Canada’s second- and fifth-largest Big Banks are both rock-solid investments but one is the slightly better choice today.

| More on:
edit Close-up Of A Piggybank With Eyeglasses And Calculator On Desk

Image source: Getty Images

Canadian banks blossomed from mere deposit takers and lenders to protectors of investors. People refer to Canada’s banking sector as a bedrock of stability. The term isn’t an exaggeration because the “Big Six” are profitable and have delivered healthy, long-term returns.

Choosing which Big Bank stock to invest in today could be confusing, even if it’s between the second- and fifth-largest banks. The Toronto Dominion Bank (TSX:TD) is three times larger than the Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (TSX:CM), but it doesn’t mean the smaller bank is an inferior investment.

Longevity and size

The two Big Five banks are products of mergers, and the merged banks or their founders were established between 1855 and 1879. TD was formed on February 1, 1955, while CIBC’s date of birth was June 1, 1961. Size-wise, the former has the edge, at a $154.2 billion market cap versus $50.1 billion.

Share price and dividends

CIBC should have the nod of price-conscious investors as its share price is $54.22 compared to TD’s $84.98. Yield-thirsty investors will choose CIBC (6.49%) over TD (4.56%) because of the higher dividend yield. However, TD has a longer dividend track record.

TD has been paying dividends since 1857 (if you include the old chartered banks), while CIBC started sharing a portion of its profits with shareholders in 1868. Either bank’s more than 100 years of dividend payments is not in danger and will continue for decades.

Interestingly, TD and CIBC also rank second and fifth on 20-year performance and dividend growth (Bloomberg Finance data as of February 28, 2023). TD’s is 12.87% and 586%, respectively, against CIBC’s 9.84% and 315%.

Position of strength

In Q3 fiscal 2023, TD’s net income decreased 7.8% to $2.96 billion, and provision for credit losses (PCL) increased 28% to $799 million versus Q3 fiscal 2023. Still, Bharat Masrani, the Group’s President and CEO, said the strong revenue growth (10.7% year over year to $12.8 billion) demonstrates the value of TD’s diversified business mix in a challenging economic environment.

TD terminated the agreement to purchase First Horizon in the U.S., but completed the acquisition of Cowen. The combination with the full-service investment bank will expand, strengthen, and accelerate the growth of TD’s Wholesale Banking segment. “As we look ahead, TD is in a position of strength, with a growing franchise and a strong capital position,” added Masrani.

Strong momentum

CIBC’s revenue in Q3 fiscal 2023 increased 5% to $5.9 billion, although net income dropped 14% to $1.4 billion versus Q3 fiscal 2022 due to higher PCL (+202.9% year over year to $736 million). The bank has a sizeable mortgage exposure but is amply covered by PCL if credit quality deteriorates.

Nevertheless, its President and CEO, Victor Dodig, said CIBC delivered solid financial results. He also expects the core business’s strong momentum to continue. CIBC shares are up 3.8% year to date, while TD’s positive return is 1.3%.

Staying power

Staying power is the common denominator between TD and CIBC.  Both banks will not disappoint in protecting your capital and sustaining quarterly dividend payments. While both stocks are not immune from market headwinds, they have recovered historically from downturns.

TD is the better choice today, but only slightly. The giant bank is the only company that reported revenue and income growth during the infamous financial crisis.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Christopher Liew has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Bank Stocks

Mature financial advisor showing report to young couple for their investment
Bank Stocks

3 Top Financial Stocks to Buy on the TSX Today

The top financial stocks to buy on the TSX today are two small lenders and one Big Bank.

Read more »

data analyze research
Stocks for Beginners

3 Common Tax Mistakes Canadian Investors Continue to Make

If you're reflecting on mistakes, these are the most likely ones you're making. And if fixing even one on this…

Read more »

Man considering whether to sell or buy
Dividend Stocks

TD Stock: Buy, Sell, or Hold?

TD stock (TSX:TD) plunged as the company looks to have more expenses on the books for the next year. So…

Read more »

Dividend Stocks

My 2 Favourite TSX Dividend Stocks for December 2023

These dividend stocks continue to see buy recommendations from analysts, and are the top choices in their sectors. So now…

Read more »

Dollar symbol and Canadian flag on keyboard
Bank Stocks

2 Canadian Stocks for Beginners in December 2023

Now could be an excellent time to begin investing in the stock market. Here are two companies to add to…

Read more »

tsx today
Bank Stocks

TSX Today: What to Watch for in Stocks on Friday, December 8

Rebounding commodity prices could lift the TSX index at the open today, as investors await important labour market data from…

Read more »

data analyze research
Bank Stocks

Better Bank Buy: TD Stock or CIBC Stock?

These bank stocks didn't exactly do amazing during fourth quarter earnings, but which is now a deal, and which is…

Read more »

data analytics, chart and graph icons with female hands typing on laptop in background
Bank Stocks

Better Buy: Royal Bank of Canada Stock or Toronto-Dominion Bank?

TD and Royal Bank are moving higher. Is one stock still oversold?

Read more »