Better Buy in February 2024: Magna Stock vs. Aritzia Stock

When it comes to long-term growth, which is the better buy: Magna (TSX:MG) stock or Aritzia (TSX:ATZ) stock on the TSX today?

We’re starting to look back at February, and seeing where some companies thrived and others fell after earnings. Two of the companies that investors now may want to consider after earnings then are Magna International (TSX: MG) and Aritzia (TSX: ATZ). Both companies had strong performance and a history of growth stock status in the past. But are these two headed towards more of that in the future?

Here’s which one I would consider on the TSX today between Magna stock and Artizia stock.

data analyze research

Image source: Getty Images

Magna stock

When it comes to Magna stock, investors are likely looking ahead. The company has a strong outlook, given its exposure to electric vehicle (EV) production. While Magna stock has already seen growth in this area, it still brings in a lot from internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles as well. Every car has electronic components now, making the transition a seamless one for the company.

There is also an increasing demand for lightweight materials, and Magna stock has taken the call. It’s now a leader in developing and manufacturing lightweight materials, helping to improve fuel efficiency as well as battery life in EVs.

While the stock faces competition on a global scale, here in Canada, it’s an industry leader. And this has been seen in its recent performance. After poor results during the pandemic, Magna stock has been coming back strong. The company reported diluted earnings per share (EPS) of US$0.94, triple the year before. For the year, it hit US$4.23, up from US$4.16 a year earlier.

Meanwhile, shares of the stock trade at 12.84 times earnings and offer a 3.47% dividend yield. Shares are now back to where they were a year ago, seeing growth of 11% since the market bottomed in October. It now looks like it’s a valuable time to pick up the stock, especially for long-term shareholders.

Aritzia stock

Then there’s Aritzia stock, a company that had the opposite position during the pandemic. The company surged with more United States growth than ever. It went on to open more and more locations across the country, seeing shares climb in response. It helps that people such as Meghan Markle seem to wear their stuff as well.

But there’s more than just celebrity status for the company. Aritzia stock is latching on to the continued growth of the women’s apparel market, especially in the United States. This is expected to reach US$2.2 trillion by 2027, driven by more disposable income and increasing demand for online shopping.

Plus, the company is marketed as “everyday luxury,” catering to customers who can afford to pay a premium for quality and design. And now, customers can pick up through online and physical stores, with more plans to expand.

But does it seem too valuable with all this good news? During the latest quarter, Aritzia stock reported EPS of $0.47, which was down from $0.67 the year before. Even so, revenue climbed 5%, despite net income dropping 39%. If you’re wondering if it’s valuable, Aritzia stock certainly thinks so; it recently approved an automatic share-repurchase plan. Still, it trades at 43.53 times earnings over the last year, with shares down 16%. Shares have climbed 67% though since November bottoms, so there could be more on the way.

Bottom line

Aritzia stock, to me, just looks too volatile at these levels. Growth should stabilize in the near future, and when it does so will the stock. And that’s the time I would pick it up. Meanwhile, Magna stock has a stable and bright future ahead — especially through the use of EVs, and that should last for a decade at least! And with a dividend on top, it’s what I would consider on the TSX today.

Fool contributor Amy Legate-Wolfe has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Aritzia. The Motley Fool recommends Magna International. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Stocks for Beginners

atomic particle
Tech Stocks

Constellation Software in a TFSA: Great Business, but Is the Price Right?

Constellation’s acquisition engine appeals, while a cash-flow valuation check argues for patience.

Read more »

A series of red ladders lead to successively higher levels
Dividend Stocks

Is Brookfield Stock a Buy, Sell, or Hold for 2027?

Is Brookfield stock a buy, sell or hold for 2027? Explore its latest earnings, insurance expansion and potential for long-term…

Read more »

Blocks conceptualizing Canada's Tax Free Savings Account
Dividend Stocks

How Much Would You Need in a TFSA to Replace a $500 Monthly Bill?

Replacing a $500 monthly bill starts with a realistic capital target and an income plan that can grow.

Read more »

traders work at stock exchange
Stocks for Beginners

Canadian Bank Stocks: Buy, Sell, or Hold for 2027?

Explore the Big Six, their latest earnings and dividend yields, with income and defensive picks.

Read more »

trading chart of brent crude oil prices
Energy Stocks

Suncor Stock: The Dividend Test I’d Use When Oil Prices Swing

Suncor’s dividend increase needs to be assessed beside cash after investment and a weaker-oil stress test.

Read more »

groceries get more expensive as inflation rises
Dividend Stocks

What $25,000 in Manulife Could Add to Your Annual Dividend Income

A $25,000 Manulife budget provides about $755 annually, with a clear trade-off between spending and reinvesting.

Read more »

Canadian investor contemplating U.S. stocks with multiple doors to choose from.
Dividend Stocks

Great-West Lifeco vs. Manulife: Which Insurance Stock Would I Buy for Income?

Manulife gets a narrow income preference, while Great-West offers a strong retirement-and-wealth alternative.

Read more »

man shops at grocery store
Dividend Stocks

Choice Properties Pays Monthly: Does the Yield Compensate for Higher Rates?

Choice’s yield deserves a closer look at cash after property spending and financing costs.

Read more »