They’re Down More Than 23% This Year, So Are These Stocks a Bargain — or Buyer Beware?

Both stocks appear to be cheap, but Constellation Software seems to be the better buy based on its track record of execution.

| More on:
man looks worried about something on his phone

Source: Getty Images

Key Points

  • Both Constellation Software (TSX:CSU) and CGI (TSX:GIB.A) are down over 23% in 2025 yet trade at notable analyst-implied discounts (Constellation ~37% undervalued; CGI ~23%).
  • Constellation is a deeper value play after AI fears and CEO Mark Leonard’s exit but with strong free cash flow and ~58% implied upside, while CGI’s weakness is operational/temporary with improving adjusted EPS, solid cash generation and ~30% implied upside.
  • 5 stocks our experts like better than Constellation Software

When the broader Canadian market surges more than 20% in a year, yet some large tech stocks tumble over 20%, investors have to ask: Is something fundamentally broken, or is the market offering a rare chance to buy quality at a discount? Two tech companies — Constellation Software (TSX:CSU) and CGI (TSX:GIB.A) — have stumbled hard in 2025. Let’s see if their drops spell danger or opportunity.

Constellation Software: A rare dip in a long winning streak

Constellation Software has long been a darling of the Canadian market, compounding wealth through its disciplined mergers-and-acquisitions (M&A) strategy. 

Yet even this market favourite isn’t immune to turbulence. The stock plunged more than 25% year to date, rattled first by investor anxiety about how artificial intelligence (AI) might reshape the software landscape, and then by news that founder and CEO Mark Leonard was stepping down from his role as president after 30 years due to health reasons.

Despite the leadership shock, Constellation’s fundamentals remain solid. Year to date, the company reported 15% revenue growth to US$8.45 billion, while net income slipped 6.3% to US$420 million and earnings per share (EPS) fell 9.9% to US$18.96. Crucially, free cash flow surged 27% to US$1.26 billion — a sign the business remains highly profitable beneath the headline volatility.

After this correction, Constellation trades at what analysts view as a steep discount, with the consensus price target implying roughly 37% undervaluation and potential upside of about 58% from its current price near $3,305 per share. 

The stock has multiplied sevenfold over the past decade, and if management can sustain its proven M&A engine, investors could still see annualized returns of 15–25% over the next few years. In short, this looks less like a collapse and more like a golden pause.

CGI: A resilient operator in a rough patch

CGI is another tech heavyweight on the TSX that has lost its footing this year, dropping over 23%. The reasons are less dramatic than Constellation’s — more operational than existential. The firm has struggled with slower organic growth compared to peers and restructuring costs in its Continental European operations, which are temporarily dragging results.

In its fiscal 2025 results, CGI reported 8.4% revenue growth to $15.9 billion. Net income slipped 2% to $1.66 billion, but adjusted earnings rose 6% to $1.87 billion, and adjusted EPS climbed 8.9% to $8.30. The company emphasized that in the fourth quarter, it delivered strong cash generation and double-digit EPS expansion, driven by AI-enhanced managed services and a share-buyback program.

Analysts estimate the shares are currently undervalued by about 23%, trading near $120 per share — implying a potential 30% upside. CGI’s solid balance sheet with an investment-grade S&P credit rating of BBB+ and consistent execution of long-term earnings growth suggest its struggles should be short term.

Two quality names: One bigger bargain

Both Constellation Software and CGI have been punished this year, but not because their business models are failing. Their short-term earnings dips have compressed valuations to levels rarely seen in quality Canadian tech. For investors seeking long-term compounders, both stocks offer appeal — yet Constellation Software stands out as the deeper value play with the more proven compounding record.

Sometimes, the market’s biggest bargains are simply the market’s best stocks taking a breather. Investors just need to practice patience to give the business — and the stock — time to recover and thrive again.

Fool contributor Kay Ng has positions in Constellation Software. The Motley Fool recommends CGI and Constellation Software. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Tech Stocks

investor looks at volatility chart
Tech Stocks

This Soaring Canadian AI Stock Still Trades at a 33% Discount in December 2025

Down 14% from all-time highs, Celestica is an AI stock that trades at a discount to consensus price targets in…

Read more »

data center server racks glow with light
Tech Stocks

Why AI Infrastructure Could Be Canada’s Hidden Asset Boom

Canada’s clean power and land could make it the backbone of AI’s growth, and Hut 8 offers an infrastructure-first way…

Read more »

A person's hand cupped open with a hologram of an AI chatbot above saying Hi, can I help you
Tech Stocks

Shopify Made a Transformative Deal With OpenAI: Is the Stock a Buy?

Shopify (TSX:SHOP) is an AI winner and shares might be too cheap to pass up given the growth catalysts in…

Read more »

Illustration of data, cloud computing and microchips
Tech Stocks

If You’d Invested $1,000 in Celestica Stock 5 Years Ago, This Is How Much You’d Have Now

A $1,000 investment in Celestica stock five years ago would’ve turned into over $45,000 – here’s what made that possible.

Read more »

space ship model takes off
Stocks for Beginners

1 Magnificent Canadian Stock Down 52% to Buy and Hold Forever

While its share price has taken a hit, this Canadian stock is executing well and still seems to have a…

Read more »

visualization of a digital brain
Tech Stocks

This Canadian Tech Stock Could Be a Global Leader, and Soon

Enghouse’s cash-rich, debt-free software model and 70% recurring revenue could quietly turn this Canadian niche player into a global compounder.

Read more »

top TSX stocks to buy
Tech Stocks

My 3 Top Growth Picks for December

For investors looking for more of a growth angle and to play any Santa Claus rally that may arise towards…

Read more »

stocks climbing green bull market
Dividend Stocks

The Best TSX Stocks for Canadians to Buy With $1,000 on Hand

Got $1,000? Three TSX compounders can kick-start long-term growth and add growing income.

Read more »