Have a Few Duds? How to Be Smart About Investment Losses (Tax-Loss Strategies for Canadians)

Tax-loss selling can help Canadians offset capital gains in non-registered accounts, but each underperforming stock should be evaluated carefully before selling.

Key Points
  • Tax-loss selling can help Canadian investors offset capital gains, but each underperforming stock should be evaluated carefully before selling.
  • Some “dud” stocks may actually offer long-term opportunity, making year-end weakness a potential chance to buy quality names at better valuations.
  • 5 stocks our experts like better than Waste Connections

No matter how carefully Canadians build their portfolios, sooner or later every investor ends up holding a few disappointments. The question isn’t whether you’ll encounter losing positions — it’s how you choose to handle them. 

Smart investors know that even a “dud” can offer hidden opportunities, whether through tax planning or contrarian long-term investing. The key is learning to separate genuinely broken investments from temporarily weakened ones.

a person watches a downward arrow crash through the floor

Source: Getty Images

Understanding the mechanics — and purpose — of tax-loss selling

In Canada, tax-loss selling is most commonly executed late in the year, typically through November and December. The goal is to sell losing positions in non-registered accounts to generate capital losses that can offset realized capital gains. Done thoughtfully, this can meaningfully reduce your tax bill.

To apply losses to the current tax year, trades must settle by December 31. Because most Canadian and U.S. securities settle one business day after the trade date, the last eligible trading day for 2025 is Tuesday, December 30. Still, financial advisors often encourage investors to complete any key trades by mid-December to avoid holiday-season volatility.

But tax-loss selling should never become an annual ritual done simply for the sake of “cleaning house.” Before selling anything, ask: “Is this truly a permanent loser, or is it a temporarily underperforming asset with the potential to recover?”

In many cases, future winners begin as volatile laggards. For patient investors, tax-loss season can also be a chance to accumulate quality names at weakened prices.

When “losers” are actually opportunities: 2 stocks worth a second look

CGI: A tech name facing pressure

CGI (TSX: GIB.A) has had a tough year, dropping roughly 21%. That weakness has pushed the stock toward more attractive valuations relative to its historical norm. The softness was driven largely by restructuring costs — particularly in Continental Europe — as well as slower organic growth and heavier debt loads from acquisitions.

Yet the company’s fiscal 2025 results paint a more nuanced picture:

  • Revenue climbed 8.4% to $15.9 billion.
  • Net earnings slipped 2% to $1.7 billion, while diluted EPS inched up 0.5% to $7.35.
  • Adjusted net earnings rose 6% to $1.9 billion and adjusted EPS surged 8.9% to $8.30.
  • The company ended the year with a substantial $31.45-billion backlog.

At roughly $124 per share at writing, the analyst consensus target implies a discount of about 20%, translating to potential near-term upside of more than 24%. 

Management expects meaningful margin recovery in late 2026 or 2027, supported by AI-driven managed services — a runway that suggests patient investors should think in terms of a multi-year horizon rather than a quick trade.

Waste Connections: A rare dip for a long-term compounder

Another interesting case is Waste Connections (TSX: WCN), down about 6% year-to-date — a notable decline for a stock that has been a long-term winner. 

Over the past decade, the company has been more than a 12-bagger, delivering annualized returns close to 29%.

Its business model is simple and essential: providing garbage and recycling services, managing landfills, handling specialized waste streams, and keeping communities functioning smoothly. Here are some highlights in the first nine months of the year:

  • Revenue rose 6.5% to US$7.1 billion.
  • Operating income grew 1.8% to US$1.3 billion.
  • Net income ticked up 0.7% to US$818 million.
  • Diluted EPS improved 0.3% to US$3.16.

In October, the company raised its dividend by 11.1%, a clear signal of management’s confidence.

At about $232 per share at writing, the analyst consensus target indicates a discount of 13% and a potential 15% upside. For long-term investors, this pullback could be an opportunity to ease into a high-quality compounder.

Investor takeaway: Review, don’t react

As December progresses, additional tax-loss pressure can create short-term volatility, especially in stocks already underperforming this year. 

Instead of reacting impulsively, investors should take the time to review their portfolios carefully. Determine whether tax-loss selling makes sense for your situation — and assess which weakened stocks may actually deserve a spot in your long-term strategy. 

Sometimes, the best opportunities come wrapped in a short-term loss.

Fool contributor Kay Ng has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends CGI. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Tech Stocks

atomic particle
Tech Stocks

Constellation Software in a TFSA: Great Business, but Is the Price Right?

Constellation’s acquisition engine appeals, while a cash-flow valuation check argues for patience.

Read more »

Close up of an egg in a nest of twigs on grass with RRSP written on it symbolizing a RRSP contribution.
Dividend Stocks

The RRSP Deadline Is in March: Why Starting in November Gives You the Advantage

Many investors hold stocks like Shopify Inc (TSX:SHOP) in their RRSPs.

Read more »

man studies at computer
Dividend Stocks

Here Are The 3 Canadian Stocks I’d Tell a New Investor to Buy ASAP

Discover strategies for investing in stocks that can help you thrive in a market filled with volatility and uncertainty.

Read more »

Canada Day fireworks over two Adirondack chairs on the wooden dock in Ontario, Canada
Dividend Stocks

Where to Invest Your $7,000 TFSA Contribution Before 2026 Is Over

Put your $7,000 TFSA contribution to work before 2026 ends. Explore BMO, CN and Constellation Software for income and long-term…

Read more »

moving into apartment
Tech Stocks

Your TFSA Contribution Room Could Be Larger Than You Think

Shopify Inc (TSX:SHOP) stock has delivered large returns. Those who cashed out TFSA SHOP positions may have more room than…

Read more »

woman relaxes with phone
Dividend Stocks

BCE Cut its Dividend: Has the Stock Become a Better Income Investment?

BCE’s new payment offers income, but cash after spending still has to support the recovery.

Read more »

A chip in a circuit board says "AI"
Tech Stocks

Celestica Stock: Is AI Growth Worth the Risk in a Retirement Portfolio?

Celestica offers retirement growth potential, with a cash-flow trade-off that deserves more attention than sales alone.

Read more »

A person's hand cupped open with a hologram of an AI chatbot above saying Hi, can I help you
Tech Stocks

CGI vs. OpenText: Which Canadian Tech Stock Offers the Better Long-Term Case?

CGI gets my long-term preference, while OpenText offers a recovery case that still needs stronger sales.

Read more »