CIBC vs. TD: Which Bank Offers the Better Case for a Long-Term TFSA?

The two banks offered almost identical yields at recent prices. I’d use my next TFSA purchase on the business I can better judge from here.

Key Points
  • CIBC reported third-quarter adjusted earnings of $2.73 per share.
  • TD reported adjusted earnings of $2.77 per share and has a different mix of U.S. opportunities and risks.
  • I’d lean towards CIBC today and leave room to buy TD if the price or outlook improves.

Putting two big banks in the same account feels a bit like ordering two kinds of toast. The toppings differ. A lot of what you’re getting underneath is the same. Before choosing one for a long-term Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA), I’d see what each can give me that I don’t already own.

Piggy bank with word TFSA for tax-free savings accounts.

Source: Getty Images

Give the account time to work

Shares inside a TFSA can generally compound free of Canadian tax. Unused room carries forward and withdrawals usually restore room the following calendar year. I’d keep near-term spending elsewhere and give the investments time to work through a slow credit cycle.

A bank earns interest on loans and collects fees, then sets money aside for borrowers who might fall behind. A rising loan book can support earnings when customers keep paying. If unemployment rises or businesses struggle, credit losses can take a bigger share of the profits.

I’d let the money compound through both good and bad years. When a bank has a rough quarter, I’d check whether it’s setting aside more for a temporary slowdown or whether its loans are performing worse than I expected. That distinction can change whether I reinvest the next dividend there.

I’d check what I own before deciding that I need another bank. A broad Canadian fund may already give me plenty of exposure to the industry. If I add a bank on top, I want a reason to prefer its earnings and price over simply buying more of the fund.

Similar cheques, different stories

Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (TSX: CM) earns from Canadian consumer and business banking, wealth and other operations, including in the U.S. Third-quarter adjusted earnings rose to $2.73 per share from $2.16. I’d check how much of that growth can continue when loan losses and fee income are less favourable.

Toronto-Dominion Bank (TSX: TD) has a large Canadian franchise and a sizeable U.S. retail operation. Adjusted earnings rose to $2.77 per share from $2.20 in its third quarter. Its U.S. recovery could give shareholders more growth, and restrictions tied to its anti-money-laundering failures are still part of what I’m buying.

CIBC’s $1.07 quarterly dividend annualizes to $4.28. TD’s $1.12 works out to $4.48. At recent prices of $162.69 and $172.92, both yields round to 2.6%. I’d leave the dividend to break a tie only after I’ve decided which earnings I’d rather own.

Considerations

On separate $10,000 budgets, CIBC buys 61 shares for $9,924.09 and starts with $261.08 of annual income. TD buys 57 shares for $9,856.44 and starts with $255.36. The figures assume the dividend rates stay put and exclude fees. A few dollars a year doesn’t settle this one.

COMPANYRECENT PRICENUMBER OF SHARESANNUAL DIVIDENDANNUAL TOTAL PAYOUTFREQUENCYTOTAL INVESTMENT
CM$162.6961$4.28$261.08Quarterly$9,924.09
TD$172.9257$4.48$255.36Quarterly$9,856.44

I’d lean towards CIBC at these prices. I can build my case around how well it serves existing customers and manages credit. TD gives me a different opportunity if its U.S. operations improve, and I’d want more room in the price for the time that could take.

There’s also room to change my mind if the price moves. A bank I’d pass on at one price can make sense at another. I’d compare what each can earn after a sensible allowance for loan losses before giving either one more room in the account.

I wouldn’t make either of them the biggest source of income in a TFSA already heavy in Canadian dividend stocks. Both depend on borrowers continuing to pay, and a weaker economy can hit several banks at once. My next purchase would be sized with the rest of my account in mind.

Bottom line

I’d buy CIBC for a long holding period and revisit TD when I can get more of its recovery at a price I like. The dividend can do its work in the meantime while I watch how each bank earns the next raise.

Fool contributor Amy Legate-Wolfe has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Stocks for Beginners

dividends can compound over time
Energy Stocks

Algonquin Stock: Income Opportunity or Another Yield Trap?

Algonquin’s latest results show progress. I’d still need more evidence that the utility can fund the dividend after investing in…

Read more »

A woman stands on an apartment balcony in a city
Dividend Stocks

Retiring in 5 Years? How I’d Build a $300 Monthly Dividend Target

Five years gives you time to build a $300 monthly income target, especially if you start with capital and make…

Read more »

Person holds banknotes of Canadian dollars
Stocks for Beginners

$1,000 Is Enough to Start Investing in Canada – Really

New investors shouldn't underestimate the power of time in the market.

Read more »

A plant grows from coins.
Dividend Stocks

How I’d Reinvest $200 a Month in Dividends to Build a Bigger Income Stream

A $200 paycheque in dividends won’t buy much of a portfolio today. Repeated every month, it can build a second…

Read more »

gold prices rise and fall
Stocks for Beginners

Agnico Eagle Stock: The Cash Flow Behind the Gold-Price Headlines

Gold can have a great week without making every miner a great investment. Agnico’s cash flow shows what shareholders actually…

Read more »

Business doodle about dividends on chalkboard
Dividend Stocks

BCE vs. Enbridge: Which Stock Offers the More Convincing Dividend Case?

BCE and Enbridge offer similar starting yields. I’d choose the one with a clearer route from operating cash to the…

Read more »

man in bowtie poses with abacus
Dividend Stocks

How Much Would You Need in SmartCentres to Collect $250 a Month?

SmartCentres can pay an actual monthly distribution. Reaching $250 from it alone would require nearly $45,000 at recent prices.

Read more »

ETF stands for Exchange Traded Fund
Dividend Stocks

2 of the Best ETFs to Buy Now

Looking for the best ETFs to buy now? Explore how XEQT offers global stock exposure while ZAG adds Canadian bonds…

Read more »