Can One Simple Strategy Outperform the TSX?

Can one simple strategy allow an investor to beat the TSX? If the past 25 years is any indication, yes.

| More on:
The Motley Fool

Over the years, one strategy for American investors has seen its popularity ebb and flow, increasing at times but seemingly fading to obscurity at other times. This strategy is so simple in design that any investor can pull it off with just a small bit of research and a few minutes to execute the trades. And, since 2000, this strategy has pretty consistently outperformed the underlying index, increasing 128% compared to 111%.

This strategy is commonly referred to as the “Dogs of the Dow.”

All an investor needs to do is pick the 10 stocks of the Dow Jones Industrials (Index: DJI) with the highest dividend yields, take equal positions in each, and then reevaluate the positions after a year is up, switching out any company that is no longer in the top 10 or has cut the dividend. It’s a pretty easy strategy for something that outperforms on average every year.

One problem with the strategy is the Dow Jones Industrials only has 30 stocks, meaning choices are somewhat limited. Luckily for Canadian investors, they can easily replicate the strategy with the S&P/TSX 60, which should broaden the universe of potential stocks, although it is heavily weighted in financials and energy.

According to research done by Global Securities Corporation, the Dogs of the TSX beat the index handily in 2013, returning 19.87%, compared to 13.26% for the TSX 60 and 12.98% for the TSX Composite. The top performers were Sun Life Financial (TSX:SLF) and Enerplus (TSX:ERF), which were both up more than 50% in 2013. The Dogs were weighed down by Transalta (TSX:TA) and Penn West Petroleum (TSX:PWT).

Here is a list of the 2014 Dogs of The TSX. All information is as of January 1st.

Company Ticker Symbol Dividend Yield
Penn West TSX:PWT 10%
Transalta TSX:TA 8.6%
Canadian Oil Sands TSX:COS 7%
Crescent Point TSX:CPG 6.7%
Enerplus TSX:ERF 6.1%
Encana TSX:ECA 4.4%
Fortis TSX:FTS 4.1%
Bank of Montreal TSX:BMO 4.1%

The average dividend yield for the Dogs is more than 6%, giving this portfolio some impressive dividend power. As many investors know though, high dividends often come with high risk. Transalta has already cut its dividend in 2014, from 29 cents to 18 cents, quarterly. While this doesn’t have a huge effect on the underlying portfolio, it still negatively affects returns, especially after the cut sent shares 20% lower in a matter of days.

These types of events are somewhat common with the Dogs of the TSX, and it still hasn’t stopped them from outperforming. From 1987 through 2011, the Dogs of the TSX have returned 11.97%, compared to 9.34% for the TSX. It started off investing in the top 10 yielding stocks in the TSE 35, morphing the strategy once the TSE 35 was replaced with the TSX 60 in 1998.

One negative of the Dogs portfolio is the concentration in financials and energy, sectors which could very easily be affected by sector-wide factors. If the price of oil suffers in 2014 or if the Canadian housing market starts to roll over, this strategy could easily underperform.

Still, the strategy has outperformed over time, and that’s partially due to the simplicity of the Dogs. While dividend yield isn’t a perfect metric to measure underlying value, generally a company with a higher dividend yield is having some short-term problems. The yield is a representation of the overall value, and makes it pretty easy for investors to pick value stocks just using yield alone.

Foolish bottom line

The Dogs of the TSX is a simple strategy that makes it pretty easy for casual investors to identify value stocks. While I wouldn’t go out and blindly buy all 10 of the stocks on the list, I think the 10 highest yielding companies on the TSX 60 would be a good place for an investor to begin their research.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Nelson Smith has no position in any company mentioned in this article. 

More on Investing

question marks written reminders tickets
Dividend Stocks

Dividend Investors: Is BCE Stock a Buy Now?

BCE now offers a 7.9% dividend yield.

Read more »

A bull outlined against a field
Tech Stocks

Is a Bull Market Here? 4 Reasons to Buy Celestica Stock Like There’s No Tomorrow 

Celestica (TSX:CLS) stock has been a huge winner for investors this year, but there could be even more in the…

Read more »

Retirement plan

1 Retirement Savings Hack That Has Created Many Millionaires

Investors can retirement with $1 million in savings by investing in index funds such as the S&P 500.

Read more »

edit Taxes CRA
Dividend Stocks

CRA Money: 2 More Days to Boost Your Tax Refund!

Dividend stocks like Toronto-Dominion Bank (TSX:TD) can be great RRSP holdings.

Read more »

close-up photo of investor Warren Buffett
Stocks for Beginners

The Best Warren Buffett Stocks to Buy With $300 Right Now

These Warren Buffett stocks have long histories of growth, each offering their own reasons for why investors need them today.

Read more »

grow money, wealth build
Dividend Stocks

3 TSX Dividend Stocks With Yields Above 7% (But Are They Safe?)

These three dividend stocks all have ultra-high yields, making them some of the best to buy if you're looking to…

Read more »

oil and natural gas
Energy Stocks

3 Energy Stocks Already Worth Your While

TSX energy stocks could shine for much longer. Here's why Canadian Natural Resources (TSX:CNQ), Parex Resources (TSX:PXT), and another oil…

Read more »

Light bulb with jester hat perched on top
Dividend Stocks

3 Canadian Dividend Stocks With Payouts That Are No Joke 

Here are three top Canadian dividend stocks long-term investors would be remiss to ignore, particularly at these current valuations.

Read more »