Which Life Insurer Has the Better Dividend?

Is it better to have a big payout, or one with room for growth?

| More on:
The Motley Fool

Which is better: a large dividend or a growing dividend? It’s a question that yield-focused investors have to ask themselves all the time. There’s no better example than in the life insurance industry, where there are some companies that are truly worth considering for your portfolio. Below we take a look at two of them.

1. Manulife

Manulife Financial (TSX: MFC)(NYSE: MFC) certainly doesn’t fit into the “large dividend” category; the stock yields only 2.5%, much less than its competitors or the big banks. However, there are plenty of reasons to believe it will go higher.

To establish proper context, Manulife suffered more during the crisis than any other large Canadian financial services company — even CIBC. Now that the company has recovered, it understandably wants to be very conservative with its capital. As a result, the company has not raised its dividend since slashing it in half in 2009. Last year Manulife paid out only $0.52 in dividends despite earnings per share of $1.62.

Thus Manulife has plenty of room to raise its dividend, and with the highest capital ratio in the industry, there will only be more room down the road. Dividend investors, take note.

2. Sun Life

Sun Life’s (TSX: SLF)(NYSE: SLF) yield is currently a lot more substantial than Manulife’s at 3.7%, but that isn’t because the shares are any cheaper. Rather, it’s because the company pays out a greater percentage of its earnings.

To illustrate, last year Sun Life paid out a total of $1.44 per share in dividends, despite earnings of only $1.55 per share. Therefore the company’s payout ratio was 96%, triple that of Manulife’s.

In fact, at 15.1 times earnings, Sun Life is actually a more expensive stock than Manulife, which trades at only 11.9 times earnings. The higher dividend yield certainly has something to do with that. However, if you look closely, you’ll notice that Sun Life’s dividend has remained constant since 2008, and there’s little reason to believe it will be raised any time soon. Furthermore, Sun Life’s capital ratio is not as strong as Manulife’s.

Not worth paying for extra yield

In this case, Manulife’s growing dividend is likely a better option than Sun Life’s high dividend. But it’s important to keep tabs on how Manulife uses its money; if it doesn’t want to pay out much of it to shareholders, then it better put it to good use increasing the value of the company. That being said, for now it’s worth giving Manulife the benefit of the doubt.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Benjamin Sinclair holds no positions in any of the stocks mentioned in this article.

More on Investing

Hour glass and calendar concept for time slipping away for important appointment date, schedule and deadline
Dividend Stocks

This 8% Dividend Stock Pays Cash Every Month

Earn monthly cash of $154 with this 8% dividend stock.

Read more »

A miner down a mine shaft
Metals and Mining Stocks

Should Investors Buy the Correction in Lundin Mining Stock?

Lundin (TSX:LUN) stock has fallen by 10% in the last few weeks, but so has the price of copper. Coincidence?…

Read more »

Metals and Mining Stocks

Best Stocks to Buy in May 2024: TSX Materials Sector

A TSX materials sector ETF could help investors gain cheap diversified exposure to the hot sector's stocks – so will…

Read more »

man is enthralled with a movie in a theater

Should You Buy Cineplex While it’s Below $9?

With analysts expecting a significant recovery in the second half of 2024, is this the last chance to buy Cineplex…

Read more »

oil tank at night
Dividend Stocks

Think Oil Is Going Higher? 3 Dividend Stocks to Buy Now

Looking for steady dividend growth? These three Canadian oil stocks could provide substantial dividend income in the coming years.

Read more »

Profit dial turned up to maximum
Dividend Stocks

This 7% Dividend Stock on the TSX is Worth Watching

With this superb TSX stock now trading at the bottom of its 52-week range, it's certainly a dividend stock you'll…

Read more »

Dots over the earth connecting the world
Dividend Stocks

1 Magnificent Dividend Stock Down 23% to Buy Right Now Near a Once-in-a-Decade Valuation

Patient investors could be happy with this dividend stock a few years down the road.

Read more »

edit Businessman using calculator next to laptop
Dividend Stocks

2 TSX Dividend Stocks to Buy While They Still Offer Great Yields

These top dividend-growth stocks now offer 7% dividend yields.

Read more »