3 Reasons Canadian Oil Sands Ltd. Should Have Accepted the $4.5 Billion Bid From Suncor Energy Inc.

The bid from Suncor Energy Inc. (TSX:SU)(NYSE:SU) is probably the best that Canadian Oil Sands Ltd. (TSX:COS) can do.

The Motley Fool

In a move that was not unexpected, Canadian Oil Sands Ltd. (TSX:COS) formally rejected a $4.5 billion offer from Suncor Energy Inc. (TSX: SU)(NYSE: SU). This comes after COS adopted a poison pill last week, one that will last longer than Suncor’s bid.

But the COS board is playing a very dangerous game. We take a look below at three reasons why they should reverse course and accept the Suncor bid instead.

1. We’re unlikely to see a higher offer

In a conference call Monday morning, COS management identified 11 reasons to reject Suncor’s bid. One of them is that “the Board of COS and its advisors continue to examine alternatives.” In other words, they are expecting a higher offer to come, either from Suncor or from another company.

But that is very unlikely to happen. As we all know by now, there are plenty of companies looking to sell themselves, and very few companies looking to buy. So, if you’re running an oil company and are looking to make an acquisition, there’s no reason to start a bidding war with Suncor.

Likewise, it’s unlikely that Suncor will make a higher offer. The company has already offered a 43% premium, and doesn’t want to send any messages of weakness. Besides, Suncor will probably try to acquire other companies in the near future, and certainly doesn’t want to encourage them to mimic COS’s approach.

2. The outlook doesn’t look good for oil

COS’s management rightly points out that the company offers higher leverage to oil prices. This should make perfect sense. Suncor has a large downstream business (refining and gas stations), and also has relatively little debt.

But is that really such a good thing? As 2015 drags on, evidence is mounting that oil prices aren’t recovering any time soon. And that could be a major concern for the company, especially given its high debt levels.

3. A sudden, steep drop

If COS rejects Suncor’s bid and no higher offers are made, then it won’t be pretty for COS’s shareholders.

To understand what this would look like, one only has to look at what happened to Pacific Exploration and Production Corp. (TSX:PRE). The company received a takeover offer worth more than $2 billion, but rejected the bid, claiming it significantly undervalued the company. As a result, its share price decreased by more than 45% in one day. The same thing could easily happen to COS.

So, if you hold COS stock and are looking for exposure to higher oil prices, you should sell your stock now. Then you can buy any number of levered oil producers.

Fool contributor Benjamin Sinclair has no position in any stocks mentioned.

More on Energy Stocks

trading chart of brent crude oil prices
Energy Stocks

Suncor Stock: The Dividend Test I’d Use When Oil Prices Swing

Suncor’s dividend increase needs to be assessed beside cash after investment and a weaker-oil stress test.

Read more »

golden sunset in crude oil refinery with pipeline system
Energy Stocks

Buy 1,225 Shares of This Top Dividend Stock for $300/Month in Passive Income

This Canadian dividend stock’s attractive yield and strong growth outlook make it worth considering for investors aiming to generate $300…

Read more »

A close up color image of a small green plant sprouting out of a pile of Canadian dollar coins "loonies."
Energy Stocks

A Dividend Champion Every Canadian Needs in Their TFSA 

Find out why investing in dividends through a TFSA can effectively protect your earnings from inflation and taxes.

Read more »

Natural gas
Energy Stocks

A Perfect TFSA Stock: A 6.5% Payout Each Month

Peyto Exploration and Development is growing its dividend as natural gas fundamentals continue to improve.

Read more »

A meter measures energy use.
Energy Stocks

Canadian Utilities vs. Hydro One: Which Dividend Stock Would I Hold for 15 Years?

A proposed merger changes the Canadian Utilities comparison, while Hydro One still requires price discipline.

Read more »

Blocks conceptualizing Canada's Tax Free Savings Account
Energy Stocks

Retirees: How to Use Your TFSA to Earn an Average of $386 in Monthly Tax-Free Income

This TFSA strategy can help boost average returns while reducing risk.

Read more »

Investor wonders if it's safe to buy stocks now
Energy Stocks

TC Energy Stock: Buy, Sell, or Hold in Late 2026?

With demand for natural gas expected to grow significantly in the coming years, is TC Energy stock worth buying before…

Read more »

a person watches a downward arrow crash through the floor
Energy Stocks

Cenovus Energy: What $10,000 Could Earn in Dividends After Its Latest Results

Cenovus Energy (TSX:CVE) looks like a deep-value dividend juggernaut worth loading up on after the post-earnings dip.

Read more »