Is the TSX Composite in a Gigantic Bubble?

Just because the S&P/TSX Composite Index (TSX:^OSPTX) is up smartly doesn’t mean it’s in a bubble. In fact, it could still surge much higher.

The Motley Fool

After increasing more than 17% over the last year and hitting new all-time highs last month, many investors are beginning to declare that the S&P/TSX Composite Index (TSX:^OSTPX)(TSX:^GSPTSE) has entered bubble territory.

One thing is for sure: the index sure isn’t cheap. The latest reports show the companies in the TSX Composite collectively earned about $260 in the last year, while the index currently sits at 15,496. That puts the index at approximately 60 times earnings.

But that doesn’t tell the whole picture. The TSX Composite is dominated by financial stocks (35% of the index), energy (21%) and materials (12%). Financials are doing fine, but both energy and material stocks have been decimated with non-cash write-offs for years now.

Normalized earnings are closer to $650, which puts the TSX Composite at a much more civilized P/E ratio of less than 24. Canada’s benchmark index also has a cyclically adjusted P/E (CAPE) ratio of just over 20, which factors in earnings over the last 10 years.

That’s expensive when compared to valuations in the past, but it isn’t really when compared to similar markets around the world. Both the United States and Japan have similar trailing P/E ratios, and both have CAPE ratios approaching 25 — a full 25% higher than us here in Canada.

The TSX Composite also offers a dividend yield of nearly 2.7%, using the iShares S&P Capped Cmpst Index Fund (TSX: XIC) as a proxy for the TSX Composite. Both the United States’s and Japan’s benchmark stock indexes offer yields of closer to 2%.

There’s one other important factor that could shoot the TSX Composite Index much higher, even if other stock markets around the world suffer.

Earnings growth

As I touched on earlier, earnings from Canada’s energy and materials sectors have been abysmal for years now. Energy peaked in 2014, while gold and other precious metals have struggled since peaking in 2011.

What happens when these earnings come back?

Remember, one-third of the TSX Composite consists of energy and materials stocks. These stocks also have incredible operating leverage, meaning their costs stay mostly the same even if the price of the commodity skyrockets.

Teck Resources Ltd. (TSX: TECK.B)(NYSE: TECK) is the perfect example of a materials stock with massive operating leverage. Just over a year ago, shares bottomed out at below $5 each as investors were convinced the company was going to go bankrupt.

After the price of metallurgical coal shot up from multi-year lows of US$75 per tonne, Teck shares peaked at $34 each in November before selling off slightly to today’s level of $26.54 each. A tonne of coal peaked at US$308 per tonne in November before falling to US$170, where it sits today.

There’s no guarantee that every oil or materials stock will deliver such a return when those sectors come back. Both have already rallied from their lows. But if we enter another commodities bull market, these stocks could easily head much higher, bringing the index up with it.

The bottom line

Selling because the market is flirting with all-time highs is a silly reason to act. The market hits all-time highs all the time. It’s a fairly normal occurrence.

Investors are also terrible at predicting market tops. Pulling your money out of stocks and into safer vehicles carries opportunity costs. Imagine selling everything and then markets go up another 50%. Those returns are tough to miss out on.

But just because markets aren’t in a bubble doesn’t mean investors don’t have to watch their portfolios. Our newest FREE report can help with that. Check it out!

Fool contributor Nelson Smith has no position in any stocks mentioned.

More on Metals and Mining Stocks

financial chart graphs and oil pumps on a field
Stocks for Beginners

What $10,000 in Freehold Royalties Could Add to Your Income Over a Year

Freehold could produce about $634 in annual income from a $10,000 budget, with commodity prices still influencing the payment.

Read more »

copper wire factory
Stocks for Beginners

Ivanhoe Sits on 43,000 Tonnes of Unsold Copper as Prices Stay High: Is the Stock a Buy?

Ivanhoe holds 43,000 tonnes of unsold copper at Kamoa-Kakula. Does this make the miner a buy for your portfolio right…

Read more »

top TSX stocks to buy in november 2026
Metals and Mining Stocks

Top Motley Fool Stocks to Buy in November 2026

Unbridled optimism is now being served with a dose of skepticism, and you know what that means: It's time to…

Read more »

todder holds a gold bar
Metals and Mining Stocks

Alamos Gold Tumbled 12.5% in 5 Days: Should Gold Investors Be Worried?

Alamos Gold fell 12.5% in five days after Q3 results and slipping gold prices. See what went wrong at Island…

Read more »

telecom towers concept for wireless technology
Stocks for Beginners

Europe’s Carbon Border Tax Could Reshape Canadian Steel: This Producer is Spending to Get Cleaner

Algoma’s electric-furnace transition could improve its competitive position, while current losses make this a recovery investment.

Read more »

A plant grows from coins.
Stocks for Beginners

European Financing Is Coming for Canadian Resources: This Copper Stock Has the Scale to Benefit

Teck offers producing mines and a development pipeline, while new European financing still needs approved borrowers.

Read more »

panning for gold uncovers nuggets and flakes
Metals and Mining Stocks

Why Gold, Silver, and Copper Miners Keep Sliding, and What It Means for TSX Mining Stocks

Falling precious-metal prices have rattled TSX miners, but these two producers still offer strong long-term potential.

Read more »

quantum correlation
Stocks for Beginners

Europe Wants Canada’s Critical Minerals: This TSX Stock Already Makes the Finished Product

Neo has started shipping the magnets Europe needs, giving investors something tangible behind the summit headlines.

Read more »