Which Is the Better Buy? Goldcorp Inc. vs. Kirkland Lake Gold Ltd.

With interest rates rising, stock market volatility could be set to increase. Find out if Goldcorp Inc. (TSX:G)(NYSE:GG) is the answer for your portfolio, or is a junior gold miner a better option?

Gold has long been viewed as a valuable asset to hold, particularly in times of uncertainty when there is a “flight to safety.”

The price of gold bullion is up 12.6% since the start of the year, and with geopolitical tensions on the rise, not to mention the need in the United States to raise the debt ceiling, that trend may be expected to continue.

And with central banks around the world starting to interest rates, including the Bank of Canada, that could threaten the heightened levels of the stock market, and a flight to safety trade might very well be where we’re headed.

Both Goldcorp Inc. (TSX:G)(NYSE:GG) and Kirkland Lake Gold Ltd. (TSX:KL) offer attractive options to play this angle.

The question is, which is the better buy for your portfolio?

Goldcorp Inc.

Goldcorp is one of the world’s largest gold producers, so, theoretically at least, there is an added element of safety.

Yet for the company, profitability has been depressed amid lower gold prices that have been in place since 2012.

Management has not been able to generate excess returns on its capital over that period and, in fact, has been far off that mark. This explains why shares are available at less than book value. That means the company could pay down all its debt and still have money left over to return to shareholders.

It also means that if you buy shares in the company today, you are getting any future profits of the company virtually for free.

And while the company managed to generate only $0.19 of earnings per share (EPS) in 2016, this year is off to a better start with the company already accumulating $0.36 of EPS over the first two quarters of 2017.

Kirkland Lake Gold Ltd.

Kirkland Lake, at a market cap of $3.1 billion, is about one-quarter of the size of Goldcorp.

This means that Kirkland Lake shares have more risk to them, but it also means that Kirkland Lake has more of a runway for growth. This should be appetizing to investors looking to put a little extra cash in their pockets, provided they’re willing to bear the risk.

Kirkland Lakes shares also have momentum on their side.

While Goldcorp shares are down so far in 2017, it’s a much different story for shareholders of Kirkland Lake as the shares are up more than 100% since the start of the year. What’s more, Kirkland Lake shares are up more than 700% since the company released its initial public offering in mid-2015.

Right now, Kirkland Lake trades at a 29 times price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio, which is a slight premium to Goldcorp, which trades at 23 times forward earnings.

Yet at least part of that premium is attributable to the outlook for Kirkland Lake, whose earnings growth is forecast to be 61% in 2018 compared to Goldcorp, whose EPS growth is forecast to be 29%.

Which should you buy?

Neither stock pays much of a dividend with Goldcorp shares yielding 0.62% and Kirkland Lake yielding just 0.07%, so dividend and income investors may be best advised to look elsewhere.

Yet for investors or traders who are more focused on capital gains, there is opportunity in both companies, particularly if the price of gold bullion were to continue on its ascent.

Goldcorp is the “classic” value play trading below book value, offering the lower P/E and higher dividend yield.

Yet the combination offered by Kirkland Lake shares in terms the trade-off in price for future growth suggests it to be to the better option of the two today.

Even if we are headed for some turbulence in the markets, there’s still opportunity to pad your profits, provided you’re willing to think Foolishly.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Jason Phillips has no position in the companies mentioned.  

More on Dividend Stocks

thinking
Dividend Stocks

Should You Buy BCE Stock for its 8.6% Dividend Yield?

Down over 20% from all-time highs, BCE stock offers you a tasty dividend yield in 2024. But is the TSX…

Read more »

grow dividends
Dividend Stocks

How Long Would It Take to Turn $20,000 Into $100,000 With TSX Dividend Stocks?

Here's how high-quality TSX dividend stocks and the power of compound interest can help grow your investments by 400% or…

Read more »

Paper airplanes flying on blue sky with form of growing graph
Dividend Stocks

2 Soaring Stocks I’d Buy Now With No Hesitation

These two stocks may be the most expensive on the market, but they're high for a reason! And I'm still…

Read more »

Hour glass and calendar concept for time slipping away for important appointment date, schedule and deadline
Dividend Stocks

Invest $374.50 Each Month to Create Passive Income of $288 in 2024

Investing a specific amount each month to create passive income this year is possible with monthly dividend payers.

Read more »

Happy retirement
Dividend Stocks

2 Stocks to Help Turn $100,000 Into $1 Million

If you want to reach $1 million, $100,000 can certainly get you there. Even if you invest in some low…

Read more »

warning or alert
Dividend Stocks

Income Alert: These Stocks Just Raised Their Dividends

There's no shortage of companies that raised their dividends recently. Here's a trio of options to consider buying now.

Read more »

Business success with growing, rising charts and businessman in background
Dividend Stocks

Don’t Look Now, But These 3 TSX Stocks Look Poised for a Nice Rally 

Three TSX stocks are in a downtrend amid headwinds. 2024 may be rocky for them, but they are poised for…

Read more »

protect, safe, trust
Dividend Stocks

3 Safe Dividend Stocks to Beat Inflation

These three dividend stocks are excellent buys to beat inflation, given their solid underlying businesses and high yields.

Read more »