Which Is a Smarter Buy: Gold Stocks or Gold Bars?

We take a look at McEwen Mining Inc. (TSX:MUX)(NYSE:MUX) and discuss gold investment, and why holding actual gold bullion is still a bad idea.

Gold prices are sitting at $1,294.90 per ounce, suggesting that the precious metal is going to dip before it surges. Thus, now might be a great time to invest in stocks of the yellow stuff. But before we look at a stock so tasty that even SeaCrest Wealth Management, LLC is holding it, let’s look at whether gold is indeed acting bullishly, and consider that other gold investment strategy.

Going for gold

There are many gold miners on the TSX worth looking at, from those with high market caps and solid assets to decidedly shaky junior miners. Let’s look at one of the former.

McEwen Mining Inc. (TSX: MUX)(NYSE: MUX) decided that it was worth investing in its future rather than look good in 2017. It dropped $5.2 million on developing its assets last year, essentially gambling on a 13% increase for 2018. While bold moves like this might worry more timid investors, those willing to take a chance on its possibly calculatedly undervalued stock could reap the rewards in a few years’ time.

Why else should you consider McEwen? Well, their assets are solid, with four currently productive mines, two prospective mines, and two more about to start producing spread across Mexico, Argentina, the U.S., and Canada. And as we mentioned above, SeaCrest holds stocks in McEwen, so if you do decide to buy, you’ll be in good company. Gold is looking good for 2018, and McEwen would be some nice arm candy for that party.

Now let’s look at that other means of gold investment, and why it’s as dumb as a box of hair.

Do people really still buy actual gold?

There is an entire industry devoted to safely transporting gold bullion to your house. People like the feel of gold – it’s an emotional thing. In fact, investment in gold is emotional, period. People seem to think that gold is recession-proof, that it is “safe” and “out of the system.” But the fact is that actual gold – gold that you can go down into your basement and touch – hasn’t changed much in average value ever.

Don’t believe us? Jusk ask the Royal Economic Society, whose recent study of gold found that between 1836 and 2011, gold prices changed at an average rate of just 1.1% per year. As well, gold prices during times of stress weren’t much different than prices witnessed during stable economic environments. What’s changed isn’t gold’s overall value, but the fortunes of those who mine it.

But, as Hank Hill once told his wife, let’s put this in terms even a genius can understand.

Go buy a gold bar for $100 and put it in your safe. In a decade, that gold bar may very well still be worth $100, meaning you’ve missed out on profits from inflation at the very least. Other than the fact that your gold may have actually dropped in value over those 10 years, you also have a storage problem. Not just space itself, but security and insurance will also be issues. You can go ahead and own thousands in physical gold bullion, but you’ll be insured for a tiny fraction (or none) of it.

Store it somewhere else? Sure, but storage costs will eat into your gold’s value, and if you store it in a bank that goes bust, you can say goodbye to your investment.

The bottom line

Investing in gold miners makes 100% more sense than buying actual gold and keeping it in your house, which, believe it or not, people still do.

Getting back to reality
 while gold is still not at the value it could be, go out and buy stocks in some of the most stable discounted gold miners. Gold may well be about to go full-bull, (either this year or next, but it’s coming), and you’re going to want to be there when it does. McEwen is a good buy if you want to back solid assets and a smart acquisition strategy.

Fool contributor Victoria Hetherington has no position in any of the stocks mentioned.

More on Dividend Stocks

Group of people in a line at an ATM waiting to make a cash withdrawal
Dividend Stocks

The TFSA Withdrawal Rule Every Canadian Should Know

The account is a much better place to invest long term than to make frequent trades and withdrawals.

Read more »

man shops at grocery store
Dividend Stocks

The Best Canadian Stocks for Conservative Investors Right Now

These two Canadian stocks combine durable businesses, growing earnings, and shareholder returns.

Read more »

Three children jump on an outdoor trampoline
Dividend Stocks

2 Solid Dividend Stocks Down 20 Percent to Buy Before They Bounce Back

These Canadian companies have been increasing their dividends year after year, while their stocks have pulled back from recent highs.

Read more »

happy woman throws cash
Dividend Stocks

The Ideal TFSA Stock: A 5.9% Yield-Paying Constant Cash

Enbridge’s predictable cash flows, substantial growth pipeline, and long history of dividend increases underpin its long-term investment appeal for TFSA…

Read more »

woman gazes forward out window to future
Dividend Stocks

Dividend Income in Retirement: What Could Go Wrong?

Dividend investing is a proven way to create income in retirement but you must know the risks you need to…

Read more »

The TFSA is a powerful savings vehicle for Canadians who are saving for retirement.
Dividend Stocks

A 5% Monthly Payer I’d Buy for My TFSA: About $100 a Month on $24,000

Canada’s largest residential landlord offers a high yield, reliable monthly income, and a tax-sheltered foundation for TFSA investors.

Read more »

Two seniors walk in the forest
Dividend Stocks

Can Dividends Replace a Paycheque in Retirement?

Can dividends in retirement replace your paycheque? Explore how Scotiabank, RioCan REIT, and Fortis can help build a steady retirement…

Read more »

Sliced pumpkin pie
Dividend Stocks

The Fees That Quietly Eat Into a Small Investment

Many funds charge outrageous fees, but broad market index funds like the iShares S&P/TSX Capped Composite Index ETF (TSX:XIC) usually…

Read more »