What Horrid Ways to Invest in a TFSA!

Will you allocate a part of your portfolio in speculative stocks, such as Katanga Mining Ltd. (TSX:KAT), for potential out-of-this-world gains?

The top contestants for a tax-free savings account (TFSA) contest amassed about $70,000-$500,000 by early 2015. (Up to $41,000 could have been their seed money from the contributions they’ve made since 2009.)

Some of their investment strategies include betting big on penny stocks, high-growth nano-cap stocks, and concentrating in one stock at a time. These strategies can be super lucrative, but they’re also super risky.

Penny stocks

The winning couple that accumulated more than $500,000 each in their TFSAs actually placed their bet on one single penny stock, which appreciated from $0.10 to $6.50 per share (i.e., 65 times the original investment!).

They felt really good about the idea, and at the time they believed the stock would go to $25. However, the stock hasn’t gone past $7 yet and actually sits at $0.60 as of writing.

To be fair though, if the couple still owned the stock, they would still be sitting on gains of five times their original investment. They also recognized the risk they were taken and had the goal of diversifying their TFSAs into income-producing stocks and mutual funds.

Personally, I would never bet big on penny stocks. I see them as speculative investments that are closer to gambling. Earlier this year, I made a tiny bet on Katanga Mining (TSX:KAT) in my TFSA and booked a roughly 50% gain in about three weeks.

My target exit price was actually higher than what I sold it for, but was I glad I wasn’t greedy — if I had held on, I would be sitting on a double-digit loss right now. My experience in reading technical charts and luck also had a lot to do with the favourable outcome. I was able to be non-emotional on the trade because I only made a small bet.

High-growth nano-cap stocks

There’s no doubt that nano-caps (companies with market caps of less than $50 million) are underfollowed, and, as a result, there are many more undervalued gems to be discovered versus the large-cap and mid-cap spaces. However, like penny stocks, if you bet on the wrong ones, you can lose your shirt.

Concentrate on one stock at a time

If you’re concentrating on one stock at a time, you have to be very confident about your idea. Otherwise, if the stock turns south, you’ll have to make the difficult decision of buying, holding, or selling under a considerable amount of stress.

Investor takeaway

It’s important to point out that some of the winners were highly educated and experienced in the finance world with financial advisors and an accountant in the mix; as such, their strategies may be difficult to execute for average investors who may not have enough expertise or time to do thorough research.

Buying penny stocks and nano-cap stocks, or concentrating on one stock at a time can be super lucrative if you make the right bets. However, making the wrong bets will lead to huge losses. So, these strategies are best avoided by most investors and especially conservative ones.

If you do decide to make some speculative bets, make sure they cumulatively don’t exceed, say, 5-10% of your portfolio. Instead, focus on the Foolish way to invest — average in to businesses with great management that treat shareholders well. Over the long term, you should be very pleased with your returns.

Fool contributor Kay Ng has no position in any of the stocks mentioned.

More on Metals and Mining Stocks

nugget gold
Metals and Mining Stocks

One TFSA Stock That Could Be Well Suited for a Turbulent 2026

This gold stock could help your TFSA stay resilient during market volatility in 2026 and beyond.

Read more »

Metals
Stocks for Beginners

Why These 2 Canadian Stocks Look Like Bargains Right Now

These two TSX stocks look cheap, but still have the cash flow and balance sheets to keep rewarding shareholders.

Read more »

woman holding steering wheel is nervous about the future
Metals and Mining Stocks

Canadian Investors Are Missing This Huge Trend Right Now

Copper is the “picks-and-shovels” theme behind EVs, grid upgrades, and data centres, and these two TSX names give different ways…

Read more »

diversification and asset allocation are crucial investing concepts
Metals and Mining Stocks

3 Canadian Stocks That Look Like Smart Long-Term Buys Today

Lundin Gold, OR Royalties, and Franco-Nevada offer three different ways to benefit from strong gold prices with businesses built for…

Read more »

gold prices rise and fall
Stocks for Beginners

3 Canadian Stocks to Buy if Gold Keeps Climbing

Even with a sharp March pullback, some analysts still see room for strength ahead, driven by diversification demand and a…

Read more »

panning for gold uncovers nuggets and flakes
Metals and Mining Stocks

1 Gold and Silver Mining Stock to Buy in April

Gold trades above $3,000 and silver above $90. Two mining stocks stand out right now: Agnico Eagle and Endeavour Silver.…

Read more »

groceries get more expensive as inflation rises
Stocks for Beginners

2 Canadian Stocks That Could Outperform if Inflation Stays Sticky

Sticky inflation could keep pushing investors toward hard assets, and these two miners offer real leverage to gold and silver…

Read more »

Safety helmets and gloves hang from a rack on a mining site.
Stocks for Beginners

Miners Sold Off: 3 TSX Materials Stocks Worth a Second Look

Materials stocks have sold off together, but these three miners have company-specific progress that could surprise investors in 2026.

Read more »