Silver or Gold? Which Is the Best Mineral Stock for Your TFSA?

Mineral stocks are selling low, but should you consider Wheaton Precious Metals Corp (TSX:WPM)(NYSE:WPM) or Imperial Metals Corp (TSX:III) for your portfolio?

| More on:

The great Burl Ives once sang, “Silver and gold, silver and gold, everyone wishes for silver and gold.”

Ives was singing as a snow man to Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer at the time, but he might as well have been crooning to the stock market.

Minerals are a staple that almost every investor considers adding to their portfolio. Like oil and gas, gold, silver and copper will continue to be bought and sold for generations to come.

But in the last year there have been two problems:

  • The United States and China trade war
  • A volatile market

The former has sent silver and gold stocks plunging, as China is the biggest metal consumer. The latter has proven that when the markets are down, people just aren’t as willing to invest in metal companies. That leaves investors with an opportunity to buy cheap, but which company will be worth the investment? Today I’ll compare Wheaton Precious Metals (TSX:WPM)(NYSE:WPM) and Imperial Metals (TSX:III) to see where you should be putting your hard-earned cash this holiday season.

Will Wheaton continue to shine?

Wheaton is a heavy hitter in the precious metals industry. It is the world’s largest pure streaming company, giving mines cash upfront to get started and getting back a percentage of the mine’s metals at a well-below discount. In 2017, for example, Wheaton paid an average of $6.03 per ounce of silver and sold it for $22.83, and paid $530 for gold while selling it for $1,687!

The company doesn’t show any signs of slowing down on this business model. It currently works with 19 mines — some of the biggest miners in the world — and has plans in the works for nine more. By 2022, Wheaton estimates it’ll produce about 385 thousand ounces of gold and 25 million ounces of silver per year.

But share prices have been down as of late. This is partly due to a lawsuit with the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA). The CRA argued Wheaton’s subsidiary, Wheaton International, was subject to tax in Canada. However, the dispute recently settled in court, which sent stocks up 14.2%. Now the company can focus on finding more streaming deals with other mines and hopefully bring attention back to expansion for shareholders.

While the stock is still down about 11% from the highs of summer at the time of writing this article, the stock is still up about 30% from its 52-week low and on target to reach its fair-value estimate of about $28 per share.

The empire has fallen

The once-great Imperial Metals has seen barely any profits in the past five years. They’ve been hit hard by the falling price of copper, with prices falling 15% this year for copper and 63% for the company. In the latest Q3 report, revenues were down to $70.5 million from $90.2 million the same time last year, with debt at $728.4 million. The last few quarters have been brutal, with shares falling from $2.16 to as low as $0.99. This is quite the blow from the all-time high they once had back in 2014 of $17.85.

Yet in the past few months, insiders have invested more than 1.83 million shares. Why? That comes from news that Imperial has hired Bank of Montreal to start the formal process of selling the business, either completely or partially. That could give Imperial much-needed cash of up to $1 billion and a boost in share prices to boot.

Bottom line

It’s really a no brainer in this scenario. While both stocks are undervalued, Imperial is just too risky at this point to invest in unless you know the company and the market. Wheaton, however, has strong finances and is expanding its streaming business regularly. If you want your investments to sing as sweetly as Burl Ives in 2019, the pick just has to be Wheaton Precious Metals, in my opinion.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Amy Legate-Wolfe has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Wheaton Precious Metals is a recommendation of Stock Advisor Canada.

More on Metals and Mining Stocks

silver metal
Metals and Mining Stocks

1 Reeling Silver Stock to Consider Today

Aya Gold & Silver (TSX:AYA) is a Montreal-based company that is engaged in the acquisition, exploration, evaluation, and development of …

Read more »

Woman has an idea
Metals and Mining Stocks

Want High Growth? 3 Under-$7 Stocks Could Climb 100%

The TSX extended its losing streak to five trading days on January 24, 2022. Canada’s main equities benchmark is now …

Read more »

TSX Today
Metals and Mining Stocks

TSX Today: What to Watch for in Stocks on Thursday, January 27

The stock market continued with high volatility on Wednesday, as expected on the day of key monetary policy announcements. While …

Read more »

gold stocks gold mining
Metals and Mining Stocks

3 Stocks to Buy as Gold Hit Fresh Highs

Gold has always been an attractive investment option during political and economic uncertainties. With growing concerns over multi-decade high inflation, …

Read more »

A miner down a mine shaft
Metals and Mining Stocks

Why This Mining TSX Stock Shot Up 15% Yesterday

Turquoise Hill (TSX:TRQ)(NYSE:TRQ) is a Montreal-based mining company. It owns a majority stake in a Mongolia-based copper and gold mine. …

Read more »

grow dividends
Metals and Mining Stocks

Why Did Turquoise Hill Stock Soar 18% on Tuesday?

Turquoise Hill Resources (TSX:TRQ)(NYSE:TRQ) shares climbed as high as 18% in early Tuesday trading. This came after news that a …

Read more »

stock research, analyze data
Metals and Mining Stocks

Forget Tesla (NASDAQ:TSLA): Buy This Lithium Stock Instead

Tesla (NASDAQ:TSLA) is dropping like a rock this year. Investor sentiment about tech companies with hyped-up valuations has clearly turned. …

Read more »

happy new year 2022
Metals and Mining Stocks

1 Canadian ETF to Help Your Portfolio Thrive in a Volatile 2022

The volatile start to 2022 may or may not be a sign of what to expect for the remainder of …

Read more »