Tilray (NASDAQ:TLRY) vs. Aphria (TSX:APHA): Which Marijuana Stock Is Riskier?

Tilray Inc. (NASDAQ:TLRY) and Aphria Inc (TSX:APHA)(NYSE:APHA) are two marijuana stocks that you shouldn’t buy unless you have a higher risk appetite.

| More on:

Marijuana stock trading has made many millionaires during the past few years. Investors who’d jumped in this trade early made killings, as the companies benefited from global interest in this growing industry.

But with winners, this space has also produced plenty of losers who got stuck when short-sellers pounced on weak marijuana companies. No doubt this industry has a lot of potential, as the use of both medical and recreational cannabis grows and more countries legalize it.

But that being said, there are many pot stocks that are highly speculative, and investors should be very cautious while buying those stocks. Here are two names that fall into this category.

Tilray

The price chart of Tilray (NASDAQ:TLRY) stock shows that the crazy rush, which pushed this top marijuana stock to $300 a share last year, has ended. Its stock is down more than 40% this year, massively underperforming other players.

One big negative factor that hit the stock this week is the company’s announcement that it won’t generate positive earnings for at least another year, as it spends on the U.S. CBD market and other opportunities.

Analysts were originally expecting the Nanaimo, British Columbia-based cannabis producer to achieve positive earnings by the end of 2019, but that stage won’t reach until 2020 at least.

Despite this short-term setback, the U.S.’s legalization of hemp and hemp-derived CBD in December has created new opportunities south of the border for Tilray, but that means more investment into future growth.

Tilray acquired hemp-food manufacturer Manitoba Harvest and partnered with Authentic Brands Group earlier this year; it expects both to begin selling non-intoxicating cannabidiol products in the U.S. in the back half of 2019.

The U.S. is the market where recreational marijuana is currently legal in 10 states, and many now see federal U.S. legalization as inevitable within the next five years.

Aphria

Aphria (TSX:APHA)(NYSE:APHA) has been through a lot in the past year. This marijuana producer has faced a powerful attack from a short-seller, and it successfully battled a hostile takeover bid.

The latest bearish spell began when the company reported disappointing earnings for the quarter ended Feb. 28. The report included a significant reduction in gross margin to 18% from 47% in the prior quarter and a decrease in kilograms sold.

This was partly due to packaging and distribution challenges in the early days of Canada’s legal recreational pot market and a transition to new growing methods.

This situation is unlikely to improve, according to Aphria, as it invests in automation and the development of new growing facilities. The company expects to earn $1 billion in annualized revenue by the end of calendar 2020, up from an estimated $218 million in the fiscal year ended May 31.

Bottom line

Both Tilray and Aphria are risky bets in the marijuana space, and conservative investors should stay away from buying these stocks. But if you have more appetite to take risks, then I would prefer Tilray over Aphria due to the company’s clear focus on the U.S. market and the potential for exponential growth.

Fool contributor Haris Anwar has no positions in the stock mentioned in this report.

More on Cannabis Stocks

Farmer smiles near cannabis crop
Cannabis Stocks

TFSA Investors: An Undervalued Cannabis Stock You Can Buy for $500 Right Now

Down almost 70% from all-time highs, Curaleaf is a TSX cannabis stock that trades at an attractive valuation in December…

Read more »

Farmer smiles near cannabis crop
Cannabis Stocks

Can Canopy Growth Stock Finally Recover in 2026, as Donald Trump Might Ease Cannabis Restrictions?

Down over 99% from all-time highs, Canopy Growth stock might recover in 2026 if the Trump administration reclassifies cannabis products.

Read more »

Researcher works in hemp field
Cannabis Stocks

Forget Tilray and Buy This Cannabis Stock if the U.S. Reclassifies Marijuana in 2026

While Tilray stock gained over 40% on Friday, this cannabis company is a better buy if the U.S. reclassifies marijuana…

Read more »

A cannabis plant grows.
Cannabis Stocks

Aurora Cannabis Surged 21% on Possible Cannabis Reclassification in the U.S. Is ACB Stock Finally a Good Buy?

Down almost 99% from all-time highs, Aurora Cannabis is a beaten-down marijuana stock that offers upside potential in December 2025.

Read more »

four people hold happy emoji masks
Dividend Stocks

Wary of Mining Companies? A Lower-Risk Way to Get in on the Gold and Silver Surge

Frenco-Nevada (TSX:FNV) stock might be a wiser way to play the run in gold prices this year.

Read more »

Cannabis smoke
Cannabis Stocks

Have Cannabis Stocks Totally Gone Up in Smoke?

Let's dive into whether Canadian cannabis stocks are still investable, and what investors should make of the recent volatility in…

Read more »

Researcher works in hemp field
Cannabis Stocks

1 Undervalued Cannabis Stock to Buy and Hold Over the Next Decade

Green Thumb is a beaten-down cannabis stock that trades at a compelling valuation in September 2025.

Read more »

Researcher works in hemp field
Cannabis Stocks

Pot Stocks Rallied Hard in August: Is There More to Come?

Tilray Brands (TSX:TLRY) and the broad basket of pot stocks could heat up from here.

Read more »