Wary of Mining Companies? A Lower-Risk Way to Get in on the Gold and Silver Surge

Frenco-Nevada (TSX:FNV) stock might be a wiser way to play the run in gold prices this year.

Key Points
  • Gold has topped US$4,000/oz this year on central‑bank buying and macro worries; I don’t see a bubble yet but expect short‑to‑medium‑term pullbacks toward US$3,800–4,000.
  • I prefer lower‑beta exposure to the rally—Franco‑Nevada (TSX:FNV) offers a steadier way to play precious metals (streaming model, diversified cash flows, dividend) versus volatile gold miners.

The gold surge has been the talk of the town this year, with gold prices rising above the US$4,000 per-ounce level for the first time.

And while last week saw quite the shocking pullback, I do think that staying the course and not overreacting either way is a wise move, especially since many of the same dynamics driving higher gold are still in play (think central bank buying, growing macro concerns, tariff uncertainties, recession fears, and the anticipation of lower interest rates in the U.S.). While there has been a rise in speculative activity, I wouldn’t yet say that gold prices are in a bubble yet.

Although investors should certainly brace for a correction below the US$3,800–$4,000 over the short to medium term. Either way, many big banks have a target on gold to hit US$4,900 or even US$5,000 at some point in 2026.

That’s some serious upside, which, I think, might not be smooth, especially after the latest dip that saw the gold miners take an even larger hit to the chin. Indeed, it’s quite a shock to witness some gold mining stocks tank close to 10% in a single session of trade.

four people hold happy emoji masks

Source: Getty Images

Gold’s ride could get choppy, but don’t be startled out of the trade yet!

That really does speak to the leveraged nature of the gold miners. And with so many ways to bet on physical bullion, a strong case could be made that it’s just a bit too risky to go down the mining route when it comes to one’s gold exposure. Indeed, the gold miners have been shining brighter in the past year amid gold’s run-up. However, if gold prices move lower (and many folks learned this the hard way last week), the gold miners could take a double hit to the chin.

Indeed, operating leverage cuts both ways, and for an investor looking for less volatility and hedging benefits, I’d argue that the gold miners might not be the best way to play the bull market in gold, which may or may not turn at any time. Unless you’re a pound-the-table bull on gold, I’d argue it’s wiser to play it safe with the investments that have lower betas and less dependance on higher prices.

Franco-Nevada stock: Streaming your way to a better risk/reward in gold?

A common way to bet on gold is to punch your ticket to the likes of a physical bullion ETF. However, another, more underrated play, in my opinion, is the streamers. Frenco-Nevada (TSX: FNV) was definitely not spared as the gold and silver trade rolled over last week. The stock sits down close to 14% from its all-time high. However, I still think the streamer is a fantastic way to bet on precious metals with less correlation to the broad market.

At the time of this writing, shares have a 0.59 beta, making it a far less choppy ride than the likes of your average gold miner, which has a beta closer to 1. Either way, I also like the risk/reward trade-off of the streaming business, given its greater diversification and lower-risk financing, paving the way for stabler cash flow streams.

With a fairly low cost per ounce, Franco also stands to gain a lot more when gold prices rise compared to physical bullion. Combined with a well-covered dividend and potential for further dividend growth, I think it’s clear that names like FNV are worth more attention for investors seeking a smarter, less choppy way to play the precious metals scene as things look to get a bit bumpier.

Fool contributor Joey Frenette has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Dividend Stocks

A close up color image of a small green plant sprouting out of a pile of Canadian dollar coins "loonies."
Dividend Stocks

Telus Dividend Safety: Is the Stock Still Worth Buying for Income?

Explore the latest insights on Telus dividend amid a challenging earnings report and management's new Transformation Strategy.

Read more »

voice-recognition-talking-to-a-smartphone
Dividend Stocks

BCE Just Reported: What $10,000 Could Earn You in Dividends Today

BCE is yielding a very generous 5.2%, as the company's telecom business improves and long-term investments drive growth.

Read more »

Transparent umbrella under heavy rain against water drops splash background. Rainy weather concept.
Dividend Stocks

Is Intact’s Rough Quarter a Blip or the New Normal for Canadian Insurers?

Intact reported $660 million in pre-tax catastrophe losses during the quarter, which dragged its net operating income per share lower.

Read more »

investor faces bear market
Dividend Stocks

How Much to Invest in BCE for $1,500 a Year in Dividends

BCE (TSX:BCE) could be a huge dividend value winner as the stock markets correct and potentially flirt with a bear…

Read more »

diversification is an important part of building a stable portfolio
Dividend Stocks

Want $6,000 a Year From Your TFSA? Here’s the Portfolio Size to Aim for

A $150,000 starting target can support a $6,000 annual TFSA income goal without requiring an extreme yield.

Read more »

top TSX stocks to buy
Dividend Stocks

Hot Take: The Best Monthly Dividend Stock on the TSX Right Now

For investors seeking monthly dividend payments, this REIT has a history of consistent dividend payments across different market conditions, along…

Read more »

An investor uses a tablet
Dividend Stocks

Dividend Income vs. Selling Shares: Which Strategy Generates Better Cash Flow?

You might make more money periodically selling stock than you'd make collecting Fortis Inc (TSX:FTS) dividends.

Read more »

money goes up and down in balance
Dividend Stocks

How Much to Invest in This TSX Stock for $750 a Quarter in Dividends

Want $750 a quarter? Alaris pays $1.56 a year at $21.54. See how many units to buy, what Q3 showed,…

Read more »