BlackBerry’s Patent Cases Against Facebook and Snap Are Crumbling

A tentative court ruling further reduces the scope of claims involving patent violations related to BlackBerry Messenger.

Back in early 2018, BlackBerry (NYSE: BB) sued Facebook (NASDAQ: FB) and Snap (NYSE: SNAP) over allegedly violating seven patents for BlackBerry Messenger (BBM), which cover timestamps, message notifications, push notifications for ads, tagging photos, and mapping activities. Facebook and Snap filed motions to invalidate BlackBerry’s patents last June, and all the independent claims for one of the patents (regarding time stamps) were invalidated two months later.

On Sept. 5, a district court in Los Angeles tentatively ruled that two of BlackBerry’s other disputed patents (involving targeted ads) were ineligible for protection because they were merely “dressing up the abstract concept of collecting and compiling information.” The court also invalidated two additional claims for location-based patents, which were only aimed at Snapchat.

Facebook still needs to deal with BlackBerry’s other claims, including two patents for user interfaces. Snap still faces two claims, but one of them is the time stamps claim that was crippled last August. However, BlackBerry is clearly losing its firepower in both cases, and that could be bad news for one of its biggest businesses.

What’s BlackBerry’s angle?

Under CEO John Chen, who took the top job in 2013, BlackBerry gradually phased out its dying smartphone business and licensed its brand and designs to Chinese smartphone maker TCL. It focused on expanding its enterprise software ecosystem with new products and acquisitions; that strategy paid off as its revenue growth turned positive again over the past two quarters.

To boost its margins throughout that transition, BlackBerry aggressively monetized its portfolio of about 44,000 patents by launching a flurry of lawsuits against Facebook, Snap, Twitter, Nokia, Cisco, and even Ryan Seacrest (over the creation of an iPhone case with a BlackBerry keyboard).

Therefore, BlackBerry’s cases against Facebook and Snap aren’t about protecting BBM. BlackBerry already discontinued the consumer version of the app earlier this year due to tough competition from rivals like Facebook Messenger. Instead, BlackBerry is suing Facebook and Snap to feed the growth of its licensing and IP business, which has become a high-margin growth engine in recent quarters:

Licensing & IP Q1 2019 Q2 2019 Q3 2019 Q4 2019 Q1 2020
Revenue (millions) $63 $56 $68 $99 $72
Percentage of total revenue* 29% 26% 30% 39% 27%

Source: BlackBerry quarterly reports. *Non-GAAP.

BlackBerry likely knew that the court would invalidate some of its patent claims against Facebook and Snap. But if it lands just one or two blows, the payout could easily offset the legal costs and boost its licensing and IP revenue.

Could these lawsuits hurt Facebook and Snap?

Facebook’s net income fell 49% annually to $2.62 billion last quarter due to FTC and SEC fines, associated legal expenses, and a tax hit from new IRS rules. Those troubles could continue over the next few quarters, as Facebook faces fresh antitrust probes in the U.S. and overseas. The ongoing battle with BlackBerry could exacerbate that pain.

A woman "likes" social media posts on her smartphone.

Image source: Getty Images.

Snap, which hasn’t ever posted a profit, posted a net loss of $255 million last quarter — which was still an improvement from its loss of $353 million a year earlier.

Snap doesn’t face as many legal headwinds as Facebook, but many analysts wonder if the social network can achieve profitability before running out of cash. Snap allayed some concerns in recent quarters with its accelerating user growth and narrowing losses, but a BlackBerry victory could cause its losses to widen again.

Facebook and Snap would also be forced to either pay royalties to BlackBerry or remove key features in their apps. In other words, they could be forced to choose between losing money or alienating users with redesigned apps.

BlackBerry is losing ground

BlackBerry’s decision to sue Facebook and Snap makes sense, even if it caused critics to denounced it as a “patent troll.” However, the tentative ruling indicates that BlackBerry’s cases are losing steam, and investors shouldn’t get their hopes up for big licensing payments from the two social media companies.

Randi Zuckerberg, a former director of market development and spokeswoman for Facebook and sister to its CEO, Mark Zuckerberg, is a member of The Motley Fool's board of directors. Leo Sun owns shares of Cisco Systems, Facebook, and Snap Inc. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends BlackBerry, Facebook, and Twitter. The Motley Fool owns shares of Nokia. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Tech Stocks

The letters AI glowing on a circuit board processor.
Tech Stocks

3 AI Stocks Canadians May Like Better Than Nvidia

Nvidia's stock is down 32% amid controversies. Discover the implications for Nvidia and the chip industry amid these concerns.

Read more »

chip with the letters "AI" on it
Tech Stocks

Top Canadian Stocks to Buy Now for Long-term Growth

This long-term grower is worth picking up on recent weakness and buying steadily over time.

Read more »

dividend stocks bring in passive income so investors can sit back and relax
Tech Stocks

Already Own Shopify? What the Sell-off Means for Your Investment

Analyze the seasonal trends of Shopify and understand what caused the recent stock dip after a significant rally.

Read more »

Business doodle about dividends on chalkboard
Dividend Stocks

BCE vs. Enbridge: Which Stock Offers the More Convincing Dividend Case?

BCE and Enbridge offer similar starting yields. I’d choose the one with a clearer route from operating cash to the…

Read more »

Digital background depicting innovative technologies in (AI) artificial systems, neural interfaces and internet machine learning technologies
Tech Stocks

Where Could Celestica Stock Be in 5 Years? What the New Outlook Means

Celestica’s ambitious 2027 outlook and accelerating AI infrastructure demand could fuel its next phase of growth, making its recent stock…

Read more »

A person uses and AI chat bot
Tech Stocks

This Canadian Tech Stock Is a Steal, and I’m Telling New Investors to Buy It Right Now

A beaten-down share price, growing cloud business, and AI-focused initiatives make this Canadian tech stock attractive for new investors seeking…

Read more »

frustrated shopper at grocery store
Tech Stocks

Shopify Stock Is Down 16% in the Past Month: Should You Buy the Dip?

Shopify stock fell 16% recently. Discover the impact of interest rate hikes and market sentiment on Shopify's performance.

Read more »

scanning a package shipping label for ecommerce delivery
Tech Stocks

Shopify After the Selloff: What Would Make Me Buy, Hold, or Wait?

Shopify’s latest quarter showed a fast-growing business. My buy decision depends on how much of that growth the price already…

Read more »