3 Reasons Wall Street Shouldn’t Hit the Brakes on Uber and Lyft

Analysts are lowering their expectations for the ridesharing leaders, but the accelerator pedal is so much more tempting these days.

Investors are cooling on Lyft (NASDAQ: LYFT) and Uber (NYSE: UBER), with shares of the two ridesharing leaders hitting new lows this month. Analysts are also cooling on the stock, with at least three Wall Street pros checking in on Thursday with less flattering takes on the two transportation industry disruptors.

Both stocks are now broken IPOs, trading below their debutante prices earlier this year. Let’s dive into each of the fresh Wall Street views, countering those analyst notes with a more optimistic perspective on the road ahead.

1. California regulation isn’t the end of the industry

Jeffrey Kauffman at Loop Capital is lowering his price targets on the two titans of ridesharing, concerned about the long-term earnings power for the industry given AB5 legislation in California, which will make it more expensive to do business in the country’s most populous state. Forcing Uber and Lyft to turn their drivers into employees with guaranteed wages and benefits — and not independent contractors — is going to force the ride-hailing companies into a lose-lose situation. They can’t really absorb too much of the incremental costs, as the two companies are already losing billions a year between them. The logical conclusion is that passengers will be the ones bearing the higher costs, as Kauffman believes, and that could price Uber and Lyft out of consumer consideration.

With the cloud of negative demand elasticity looming, Kauffman is lowering his price target on Uber from $54 to $48. His price goal for Lyft is getting a haircut from $60 to $52. He’s sticking to his bullish rating on the two stocks, and those revised price targets still offer some upside from the current level. However, let’s go down the independent contractor rabbit hole since it’s what the gig economy is hinging its existence on these days.

Having to pay out wages and benefits in California and any other states that follow suit would make it more expensive for Uber and Lyft to grant rides, but this is a two-way street. As W-2 employees, Uber and Lyft could exert a bit more control over their reclassified hires in terms of noncompetes, hours worked, and heightened expectations — things that I imagine most drivers would prefer to avoid. We’ll see how this plays out, but for now Uber’s global diversity makes it less dependent on its home turf than Lyft.

2. Starting lines matter in sizing up lower price targets

Brian Nowak is lowering his price target on Uber from $57 to $53, but that’s actually a bullish development. With Uber stock closing at $34 on Wednesday, we’re looking at a hearty 56% of upside even at the new lower price goal.

Nowak is naturally sticking to his earlier bullish overweight rating on the stock, and his update is loaded with positives. He is optimistic about the operating details that Uber is providing now that it’s breaking down the contributions between ride-hailing and Uber Eats, giving investors more clarity on the business. He’s lifting his adjusted EBITDA projections for this year and 2020, despite lowering his bookings estimates. Yes, starting lines matter.

3. Uber and Lyft aren’t going away

The third analyst wasn’t as upbeat as the other two, who adjusted their price targets to levels well above where the stocks are now. Jim Kelleher at Argus initiated coverage of Uber with a hold rating, arguing that the stock is fairly valued at current levels.

The argument that Uber is worth so much less than its $45 IPO — with Lyft also trading well below its springtime launchpad at $72 — doesn’t make a lot of sense. Both companies continue to grow their businesses faster than the transportation industry, so they continue to gobble up market share. Lyft revenue soared 72% in its latest quarter. Uber is growing much slower, but it’s hard to call a company growing its gross bookings at a 31% clip a failure.

We live in a mobile world, and ridesharing has carved out a market of convenience that isn’t possible with cheaper mass transit options and a market of value for others relative to the high costs of car ownership for what is a dormant asset most of the day. The trend is there, and it’s not going to shift into reverse anytime soon.

Investing in IPOs is risky, but the sell-offs for Uber and Lyft appear overdone. The companies aren’t going anywhere, especially given the massive losses they’ve incurred just to win gold or silver in this race. There’s no point in hitting the brakes when the accelerator pedal is just a few inches away.

Rick Munarriz has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Uber Technologies. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Tech Stocks

The letters AI glowing on a circuit board processor.
Tech Stocks

3 AI Stocks Canadians May Like Better Than Nvidia

Nvidia's stock is down 32% amid controversies. Discover the implications for Nvidia and the chip industry amid these concerns.

Read more »

chip with the letters "AI" on it
Tech Stocks

Top Canadian Stocks to Buy Now for Long-term Growth

This long-term grower is worth picking up on recent weakness and buying steadily over time.

Read more »

dividend stocks bring in passive income so investors can sit back and relax
Tech Stocks

Already Own Shopify? What the Sell-off Means for Your Investment

Analyze the seasonal trends of Shopify and understand what caused the recent stock dip after a significant rally.

Read more »

Business doodle about dividends on chalkboard
Dividend Stocks

BCE vs. Enbridge: Which Stock Offers the More Convincing Dividend Case?

BCE and Enbridge offer similar starting yields. I’d choose the one with a clearer route from operating cash to the…

Read more »

Digital background depicting innovative technologies in (AI) artificial systems, neural interfaces and internet machine learning technologies
Tech Stocks

Where Could Celestica Stock Be in 5 Years? What the New Outlook Means

Celestica’s ambitious 2027 outlook and accelerating AI infrastructure demand could fuel its next phase of growth, making its recent stock…

Read more »

A person uses and AI chat bot
Tech Stocks

This Canadian Tech Stock Is a Steal, and I’m Telling New Investors to Buy It Right Now

A beaten-down share price, growing cloud business, and AI-focused initiatives make this Canadian tech stock attractive for new investors seeking…

Read more »

frustrated shopper at grocery store
Tech Stocks

Shopify Stock Is Down 16% in the Past Month: Should You Buy the Dip?

Shopify stock fell 16% recently. Discover the impact of interest rate hikes and market sentiment on Shopify's performance.

Read more »

scanning a package shipping label for ecommerce delivery
Tech Stocks

Shopify After the Selloff: What Would Make Me Buy, Hold, or Wait?

Shopify’s latest quarter showed a fast-growing business. My buy decision depends on how much of that growth the price already…

Read more »