3 TFSA Mistakes Millions of Canadians Are Still Making

Millions of Canadians leave money on the table by making classic mistakes with their TFSAs. If you want to maximize your portfolio’s value, keep these lessons in mind.

Do you have a TFSA? If you do, you’re already doing better than the two-thirds of Canadians who haven’t set one up yet.

But having a TFSA is only the first step. After creating a TFSA, millions of Canadians still leave money on the table by making a few classic mistakes.

If you want to make the most of your TFSA and boost your odds of retiring rich, be sure to avoid the self-imposed mistakes outlined below.

Investing in cash

For some reason, a tonne of TFSA assets are invested in cash. This is perhaps the worst mistake you can make. You don’t necessarily have to have 100% of your money in stocks, but there are certainly better options than cash.

For example, several short-term bond funds are delivering annual income streams of around 3%. Because these funds only invest in short duration bonds, they’re largely insulated from swings in interest rates. Plus, because they’re stashed in a TFSA, they’re completely protected from taxes.

If you have a multi-year time horizon, your best bet is still to invest in a diversified portfolio, complete with a sizable equity allocation. But if you have near-term needs or just want to remain conservative, choose low-risk bond funds instead of cash. After all, even a 3% interest rate is better than a 2% interest rate.

Not catching up

Few Canadians are able to meet their annual maximum contribution limit, which this year is set at $6,000. Even fewer Canadians ever meet their cumulative contribution maximum.

If you put $6,000 into your TFSA this year, that’s incredible, but you should know that you likely have even more room to invest. That’s because any unused contribution room from previous years rolls forward. This is a huge lesson to learn: you can’t lose your TFSA contribution room!

In total, you’re allowed to contribute $63,500 to your TFSA. That’s the sum of every year’s contribution limit since the TFSA was created. If you ever withdrew money from a TFSA, that also opens additional contribution space. Work hard to meet your annual contribution max, but never forget that your real maximum is much higher.

Mixing priorities

A TFSA is technically a “savings account,” but you can invest in anything you’d like. Due to its tax-free status, many investors are urged to invest in dividend stocks. These stocks pay monthly or quarterly cash to shareholders simply for owning the stock. Often, you can earn a 3%, 5%, or even a 7% dividend every year.

Owning dividend stocks certainly isn’t a poor choice, but it often prevents you from owning high-growth companies. These companies prefer to keep the cash for themselves in order to reinvest it back into the business at an attractive rate. The capital gains you can earn from these stocks can often outpace the income that dividend stocks produce.

It doesn’t matter if you make your money with dividends or capital gains: both are tax free. If you have a long-term time horizon, don’t be persuaded into dividend stocks purely for the tax benefits. Stocks that don’t pay dividends have just as much upside, if not more, and are similarly protected from taxes.

Fool contributor Ryan Vanzo has no position in any stocks mentioned. 

More on Investing

dividends grow over time
Stocks for Beginners

2 Canadian Growth Stocks for Your TFSA in 2026

Are you wondering what types of stocks could give you the biggest returns in your TFSA? These two stocks could…

Read more »

space ship model takes off
Stocks for Beginners

2 Canadian Growth Stocks Set to Skyrocket in the Next 12 Months

Kraken and Propel are two smaller Canadian growth stocks where momentum is already building, not just a “maybe someday” story.

Read more »

hand stacking money coins
Dividend Stocks

2 Canadian Dividend Giants to Buy With Rates on Hold

These stocks should benefit if rates remain at current levels or move higher.

Read more »

tsx today
Stock Market

TSX Today: What to Watch for in Stocks on Tuesday, May 26

The TSX reached a fresh all-time high on Monday as easing fears around the Strait of Hormuz lifted sentiment, though…

Read more »

Income and growth financial chart
Investing

3 Canadian Stocks With the Potential to Triple in Value Within 5 Years

These Canadian stocks have the growth potential and execution to deliver massive returns over the next five years.

Read more »

up arrow on wooden blocks
Dividend Stocks

If Rates Fall, These 3 TSX Stocks Could Rally First

Rate cuts could spark a fast rebound in out-of-favour Canadian financial stocks that still have earnings and dividend support.

Read more »

A red umbrella stands higher than a crowd of black umbrellas.
Bank Stocks

The #1 Canadian Dividend Stock I’d Hold Through Any Storm

This Canadian financial giant combines dependable dividends with strong earnings growth and long-term stability.

Read more »

Couple working on laptops at home and fist bumping
Stocks for Beginners

The Absolute Best Canadian Stocks to Buy and Hold Forever in a TFSA

These absolute best Canadian stocks are well-positioned to capitalize on multi-year demand trends and deliver solid growth.

Read more »