It seems every week for the last decade, somebody has declared Canadian real estate is massively overvalued. Yet, despite this bearish sentiment, the market keeps on marching higher.
Sure, there have been certain markets that have struggled. Pretty much every city in Alberta has seen housing prices collapse along with the price of oil. Vancouver showed some temporary weakness, too. But these haven’t been enough to impact nationwide prices, which continue to make new record highs.
Much of the attention of bearish prognosticators has been focused on the Greater Toronto Area, which isn’t very surprising, considering it’s the largest city in the country and its real estate has performed exceptionally well. These folks say metrics like the price-to-rent ratio and the price-to-average income ratio suggest the market’s real estate is massively overvalued.
But the ugly truth is, many of these analysts have been consistently wrong for more than a decade. Will they continue to be wrong going forward? Or will they finally be vindicated with a collapse?
Nobody knows the answer for sure, but one of Canada’s top real estate experts has recently made a major shift in its opinion.
No longer risky
The Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation’s (CMHC) recent Housing Market Assessment had a very interesting change in it.
For the first time in years, the Crown corporation responsible for insuring the majority of high-ratio Canadian mortgages downgraded the Toronto housing market from highly vulnerable to moderately vulnerable. Victoria remains the only major market in the highly vulnerable category.
In fact, CMHC went one step further and downgraded Toronto’s risk from overvaluation from moderate to low. Yes, you read that right. CMHC no longer thinks Toronto’s real estate is overvalued.
There are undoubtedly Toronto real estate bears reading this — folks who are downplaying this recent CMHC report. But we must remember that CMHC has more data than just about anyone. These people know real estate and can use their expertise to make some pretty informed decisions. I won’t argue that CMHC is infallible, because we all know that isn’t true. But it’s silly to discount its official opinion because it differs from the prevailing thought.
How to invest in Toronto real estate
Conversely, if you’re bearish on Toronto real estate, then you’ll want to short Home Capital stock. Doing so would be relatively inexpensive, since shares are close to a 52-week high.
Home Capital is an alternative mortgage lender with a huge chunk of its portfolio invested in the Toronto real estate market. It specializes in certain borrowers that are still a good credit risk that might not qualify at a traditional bank. And it works with mortgage brokers, who are usually the first person called when someone’s bank rejects their mortgage application.
After spending a couple of years in stability mode after a run on the bank eroded confidence — you might remember Warren Buffett coming to the company’s rescue — Home Capital has resumed its growth. Mortgage originations were up nearly 17% during its most recent quarter, while earnings were up more than 60% compared to the same quarter last year.
The company has also reported a nice increase in net interest margins, as it both increases rates to borrowers and decreases rates paid to savers inside its GICs and high-interest savings accounts.
Finally, although the company no longer pays a dividend, it has been aggressive in returning cash to shareholders via share buybacks. In the last year alone, Home Capital has repurchased nearly $400 million worth of shares. It plans more repurchases going forward, too.
The bottom line
Home Capital shares are hitting a fresh 52-week high, which just goes to show how confident investors are about the Toronto property market. CMHC agrees with that assessment, too. Despite already posting huge gains, real estate in Toronto is still pretty healthy.
One little-known Canadian IPO has doubled in value in a matter of months, and renowned Canadian stock picker Iain Butler sees a potential millionaire-maker in waiting...
Because he thinks this fast-growing company looks a lot like Shopify, a stock Iain officially recommended 3 years ago - before it skyrocketed by 1,211%!
Iain and his team just published a detailed report on this tiny TSX stock. Find out how you can access the NEXT Shopify today!
This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.
Fool contributor Nelson Smith has no position in any of the stocks mentioned.