Warning: If Shopify (TSX:SHOP) Stock Does This, Then History Says it’s a Sell

If Shopify (TSX:SHOP)(NYSE:SHOP) stock goes up much further, it’ll join some elite company. Unfortunately, this has historically never been a good sign.

| More on:
Businessman pulling out wooden brick from toppling stack

Image source: Getty Images.

Shopify (TSX:SHOP)(NYSE:SHOP) stock has been one of the biggest beneficiaries of a COVID-19 world, as thousands of businesses look at selling their wares online for the first time ever. Many recently unemployed folks are also using this opportunity to seize their own e-commerce dreams.

If you’re selling product online, Shopify is the gold standard. The company provides everything from a website template to payment processing. It even has fulfillment centres in major cities to help cut down on shipping times — real estate its sellers can use. Shopify even offers financing to various merchants — cash infusions backed by sales data.

With that much going for it, it’s easy to see why Shopify stock has been an investor favourite for years now. We’re taught to seek companies with a sustainable competitive advantage, and Shopify has exactly that. There’s huge potential for it to raise prices over time, but for now, CEO Tobi Lütke and his team are keeping prices low to encourage growth.

This simple business plan has elevated Shopify stock to the second largest in the entire Toronto Stock Exchange, trailing only the biggest company in Canada, Royal Bank. Shopify’s market cap is rapidly approaching $100 billion. Royal Bank has a comfortable lead today — its market cap is more than $117 billion — the gap is smaller than you’d think. Just one more big move from Shopify, and it could overtake Canada’s largest bank and become the biggest company in the country.

Maybe Shopify shareholders shouldn’t cheer such a move. If history is any guide, becoming Canada’s most valuable stock isn’t a great prize.

The top stock jinx?

Since 1999, there have been several stocks that have surged past Royal Bank and become the largest stocks in Canada. And every time, success atop the market was short-lived.

Let’s start with Nortel Networks, a company that many veteran Canadian investors know well. It surged past Royal Bank and eventually became the largest company in Canada by a factor of 10. That’s right; it had a market cap of 10 times the next largest stock. Nortel is the whole reason why we have a capped TSX Composite Index. By 2001, it had relinquished its “largest company” title back to Royal Bank, and by 2009 the company was bankrupt.

Other companies have surpassed Royal Bank since Nortel was so dominant, including BlackBerry, Potash Corporation of Saskatchewan, Encana, and Valeant. BlackBerry is a shell of its former self and has very little smartphone exposure these days. Potash Corporation fell from grace and eventually merged with Agrium to form Nutrien. Encana split into two companies before weak commodity prices drove the stock much lower. It has also changed its name to Ovintiv.  And Valeant — now called Bausch Health — collapsed under a massive debt load and allegations of fraud.

These companies all have one major thing in common, something Shopify stock holders might want to pay attention to. Surpassing Royal Bank was the peak of each company’s success. And it proved a terrible time to buy the stock. In fact, it was a great time to sell.

Will the same thing happen to Shopify stock?

Naysayers argue Shopify stock is different, pointing to things like Lütke’s big ownership position, a passionate group of employees, and the company’s long-term outlook. These are great things Shopify has going for it.

But it’s easy to argue the other top companies listed had plenty going for them, too.

Ultimately, the most important factor for Shopify stock — or any stock, for that matter — is sentiment. As long as investors keep getting excited about the company, its share price will do well. But Shopify is expensive, and it could fall a long way if that sentiment ever changes.

Sentiment is a big reason why those other companies surpassed Royal Bank, and that didn’t end well for any of them. However, it takes just one company to buck a trend. Maybe Shopify is that company.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

Fool contributor Nelson Smith owns shares of Shopify and Royal Bank of Canada. Tom Gardner owns shares of Bausch Health Companies and Shopify. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends Bausch Health Companies, Shopify, and Shopify. The Motley Fool recommends Nutrien Ltd.

More on Tech Stocks

online shopping
Tech Stocks

Is Shopify Stock a Buy in March?

Shopify stock has had a volatile run, but fundamentals are strong, and valuations are much lower after its 71% decline.

Read more »

data analyze research
Tech Stocks

2 Top Stocks to Buy in March 2023

Given their solid financials and high-growth prospects, these two stocks are excellent buys right now.

Read more »

Male IT Specialist Holds Laptop and Discusses Work with Female Server Technician. They're Standing in Data Center, Rack Server Cabinet with Cloud Server Icon and Visualization
Tech Stocks

Is Kinaxis Stock a Buy at 52-Week Highs?

Kinaxis stock is up 31% in the last six months, though 5% in the last year. So as the stock…

Read more »

healthcare pharma
Tech Stocks

Should You Buy WELL Health Stock After Q4 Earnings?

Given its solid financials, healthy growth prospects, and attractive valuation, I am bullish on WELL Health.

Read more »

A data center engineer works on a laptop at a server farm.
Tech Stocks

2 Tech Stocks That Could Set You Up for Life

Canadian investors can set themselves up for the future with top tech stocks like Descartes Systems Group Inc. (TSX:DSG).

Read more »

dividends grow over time
Tech Stocks

Got $1,000? Buy These Hot Growth Stocks Before They Take Off

Investors won’t want to miss these buying opportunities. Here are three discounted growth stocks to load up on today.

Read more »

Woman has an idea
Tech Stocks

2 No-Brainer Stocks to Buy With $500 Right Now

Given their solid financials, healthy growth prospects, and attractive valuation, I am bullish on these two TSX stocks.

Read more »

Business success with growing, rising charts and businessman in background
Tech Stocks

A Bull Market Is Coming: 1 Growth Stock Down 33% to Buy and Hold Forever

Here's why quality growth stocks such as Aritzia are compelling long-term bets for TSX investors.

Read more »