CN Rail Beats CP Rail’s Bid: Which Should You Buy?

Huge news hit the headlines, as Canadian National Railway (TSX:CNR)(NYSE:CNI) outbid Canadian Pacific Railway Ltd. (TSX:CP)(NYSE:CP), but which is the better buy?

On the surface, the answer to the question posed in the title of this article seems pretty clear. In a bid for the Kansas City Southern railroad, Canadian railways Canadian Pacific Railway (TSX: CP)(NYSE: CP) and Canadian National Railway (TSX: CNR)(NYSE: CNI) both showed interest.

However, after it seemed set in stone that CP Rail would win the bid with its US$25 billion deal, CN Rail then swooped in with a 21% premium — a total of US$29.9 billion!

So, on the surface, it seems that with CN Rail as the winner of the Kansas City Southern rail acquisition that it would be the one to buy today. This was a huge win for the company, as the Kansas City rail gives exposure from Canada down to Mexico

But don’t go diving in just yet.

The CN Rail case

The US$29.9 billion bid by CN Rail included $325 for each Kansas City Southern share and $200 a share in cash and 1.059 CN shares. In comparison, CP Rail offered $275 per share, including $90 in cash.

Yet while the move sent Kansas City Southern shares up on Tuesday, the news caused CN shares to drop and CP Rail shares to rise. So, what gives?

Shareholders may worry that there will be too many costs associated with the new route. The deal should generate cash flow, though incrementally, as the business makes a transition. In the meantime, this acquisition creates a huge debt the company will need to pay down long term.

Yet CN Rail management is confident that its earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization (EBITDA) will eventually be $1 billion. This comes from increased revenues coming from lower-cost shipping alternatives in comparison to its current trucking routes.

And it’s not over yet. The company still has some regulatory hoops to jump through. This can be a long process in the United States to prove the company is operating in the public’s interest. Yet that didn’t seem to matter to CN Rail when it jumped into a bidding war, likely caused by the current cheap financing available.

The CP Rail case

All of these same facts would have been true for CP Rail had the company taken on the acquisition. CP Rail would have had access from Canada to Mexico, and it would have taken on a huge debt in the process. Investors looking for the continued strong revenue reports would have been relieved to see the deal fall out, especially in the short term.

But long-term investors may not be as thrilled. The company has come a long way since the reboot of 2012. It’s done a lot of cost cutting along with a lot of reinvestment. This has caused shares to soar in the last few years, and last year was no exception.

Meanwhile, CN Rail seems better positioned than CP Rail for the acquisition any way. It has a larger footprint, with not as much overlap in its route compared to Kansas City Southern. This can save a lot of travel time when shipping products that bring in serious revenue.

Foolish takeaway

It comes down to why you’re investing. If you’re looking to invest short term, then I would maybe stick it out with CP Rail stock. The company is up 47% in the last year and 754% in the last decade for a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 24%! Solid earnings since the reinvigoration back in 2012. It also offers a 0.82% dividend yield. You’re likely to continue seeing what you’ve seen the last decade: strong growth and income that’s steady as a rail.

However, this might be a prime opportunity for investors to get in on CN Rail if they plan to stick it out for decades to come. Honestly, when it comes to either company, they are solid. Shares are still up 35% in the last year and 408% in the last decade for a CAGR of 17.63%. It also has a dividend yield of 1.65%.

But yes, it will take a while for CN Rail to pay down this debt. While it might mean there’s a slowdown in the next year or two, it’s likely to speed up significantly over the next decade. Basically, CN Rail now has the opportunity that CP Rail created for itself back in 2012.

Fool contributor Amy Legate-Wolfe owns shares of Canadian Pacific Railway Limited. David Gardner owns shares of Canadian National Railway. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends Canadian National Railway. The Motley Fool recommends Canadian National Railway.

More on Investing

a person watches a downward arrow crash through the floor
Dividend Stocks

A TFSA Loss Doesn’t Create New Room: Here’s the Rebuilding Plan I’d Use

A falling investment won’t create TFSA contribution room. I’d rebuild using the room I actually have and a portfolio that…

Read more »

Forklift in a warehouse
Dividend Stocks

A 7.9% Dividend Stock for Monthly Retirement Income

This Canadian REIT trades at a 38.8% discount to a key valuation measure, and offers a 7.9% yield, paid monthly,…

Read more »

hand stacks coins
Dividend Stocks

Building a $1,000-a-Month Dividend Income Stream: What It Actually Takes

Wondering what it takes to earn $1,000/month in dividends? Here's some different scenarios and stocks that can help get you…

Read more »

A series of red ladders lead to successively higher levels
Dividend Stocks

Colliers Stock: The Engineering Business Behind the Real Estate Name

Colliers still earns from real estate, but engineering now gives investors a second business to follow.

Read more »

shopper checks her receipt
Dividend Stocks

2 Safe Canadian Stocks to Buy With $7,000

Loblaw (TSX:L) and another safety play that could be a great fit for Canadian investors seeking lower betas and greater…

Read more »

dreaming of financial success
Dividend Stocks

Telus vs. Fortis: Which Stock Would I Choose for a More Dependable Payout?

Telus pays more today after its reset. I’d choose Fortis for the payout I’d rather count on over several years.

Read more »

a person looks out a window into a cityscape
Dividend Stocks

This 3% Dividend Stock Pays Cash Out Every Month

Boardwalk REIT pays $0.15 a unit every month, a yield near 3%. See Q3 results, the buyback story and the…

Read more »

shoppers in an indoor mall
Dividend Stocks

2 Top TSX Dividend Stocks With High Yields Worth Considering Now

These TSX stocks offer high yields of over 5.5%, have sustainbale payouts, and are well-positioned to keep paying their dividends.

Read more »