Better Airline Buy: Air Canada Stock vs. Exchange Income

With its more predictable cash flows and a monthly dividend, this airline stock looks to be a better buy than Air Canada stock.

The airline industry is a tough area to operate and invest in. In the case of Air Canada (TSX: AC) stock, it can make big moves up or down without warning. For example, it could make more profits when the economy is doing well and the stock could rise as a result. Here’s its long-term stock price chart to give a taste of its stock volatility.

AC Chart

AC data by YCharts

Technically, it means that investors could potentially target to buy AC stock at a low and profit on a pop from good news. However, it would be a more speculative investment because of its highly unpredictable nature.

Recently, Air Canada stock has taken a dive seemingly after it provided preliminary results for its second quarter (Q2) as well as updates for its full-year 2024 guidance.

The preliminary results for Q2 included operating revenue growth of 2% to $5.5 billion versus a year ago. Unfortunately, with a sharp cut of 6.4% in its operating margin, operating income came in at $466 million, which was down 42% year over year. Adjusted EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization), a cash flow proxy, of $914 million, was down 24%, with the adjusted EBITDA margin shrinking 5.9% to 16.6%. Not surprisingly, the airline stock reduced its 2024 guidance, including guiding down its adjusted EBITDA by about 18% to a range of $3.1 and $3.4 billion.

The negative results and outlook triggered a selloff of about 7% in the cyclical stock.

Interested investors who want to roll the dice and hope for a pop could wait for the stock to settle down, stop from falling, and perhaps consolidate a bit before taking a play position. The analyst consensus price target on Air Canada stock is $22.33, representing upside potential of almost 50% from the recent quotation of $14.90.

Exchange Income: A better airline buy

A better airline stock to potentially invest in is Exchange Income (TSX: EIF) in the sense that it makes more predictable cash flows and returns for its shareholders. Exchange Income is an acquisitive company in aerospace, aviation, and manufacturing.

In May, Exchange Income reported revenue and adjusted EBITDA growth of 14% year over year to $602 million and $111 million, respectively. Although it is also subject to the ups and downs of the economic cycle, it offers a nice monthly dividend, delivering stable returns to its investors.

It turns out the stock is also less volatile than AC stock, as shown in the graph below.

AC Chart

AC and EIF data by YCharts

Accounting for dividends, its total returns were much higher in the period.

EIF Total Return Level Chart

EIF Total Return Level data by YCharts

Today, at $47.37 per share, the monthly dividend stock trades at a margin of safety. The analyst consensus price target represents a good discount of 24% or upside potential of almost 32%. Importantly, the stock pays out a fine dividend yield of close to 5.6%, which helps investors ride through market volatility. To be sure, Exchange Income has a track record of paying out stable and growing dividends. Its 10-year dividend-growth rate is 4.2%.

Exchange Income is set to report its Q2 results this Friday. Interested investors can wait for its latest results then before making a decision.

Fool contributor Kay Ng has positions in Exchange Income. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Investing

electrical cord plugs into wall socket for more energy
Energy Stocks

What $12,000 in Canadian Utilities Could Add to Your Annual Income

At its recent price, Canadian Utilities could turn a $12,000 budget into about $418 a year in dividends.

Read more »

woman gazes forward out window to future
Dividend Stocks

Delaying CPP to 70: Is the Bigger Payout Worth the Wait?

Retirees should look at their unique situation around longevity, health, savings, and taxes to decide whether to delay CPP to…

Read more »

woman checks off all the boxes
Stocks for Beginners

TFSA Withdrawal Rules Every Canadian Investor Should Know

Looking to make a withdrawal from your TFSA? Here are some guidelines to keep in mind before you do.

Read more »

Super sized rock trucks take a load of platinum rich rock into the crusher.
Stocks for Beginners

Finning Stock: Can Canada’s Construction Plans Turn Into Shareholder Returns?

Finning can sell equipment before a project opens and service it long after. I’d watch the second sale as closely…

Read more »

tsx today
Stock Market

TSX Today: What to Watch for in Stocks on Thursday, November 19

The TSX could remain volatile today after falling for five consecutive sessions, as recovering oil prices offer some support while…

Read more »

nuclear power plant
Metals and Mining Stocks

Cameco After a Q3 Loss and a Dividend Hike: Buy Now, Hold, or Wait?

Cameco (TSX:CCO) stock took a big hit but could be emerging as a deep-value play as AI energy plays come…

Read more »

young people stare at smartphones
Dividend Stocks

2 TSX Stocks Under $100 Worth a Look

Quebecor (TSX:QBR.B) and another sub-$100 stock that looks seriously undervalued with a strong, growing dividend.

Read more »

senior man smiles next to a light-filled window
Dividend Stocks

A Tailor-Made TFSA Stock With a 4.6% Yield and Monthly Payouts

Sienna Senior Living can help turn part of a TFSA into monthly spending money, and fuller residences give its dividend…

Read more »