Should You Buy TD Bank or Royal Bank Stock Today?

Royal Bank is on a roll, but TD looks cheap.

Markets are treating Canada’s two largest banks in very different ways. TD Bank (TSX: TD) trades close to where it did three years ago, while Royal Bank (TSX: RY) is bumping up against its all-time high. Investors are wondering if TD stock is now undervalued and good to buy or if RY is the safer long-term bet right now for a TSX bank pick.

Investor wonders if it's safe to buy stocks now

Source: Getty Images

TD Bank

TD just reported its first quarterly loss in more than 20 years. The surprising fiscal third-quarter (Q3) 2024 numbers are due to a US$2.6 billion provision for fines connected to the ongoing regulatory investigations into the American business. TD is under scrutiny in the United States for not having adequate systems in place to detect and prevent money laundering. The Q3 charge is much larger than the US$450 million TD already set aside earlier this year and pushes the total anticipated penalties into the upper range of what analysts had speculated could occur. The total US$3 billion charges will use up a large chunk of the excess capital TD has carried on the balance sheet over the past year. As a result, TD said it sold part of its stake in Charles Schwab to cover the US$2.6 billion hit.

The issues south of the border have hurt the stock. TD trades for close to $79.50 at the time of writing. This is above the 12-month low of around $74 but is way off the $108 the stock reached in early 2022.

The risk at this point is that American regulators could impose growth restrictions on TD in the American market in addition to the fines. TD has spent billions of dollars on acquisitions over the past two decades to build a large American retail banking business that runs from Maine down the East Coast to Florida and would like to get even bigger in the United States.

On the positive side, the roughly US$3 billion in charges appears to be where the penalties will top out. This gives investors a bit of clarity on the situation. On an adjusted basis, TD actually delivered solid fiscal Q3 results despite all the distractions. Adjusted net income came in at $3.65 billion, which is in line with fiscal Q3 2023.

Royal Bank

Royal Bank trades near $154 at the time of writing. That’s just shy of the $155 record high.

The banking giant now sports a market capitalization of about $218 billion. This not only makes Royal Bank the largest company in Canada based on this metric but also places it among the biggest banks in the world.

Royal Bank is benefitting from its $13.5 billion acquisition of HSBC Canada earlier this year. The deal added more than 100 branches in Canada with roughly 780,000 clients. It also looks like a savvy move in comparison to TD’s abandoned US$13.4 billion takeover attempt of First Horizon, a U.S. regional bank, last year. Bank of Montreal (TSX: BMO) is feeling some pain, as well, after it paid US$16.3 billion in 2023 to acquire California-based Bank of the West. BMO negotiated the deal in late 2021 at the height of the post-covid bank rally. The purchase has been a drag on Bank of Montreal’s share price over the past year amid larger provisions for credit losses caused by soaring interest rates in 2022 and 2023.

Royal Bank isn’t cheap at its current trailing 12-month price-to-earning multiple of 14.1, but you get a best-in-class pick and a decent 3.7% dividend yield.

Is one a better bet?

Conservative buy-and-hold investors should probably stick with Royal Bank. The long-term chart for the banking giant suggests that buying at high points still pays off in the long run.

Contrarian investors who are willing to take on some additional downside risk and are willing to ride out more turbulence might prefer to go with TD today. The 5% yield is attractive, and the stock should eventually recover once all the issues in the American business are put to bed.

The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. Fool contributor Andrew Walker has no position in any stock mentioned.

More on Bank Stocks

data analyze research
Stocks for Beginners

TD’s Dividend Is Only Half the Investment Case: Here’s the Recovery Math

TD’s dividend pays you while you wait. The bigger payoff depends on how much more the bank can earn from…

Read more »

traders work at stock exchange
Stocks for Beginners

Canadian Bank Stocks: Buy, Sell, or Hold for 2027?

Explore the Big Six, their latest earnings and dividend yields, with income and defensive picks.

Read more »

A worker uses a double monitor computer screen in an office.
Bank Stocks

Canadian Bank Stocks in Late 2026: Which to Buy and Which to Skip

Canada’s banking sector is a bedrock of stability but a Big Bank stock stands out if you’re investing before 2026…

Read more »

The RRSP (Canadian Registered Retirement Savings Plan) is a smart way to save and invest for the future
Bank Stocks

Maxing Out Your TFSA Is Just the Beginning: Here’s What to Do Next

Maxing out your TFSA is not only a financial achievement but also the beginning of the next phase of your…

Read more »

pig shows concept of sustainable investing
Stocks for Beginners

How I’d Turn Quarterly Bank Dividends Into a Monthly Paycheque

Quarterly bank dividends can fund regular monthly transfers without choosing stocks for payment dates.

Read more »

dividend growth for passive income
Bank Stocks

How Much to Invest in TD Bank Stock for $5,000 a Year in Dividends

TD Bank (TSX:TD) stock has been so resilient lately and it's a massive shareholder-friendly dividend giant worth buying up.

Read more »

Group of people in a line at an ATM waiting to make a cash withdrawal
Stocks for Beginners

Scotiabank vs. BMO: Which Bank Would I Choose for Retirement Income?

Scotiabank gets my retirement-income preference, while BMO offers a lower adjusted payout ratio and U.S. recovery potential.

Read more »

Happy golf player walks the course
Stocks for Beginners

The TFSA Investment Strategy I’d Use to Build a Retirement Paycheque

This TFSA investment strategy combines global growth, bonds, and dividend income to help build a reliable retirement paycheque.

Read more »