S&P 500 at All-Time Highs: Why Canadians Should Shop Local Instead

Toronto-Dominion Bank (TSX:TD) stock is cheaper than its U.S. peers.

As of this writing, the U.S.’s famous S&P 500 stock market index was at 5,942.47, down just 2.43% from its all-time high of 6,090.27, set on December 6, 2024. Not only is the S&P 500 at an all-time high level, but it is also arguably approaching an all-time high valuation. At today’s level, the index trades at 29.67 times earnings, according to GuruFocus. It also trades at a high book value ratio.

By contrast, the S&P/TSX Composite Index is relatively cheap. Trading at 21 times trailing earnings, 16.5 times estimated forward earnings, and two times book value, it does not have the typical characteristics of an overheated market. Granted, the TSX is above historically “normal” valuations, just like the U.S. markets. However, it is cheaper in an absolute sense, ignoring the qualitative differences between Canadian and U.S. stocks. In this article, I will explore why I don’t see these qualitative differences as being great enough to justify the current U.S. premium and why the TSX Index is likely worth the investment today.

woman looks at iPhone

Source: Getty Images

Canadian markets cheaper

As mentioned previously, the Canadian markets trade at lower multiples than U.S. markets. That could be because Canadian companies have lower growth or profit prospects than U.S. companies do — it’s hard to beat NVIDIA’s growth and margins, without a doubt. However, there are many cases of individual Canadian stocks priced more cheaply than U.S. stocks while having comparable growth.

Consider Toronto-Dominion Bank (TSX: TD), for example. It’s a Canadian bank stock whose revenue grew about 8% last year — faster than the large U.S. banks on average. Despite that, it trades at under 10 times earnings, which is much cheaper than the big U.S. banks.

Why is TD so much cheaper than the large U.S. banks, which trade at about 15 times earnings these days?

A big part of it is the simple fact that TD Bank got into a bit of trouble last year. It settled with the U.S. Department of Justice in a money-laundering probe, paying out $3 billion and agreeing to a $430 billion asset cap. However, TD’s U.S. retail business does not have much more than $430 billion in assets now, and its U.S. investment banking and Canadian banking businesses are unaffected. So, TD can re-invest the money it’s not allowed to invest in U.S. retail into other parts of its business.

TD is just one example among many quality Canadian companies trading at discounts to their U.S. peers. Similar examples can be found in sectors like energy, utilities, and non-bank financials.

Lower dividend taxes

A final fact you might want to take into account when deciding whether to invest in the U.S. or Canada is taxation. U.S. stocks have a 15% dividend withholding tax taken off them whether you hold them in a taxable account or a TFSA. Canadian stocks have no such tax. So, as a Canadian, you have a slight “edge” when buying Canadian stocks.

Foolish takeaway

The U.S. markets are certainly impressive. With their big tech companies and impressive financials, they certainly have a lot going for them. However, Canadian markets have a lot of value under the hood as well. So, perhaps this year, include some Canadian stocks in your portfolio if you aren’t doing so already.

Fool contributor Andrew Button has positions in Toronto-Dominion Bank. The Motley Fool recommends Nvidia. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Dividend Stocks

dreaming of financial success
Dividend Stocks

Passive Income: Is Enbridge Stock Still a Buy for Its Dividend Yield?

Enbridge’s resilient cash flow profile, solid payout history, and a growing earnings base strengthen its appeal as a high yield…

Read more »

diversification and asset allocation are crucial investing concepts
Dividend Stocks

How Many Enbridge Shares You Need for $1,000 in Dividends

Enbridge pays $3.88 a share. At $68.59, you need 258 shares, about $17,696, to earn $1,000 a year in annual…

Read more »

boy in bowtie and glasses gives positive thumbs up
Dividend Stocks

3 Blue-Chip Dividend Stocks Every Canadian Should Own

These Canadian blue-chip dividend stocks are known for consistently paying and increasing their dividends year after year.

Read more »

financial chart graphs and oil pumps on a field
Dividend Stocks

4.2% Yield: 1 Perfect TFSA Dividend Stock Paying Every Month

Whitecap Resources pays monthly, yields roughly 4.2%, and just boosted its dividend and cut debt by $1.3 billion. See why…

Read more »

up arrow on wooden blocks
Dividend Stocks

Standout Canadian Blue-Chip Stocks to Own in 2027

Explore Canadian blue-chip stocks for 2027, with Canadian National, Fortis and Manulife offering distinct paths to earnings growth and dividend…

Read more »

Traffic jam with rows of slow cars
Dividend Stocks

Canadian Tire Stock: What Its Cash Flow Says About the Dividend

Canadian Tire’s dividend is worth checking against the cash it keeps after stocking stores, funding loans and investing in the…

Read more »

A worker overlooks an oil refinery plant.
Dividend Stocks

Got $10,000? 2 Canadian Dividend Stocks to Buy Before Their Next Breather

Enbridge and Brookfield Infrastructure are two Canadian dividend stocks that offer strong, growing, and predictable dividends.

Read more »

hand stacks coins
Dividend Stocks

3 Canadian Dividend Stocks for Steady Income

With solid financials, reliable cash flows, consistent dividend growth, and clear growth prospects, these three Canadian stocks are ideal buys…

Read more »