This Beaten-Down Value Stock Yields Over 3.5%: Is it a Buy?

Canadian Tire (TSX:CTC.A) looks like a durable retailer going for cheap with a strong dividend.

| More on:
Key Points
  • Don’t ignore a sub-4% yield in a rising market—dividend growth and share price gains can matter more than starting yield, especially if you buy in stages.
  • Canadian Tire looks like a solid dividend-growth candidate at a reasonable valuation, with strong in-house brands, a growing loyalty program, and improving resilience even if consumers stay cautious.

A 3.5% dividend yield might not seem like all that much to write home about, especially in an environment where 5-6% yields still exist. Any way you look at it, though, we’re in an up market and, with that, there’s bound to be a bit more yield compression.

Even with dividend increases considered, a rapidly rising market tends to pave the way for lower dividend yields. And while that might be discouraging for new passive income investors looking to put fresh money to work, I think that there’s no shame in settling for a yield that’s at or even a few basis points below 4%.

At the end of the day, you’ll either continue to benefit from appreciation after you’ve hit the buy button, or shares will reverse lower, and you’ll have an opportunity to get more yield for a lower price. In my view, incremental buying seems perfect for this climate. That way, you have skin in the game, but you also won’t kick yourself if stocks move lower and yields start creeping higher after all the yield compression we’ve witnessed across the board in the past two years.

For the most part, dividend growth and appreciation could be the name of the game. And, in my humble opinion, that makes dividend growth investing more rewarding than income investing with a focus on the upfront yield. When it comes to dividend growth, it’s more about how large that dividend and your yield based on invested principal can grow over the span of many years.

stocks climbing green bull market

Source: Getty Images

Canadian Tire

When it comes to a retailer like Canadian Tire (TSX:CTC.A), which has a well-covered payout with room to grow, I do like the road ahead, even if the Canadian consumer isn’t in a spend-heavy state right now, given lingering inflation, muted employment, and, perhaps most concerning, the potential AI impact on jobs over the next three to five years as companies look to start automating various junior white-collar roles.

In a way, it feels like the corporate ladder is already being lifted. And while that could cause more Canadian consumers to hold back on discretionary purchases while socking more money away for a rainy day, I still think that Canadian Tire is a discretionary company that can do well in a climate that’s not at all sanguine.

In a prior piece, I highlighted Canadian Tire’s strong homegrown brands, which now include Hudson’s Bay Company (HBC), as well as its decent value proposition. Indeed, you don’t need to break the bank by shopping at the local Canadian Tire. In fact, some of the private labels and exclusive brands are quite competitive (think sports goods and consumables).

A durable dividend-growth rockstar in the making?

Of course, Canadian Tire is far from a consumer staple, but at the same time, the firm is doing so many things right at the operating level. Perhaps there’s no mystery as to why shares have gained nearly 16% year-to-date despite question marks surrounding the consumer. With high-margin brands in the portfolio (the legendary HBC is perhaps its strongest), a booming Triangle loyalty program, and a growing mix of essentials, my guess is that Canadian Tire is a more resilient beast for sideways economies.

At 13.8 times forward price to earnings, the $10.6 billion Canadian icon is just underestimated and too cheap to pass up, whether you’re in it for the growing dividend or the upside to be had if Canadian consumers feel better about spending again, perhaps once inflation plunges, tariff worries dissipate, and the economy has a chance to heat up.

Fool contributor Joey Frenette has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Investing

dividends can compound over time
Dividend Stocks

Here’s an 8.3% Dividend Stock That Pays Out Monthly

This Canadian monthly dividend stock yields 8.46% and trades on the TSX. Here is what income investors should know before…

Read more »

investor schemes to buy stocks before market notices them
Energy Stocks

CNQ or Enbridge? Here’s the Better Dividend Stock Right Now

Enbridge stock offers a 5.4% yield, but Canadian Natural Resources (TSX:CNQ) stock brings a cheaper valuation and faster dividend growth.…

Read more »

Thrilled women riding roller coaster at amusement park, enjoying fun outdoor activity.
Dividend Stocks

2 Dividend Stocks Yielding 4% to Hold in a Rocky Market

These stocks should deliver steady dividend growth in the next few years.

Read more »

golden sunset in crude oil refinery with pipeline system
Energy Stocks

Here’s How I’d Turn $14,000 in a TFSA Into $155 a Quarter

Canadians can easily turn their TFSA into a cash machine to receive recurring income streams.

Read more »

A family watches tv using Roku at home.
Dividend Stocks

This TSX Dividend Yield Seems Too Good to Be True: Here’s the Truth

Rogers Communications (TSX:RCI.B) looks like a dividend growth winner despite industry pressures.

Read more »

A train passes Morant's curve in Banff National Park in the Canadian Rockies.
Dividend Stocks

Here’s What TFSA Millionaires Know That You Might Not

Your TFSA is more than a mere savings account. Here’s how you can turn it into a successful long-term investment…

Read more »

dividend growth for passive income
Dividend Stocks

The 5 Highest-Yielding TSX Stocks, and the Risk Hidden in Each Payout

An 11% dividend yield looks tempting, but it can also be a warning that the share price is in trouble.

Read more »

woman checks off all the boxes
Tech Stocks

The 1 Number Tech Investors Should Watch

Shopify’s Rule of 40 score of 52 shows it’s pairing fast growth with real cash generation, but the stock’s valuation…

Read more »