Pembina vs. TC Energy: Which Pipeline Stock Would I Buy for the Next Decade?

I’d choose TC Energy for its natural gas focus over the next decade. Pembina has a case of its own if a bigger starting cheque is the priority.

Key Points
  • Pembina’s annualized dividend is $2.94 and TC Energy’s is $3.51.
  • Pembina offers the higher yield at recent prices.
  • I’d lean towards TC Energy for gas transmission and check how new projects turn into cash.

Pipelines look like the sort of investment you could buy and forget. Then the company starts building one, and you remember just how expensive a very long tube can be. I’d look at what customers will pay for over the next decade and how much it’ll cost shareholders to get there.

Hourglass and stock price chart

Source: Getty Images

Who pays

Pipeline operators often earn fees for transporting energy or making space available. A producer has to care about what oil or gas sells for each day. A transporter can have more predictable revenue, depending on how its contracts are written and how well its customers can pay.

A company can earn money from more than the pipe. Processing plants, export facilities and marketing can add revenue and introduce exposure to commodity prices. I’d decide whether I want that mix or more of my return tied to gas transmission. The price of gas can still matter to a company that earns fees. Sustained low prices can change whether producers drill or whether customers want more capacity. I’d rather see a new route backed by customers willing to commit to using it before I pay for the growth.

For a decade-long purchase, I’d also look at when projects start earning. The bill for construction can show up years before customers are billed for service. A growing business needs enough room between the two to keep paying shareholders without borrowing simply to cover the cheque.

Two ways to earn

Pembina Pipeline (TSX: PPL) moves and processes energy and has marketing operations. Third-quarter adjusted operating earnings before interest, taxes and depreciation rose 9%, helped by its facilities and marketing businesses. That mix gives Pembina more ways to earn, and marketing gains can be less steady from quarter to quarter.

TC Energy (TSX: TRP) is more focused on natural gas transmission, alongside power investments. In November, it raised its 2026 outlook for comparable operating earnings before interest, taxes and depreciation to $11.8 billion to $12 billion. I’d see whether the stronger earnings turn into more cash after construction and borrowing costs.

Pembina’s quarterly $0.74 payment works out to about 4.2% at its recent close of $69.50. TC Energy’s quarterly $0.88 works out to about 3.9% at $89.99. The starting difference is small enough that I can put more weight on what I’d like to own over the full decade.

Compare the cheques

Here’s what separate $10,000 purchases would look like with whole shares and no trading fees. The payments are annualized from the latest declarations. Each row is an alternative purchase.

COMPANYRECENT PRICENUMBER OF SHARESANNUAL DIVIDENDANNUAL TOTAL PAYOUTFREQUENCYTOTAL INVESTMENT
PPL$69.50143$2.94$420.42Quarterly$9,938.50
TRP$89.99111$3.51$389.61Quarterly$9,988.89

I’d choose TC Energy because I’d like more exposure to the routes that carry gas to power producers and export markets. Before buying more, I’d watch for completed projects entering service and earning fees. That’s when I can start judging how much the spending adds to what shareholders can spend.

I’d also keep my expectations for the next dividend increase separate from the starting payment. A smaller yield can catch up through growth, but I wouldn’t assume that happens on schedule. The evidence I’d want is new cash coming in after the projects that were meant to earn it are running.

Pembina could be a better fit if I wanted more income right away or liked the broader energy services mix. Either way, I’d hold the stock alongside other Canadian dividend stocks. I’d also check how much exposure I have to big projects before adding a second pipeline inside a Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA).

Bottom line

I’d buy TC Energy for the next decade and keep tabs on how much its new gas capacity earns. Pembina’s extra income is welcome, though I’d give the long-term edge to the business that gives me the gas transmission exposure I’m after.

Fool contributor Amy Legate-Wolfe has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Pembina Pipeline. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

More on Energy Stocks

Start line on the highway
Dividend Stocks

2 Simple Canadian Stocks to Buy With $1,000

Looking for Canadian stocks to buy with $1,000? Explore Enbridge and Scotiabank for dividend income and a straightforward long-term starting…

Read more »

woman considering the future
Energy Stocks

Should You Buy Enbridge Stock Today for Its 5.7% Dividend Yield?

Discover the factors affecting Enbridge’s stock as it faces challenges with acquisitions and increased capital spending.

Read more »

TFSA (Tax free savings account) acronym on wooden cubes on the background of stacks of coins
Energy Stocks

How I’d Build $57 a Month in Tax-Free TFSA Income With Northland and Peyto

Northland and Peyto are benefitting from strong sector fundamentals, resulting in rising cash flows, and possibly more dividend hikes.

Read more »

oil pumps at sunset
Energy Stocks

This 6.2% Dividend Stock Brings Investors Money Every Month

This 6.2%-yielding TSX dividend stock recently raised its monthly payout again, backed by rising production, strong cash flow, and promising…

Read more »

A worker gives a business presentation.
Energy Stocks

The Bank of Canada Hiked Rates: 2 Dividend Stocks Built for Higher Rates

Canadian Natural Resources (TSX:CNQ) and another name that couldn't be bothered by rate hikes.

Read more »

diversification is an important part of building a stable portfolio
Energy Stocks

How I’d Structure a $10,000 TFSA for Steady Income, Stock By Stock

Wondering how to earn over $325 per year in your TFSA? This simple 4-stock portfolio bulks up in some of…

Read more »

dividends can compound over time
Energy Stocks

Algonquin Stock: Income Opportunity or Another Yield Trap?

Algonquin’s latest results show progress. I’d still need more evidence that the utility can fund the dividend after investing in…

Read more »

3 colorful arrows racing straight up on a black background.
Energy Stocks

Enbridge’s $38 Billion Backlog Is Why This Dividend Stock Remains a Strong Hold

Enbridge’s $38 billion backlog supports its growth outlook. See why this dividend stock remains a strong hold for investors seeking…

Read more »