Take Stock – No, This Is Not the End of the Potash Story

The week’s edition of Take Stock is here! Check it out!

| More on:
The Motley Fool

Take Stock is the Motley Fool Canada’s free investing newsletter.  To have future editions delivered directly to you, simply click here now

Dear Fellow Fools,

If you own shares of Potash Corp. (TSX:POT,NYSE:POT), as I do, then this has been a tough week.

The stock declined a touch after the company reported disappointing earnings last week, but it really hit the fan on Tuesday when Uralkali, one of the world’s largest potash producers with about 20% of global production, announced its decision to stop selling through the Belarusian Potash Company (BPC) and direct all of its export volumes through Uralkali Trading.

The back story
The BPC was a joint agreement that accounted for about 43% of the global potash market. The other big share of the global potash market (~25%) is controlled by Canadian-based firm Canpotex — a marketing operation that is jointly owned by Potash Corp., Agrium (TSX:AGU), and Mosaic (NYSE:MOS).

Combined, these two entities (aka cartels) controlled about 70% of global potash supply. Historically, the two have worked in concert to maintain prices well above the marginal cost of production by refraining from flooding the market.

Commenting on Uralkali’s decision, Bernstein analyst Jeremy Redenius told the Financial Times, “This is as if Saudi Arabia left OPEC — for the potash sector, this is huge.”

With Uralkali pulling out of the BPC, this cozy, two-entity market essentially just gained a new supplier. Uralkali’s move essentially introduces another independent party into the potash market. What was two is now three.

Which is why, also in the Financial Times, BMO Capital Markets analyst Joel Jackson indicated that the breakdown of the BPC cartel market marked “the end of the potash world as we know it.”

The outlook

The end of the potash world as we know it!?

And yet, I still own my stake in Potash Corp. Here’s why.

As often happens, this news was met with a short-term panic. Don’t get me wrong — there are considerable implications for the industry and all stocks therein. But the analyst community and media have latched onto the remarks of Uralkali’s CEO that indicated the price of potash could tumble to $300/tonne by the end of this year as his company cranks up production. This price has been in the $400/tonne neighborhood of late.

For long-term-focused investors, however, the price of potash at the end of this year should be meaningless. Potash Corp. and its producing peers are stocks for the long run. They’re a play on the global reality of shrinking arable land and a growing population. To feed this growing population, the arable land that exists needs to become more productive. Fertilizer is at the root of this need and potash is fertilizer. Potash helps increase the productivity of the land. Nothing about this week’s announcement impacts this part of the equation.

The context

Everything about the announcement relates to the supply-side of the equation. But the thing is, the supply side has been under scrutiny for some time. Though the producers that form both BPC and Canpotex have had the market more or less to themselves for a number of years, evidence suggests that their level of control has been slipping.

Other suppliers are knocking on the industry’s door — more than 200 potential potash projects that involve potential capital expenditures of $50 billion have been proposed in the world.

The granddaddy of them all is BHP Billiton’s (NYSE:BHP) $14 billion Jansen project located in Saskatchewan. Jansen is a massive undertaking that has the potential to produce 8 million tonnes of potash per year — about 15% of 2012 potash supply. The final decision to go ahead with Jansen has not been made, but BHP has already sunk $2 billion into it.

Keep in mind, the potash industry has been built on controlling supply and convincing the world it needs this product. What better way to keep new supply out than making — at least temporarily — the economics of the industry appear unappealing? As illustrated by the $14 billion price tag on the Jansen project, building a new potash mine takes a lot of money upfront. You better be certain you understand the industry dynamics before wading in … and the industry’s dynamics appear to have just gone kaboom!

By cranking up production and potentially flooding the market with supply, thus temporarily stomping on the price of the commodity, there’s at least a fighting chance that the majority of these new entrants will be sent packing. New supply will be held at bay.

Moreover, current producers that exist outside of the big cartels, such as Germany’s K+S, are relatively high-cost. Bernstein Research indicates the company’s cash cost to be around $300/tonne — the big North American and Russian operations tend to have cash costs below $100/tonne. In a temporarily lower price environment, current producers will also get squeezed.

Keep new supply out and pinch current, high-cost suppliers: In one fell swoop, at the expense of a short-term blip, Uralkali has potentially allowed the old, tightly knit system of supply management to remain in place for a much longer time than it otherwise would have had potash prices remained relatively buoyant and the industry’s economics more favourable.

Over the long term, this week’s announcement may not have changed the supply side of the equation after all!

To be sure, this week’s news is a setback. But it’s not the end of the potash story that some are making it out to be, and long-term, it may ensure that the industry remains supply-side controlled — an attractive dynamic for investors.

In the meantime, Potash Corp. now offers a dividend yield of about 4.5% and with its recently announced $2 billion buyback program, at current levels the company can now acquire 7% of shares outstanding over the next 12 months.

Bottom line: This may have been a bad week, but long-term investors need not be shaken.

‘Til next time … happy investing and Fool on!


Iain Butler

Senior Analyst

Motley Fool Canada

Fool contributor Iain Butler owns shares of Potash.  The Motley Fool does not own shares of any companies mentioned at this time.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium service or advisor. We’re Motley! Questioning an investing thesis — even one of our own — helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer, so we sometimes publish articles that may not be in line with recommendations, rankings or other content.

More on Investing

growing plant shoots on stacked coins
Dividend Stocks

Here Are My Top 5 Dividend Aristocrats to Buy Right Now

Now is the time to buy these top five dividend aristocrats at their two-year low before they recover to 2021…

Read more »

Target. Stand out from the crowd
Stocks for Beginners

5 Stocks You Can Confidently Invest $500 in Right Now

Whether it's stocks making a comeback or proven investments over decades, these five belong in your portfolio.

Read more »

edit Businessman using calculator next to laptop

Unearthing Incredible Value: 2 Dirt-Cheap Commodity Stocks That Demand Attention Today

Barrick Gold (TSX:ABX) and another great mining stock look like huge value plays right here.

Read more »

A woman shops in a grocery store while pushing a stroller with a child

New Rules for Grocers: 1 Canadian Grocery Stock That Could Soar

Metro (TSX:MRU) stock looks poised to win as it signs onto the new grocery code of conduct.

Read more »

edit Real Estate Investment Trust REIT on double exsposure business background.
Dividend Stocks

Is NorthWest REIT Stock the Best High-Yield Dividend for You?

NorthWest REIT (TSX:NWH.UN) offers a substantial dividend, but exercise caution with this riskier stock.

Read more »

oil and gas pipeline
Energy Stocks

TC Energy Stock Is Starting to Get Ridiculously Oversold

TC Energy (TSX:TRP) stock is one of those deep-value dividend plays for the next decade and beyond.

Read more »

An analyst uses a computer and dashboard for data business analysis and Data Management System with KPI and metrics connected to the database for technology finance, operations, sales, marketing, and artificial intelligence.

Want to Get Richer? Here Are the 3 Best Stocks to Buy Now and Hold Forever

These three stocks all have fantastic operations and years of growth potential, making them three of the best to buy…

Read more »

Dividend Stocks

Income Stocks: A Once-in-a-Decade Chance to Get Rich

These two income stocks are among the best on the TSX for those seeking consistent total returns over a long-term…

Read more »